Three friends, one girl, and a bet. Toby and his friends, Andrew and Noel, are about to wrap up their senior year. But they want to end it with a big bang, so why not make a bet? Get Spencer Hastings in your bed before spring break vacation. Sounds easy enough, but when doors are opened and feelings emerge it becomes clear it's not just about winning. It's about falling in love.

Toby Cavanaugh's life was hell and not too many people knew. Drowning himself in women and alcohol. His therapist thought it was unhealthy the way he was living his life and blocking out the past. But he didn't want to relive anything that went on in his childhood home. He knew he was a lost cause and there was no hope for him until her. Spencer Hastings was going to give him hope.

Spencer was a wonderful liar. Lying was her only source of protection. No one knew about what happened behind closed door. She didn't want to cause anymore problems for her family and friends, so she just lied. Until him. Toby Cavanaugh made her feel safe for the first time in a long time. He saw through her facade. He saw the broken girl behind the lies and he found her heart.

SEQUEL: I Fell In Love With The Boy Next Door: Toby and Spencer are moving on with their lives. Everything seems great, but their worlds about to get hectic, again. They have big decisions to make for their futures. With them finishing up college, they have a lot of roadblocks turning in their lives. Can they work through their problems or is it all too much for the young couple?

AU-ish: Everyone's got a life that's a puzzle. Toby Cavanaugh never questioned the way his life was put together. He has everything he could want. What happens when he has a chance encounter with a girl? A girl that he never gave a second glance too. He a

Spencer Hastings and Toby Cavanaugh have been neighbors and the best of friends ever since the first night that Toby's family moved into the DiLaurentis' old house three years ago. Their senior year was starting for them and a new school year was not the only new thing. There were new feelings happening between them too. Can the friends make the transition to be more than friends?

Spencer was only supposed to be rebuilding the barn for her to live in until highschool was over, but she never expected to fall hard for her carpenter or have her life twisted upside down because of her decision to do so. AU-ish, first time fanfiction writer, reading it will be worth it because I'm going to put a lot of work and effort into it!