Sam Evans has been through a lot since graduating from McKinley, including becoming a single father. One day, his daughter, Heather, asks him to tell the story of her mother. The story quickly becomes a mystery. Will it be Mercedes, Quinn, or Santana?

Sam Evans is barely staying afloat at Dalton Academy. As he reaches edge of a breakdown, he meets Blaine. Can Sam put aside his own fears and accept Blaine's help? Sam's POV. Story Complete, Reviews still welcome.