The Ass Crack Bandit has returned to Greendale at a time of insecurity. City College has descended into chaos as opposition groups and a radical militant organization "Italian Ices" seek to unseat Dean Spreck. Greendale itself is in the midst of campaign season for student president, and is dealing with a backlash against City College transfer students.

A few months ago Jerry, Elaine, Kramer and George were released. Pendant Publishing offers to publish Elaine's experiences in jail. George is adapting to life outside prison. Jerry is dating his parole officer. And Kramer has found a way to be a part of a wealthy gated community.