Sequel to "Neverland Treasure". Peter Pan always gets what he wants and now he finally has Holly. Alone and outnumbered, Holly's only goal is to survive and learn as she goes. But Peter isn't patient, and the Lost Boys aren't gentle. Even her brother, John, isn't the same loving sibling she remembers. As Pan breaks her spirit, Holly wonders if she can endure.

The terms are simple: Give Peter what he wants, and him and the Lost Boys give the Never isles another year of peace. But when Peter catches a glimpse of Princess Holly, he decides he wants her all for himself. Her father denies him, and now Peter and the Lost Boys are wreaking havoc. Will Holly go with Pan? Or will she trust a certain pirate captain to help beat Pan for good?