Dean is still fighting supernatural crime with Sam when a pretty young plot twist named Sophie Gardner shows up claiming to be Dean's 15-year-old daughter. As she worms her way into his heart, he comes to realize what exactly he's been missing, and how far he'll go to fix what's broken.

Twelve years after the death of their sister, Sam and Dean stumble upon a mysterious girl. There is not only a perfect resemblance between her and their dead sibling, but she has no idea who she really is. Is she really their sister, and together can they discover what really happened to their family all those years ago? And what part does she play in the coming apocalypse?

Complete! Sam and Dean investigate a cursed diner. As the hunt begins to hurt and affect both brothers, they will have to rely on each other for wisdom, determination, support, and survival. Sam angst, Dean angst. Hurt!Sam, Hurt!Dean, protective!both