Tony Award Winning Shelby Corcoran and her wife Cassandra have come home to Lima after a stint on Broadway. They open up a School of the Arts, wanting to give back to the next generation. Deep down, Shelby sees this as a chance to make peace with the loss of her daughter she was forced to give up as a unwed teenager. Fate brings a little girl to their studio one cold snowy night.

Every year on December 18th, Shelby Corcoran rides around aimlessly lost in thought, mourning the death of her baby girl. The little girl that three years ago she was supposed to give up for adoption. It hits midnight and Shelby runs into something she thought she lost forever

I have decided to rewrite Baby girl, I have you now. When 9 year old, Rachel Berry arrives in New York city after being abandoned by her father. She finds her mother, Broadway star Shelby Corcoran. Rachel has a secret, well she has many secrets. Can she trust her mom enough to tell her what has been happening and how will Shelby cope with the revelations?

11 year old Rachel Berry is dragged to Broadway by two strangers. She mets her mother and Shelby knows that something isn't right. Can Rachel trust Shelby? How will Shelby react when the parents of her baby weren't all they made out to be.

After one of the biggest regrets of her life, for Shelby Corcoran, things are looking up. She is starring in "Wicked". She's madly in love with Cassandra July and they now live as a committed couple. One night sitting in her dressing room, Shelby gets a visitor that with one sentence changes her life. The contract she signed as a surrogate has been revoked. Her baby girl is deaf.