Timmy is starting to hate it whenever Trixie Tang treats him like he is a loser. Luckily, there is someone (other than Tootie) who doesn't agree with Trixie. But Vicky's former babysitter and enemy has recruited Ricky to make Vicky feel even more miserable, prompting Timmy to recruit someone whom he was never friends with in the past, and that person is Amanda Killman.

Just a few hours after Timmy Turner saved Vicky's life when they were trapped in a cave, she randomly decides to move out of Dimmsdale. So Timmy goes to Hillwood, where he will meet Helga G. Pataki, and then, he will meet Hailey Drew, the twenty-five-year-old former babysitter who was responsible for turning Vicky into Icky Vicky.

It's a simple question, posed to the girls (and boys) of Dimmsdale and beyond. Read on to find out what their answers were, and decide for yourself who loves Timmy Turner the most. A series of oneshots.

What caused Vicky to become Icky Vicky? Was it really an evil bug inside her body, or the fact that the "Kindness" employee inside her mind had never shown up for work? Or maybe Vicky became so hateful, and cruel because she had the WORST childhood ever?