On Sam's seventeenth birthday, he wishes for a normal life. Dean convinces John to let his sons settle down in South Dakota near Bobby for Sam's senior year of high school. Dean hopes to bring them all closer, but Sam's taste of freedom will change him.

After a fight with his brother, Sam finds himself in the past. Is it a Ghost of Christmas messing wtih him, or is something sinister at work? And what is it about the holidays that brings out the honesty in his brother? Followup to My Christmas Wish