Jack Frost and Toothiana are in a relationship, fulfilling their duties as Guardians and continuing to surprise each other in magical ways. Toothiana welcomes a new fairy into the fold, but there is something very different about this new arrival. What happens when the seemingly impossible becomes possible? References information in the books, but is not meant to be entirely loyal.

Every year North throws a party for all the Immortals who had been nice all year, and this year Jack Frost is allowed to come. However Jack did not come to the party for fruit cake and cookies, but to instead to see Tooth who had been haunting his dreams. Can Jack and Tooth survive the night while Santa and Sandy try to get them together? Rainbow Snowcone.