AU without A. Ali very purposely composed her group of Liars to include one who was smart, one who was loyal, one who was admiring, and one who was compassionate. But what if Spencer wasn't the Brain that Ali chose and went through life as one of Ali's prey? What happens when she strikes a deal with popular Toby to play a game of Pretend...? What happens when the game ends? Spoby.

"Since when does Spencer Hastings have to take her clothes off to get what she wants?" Spencer knew the game all too well. Guys only want one thing, right? It worked - until it didn't. Five years later, Spencer's a different woman juggling a job and single motherhood. Until she's trapped in an elevator with a past mistake who changed her life & their story is changed forever. Spoby

Spencer is married to Ian, who abuses her. She doesn't see a way out until she gets to know Toby Cavanaugh. What will Ian do, when he finds out about Toby? What will Toby and the girls do when they finally find out about Ian's abusive behaviour? - Rated strong T

Because some moments are left to the imagination. The missing moments of Spencer and Toby's love story, told in oneshots. Spoby.

Toby is familiar with the colors black and blue. He understands the true meaning of 'pain'. He faces it at school and at home, so he's no stranger to pain. Most of his life consisted of black and blue until she showed up. Bad summary hopefully the stories better. Rated T, may contain some minor violence and sexual content in future chapters.

The others started running away from the Cavanaugh's property and I was about to follow. But I heard screams from inside the garage, someone was in there. Before I could really think about what I was doing, I ran into the garage to try to save whoever was in there.

He's a well-known singer/songwriter/and guitarist. He has millions of fans. She is a school girl in high school. Her friends are huge fans of Air Toby, she's not. When Toby decides to take a break from his world tour to go back to high school, these two meet. Will Spencer end up falling for this guitarist, or will her fear of getting hurt keep her away? Bad Summary, but hopefully t

Spencer never thought her life was exciting or meaningful. At a party with her friend, Hanna, one night: everything changes after she meets a mysterious young man that catches her attention from across the room...

Tobias Cavanaugh is a wanted criminal on the run. He breaks out of jail, changes his name, and runs away. He ends up hiding out in a small town called Rosewood. Spencer is a part time waitress as a local diner in Rosewood. The two meet and it turns his world upside down. Will Spencer be able to change this bad boy or will he always be a cold heart criminal? Is he willing to change?

"She turned to look at him after a moment, and Toby struggled to decipher the look in her eyes. Gratitude, he thought suddenly – gratitude, and awe, and more gratitude." Spencer and Toby. Oneshot.

"How is it even possible that he managed to destroy in a few weeks what he'd spent the last year and a half building up?" Spencer and Toby. Based off of 5x24 and 5x25. Oneshot.

After 17 year old Spencer Hastings unknowingly befriends and begins a small affair with a married cop she tries to find both who she is as a person and what it really means to be close to someone.

"It dawned on him that she doesn't know what happy feels like, or what it feels to be safe or loved. She just knows what sad feels like, and hurt, and hated. But in only the twenty four hours that he's actually seen her out of school, he can tell that she's special. She's more than the broken girl everyone sees. And he's going to fix what he can. He has to." Spencer/Toby

Set after Season 3 Episode 16: What I thought could have happened. Spencer struggles to overcome the pain Toby brought on her by joining the A team, and travels down a road leading to darkness. However, with the help of her friends, will she be able to overcome it and become herself again? Or will she be overcome by the darkness? Spemily, Trigger warnings, Language, Dark themes.

Spencer makes a confession to Toby that could change everything for better or for worse and causes them to think about how they want to start their future. One-shot. Spencer, Toby and spousal privilege.

Nothing has been the same since Toby started working as a police officer, and Spencer knows it. With more stress on their relationship, everything seems to be falling apart. And when a new guy comes to town and immediately falls for Spencer, both of them need to realize their mistakes before everything crashes. (POST 5x15)

After Toby walks away from her, instead of going home, Spencer follows a dark hooded figure into an alley, wanting to end the whole thing. But when A takes it too far, harms Spencer in disgusting ways, will the end be in sight? Will her friends, will Toby be able to help hold her together? Spoby centric story. Contains content triggering for some, please read at own risk.

Spencer and Toby have been broken up for 4 years. Now, Spencer is back from college and Toby has mixed emotions. Will they destroy each other? Or will they fall in love all over again? Maybe they never stopped loving each other at all...

A continuation of Spencer and Toby in 5x15. (because honestly, how can you leave Spencer Hastings crying in the street?)

When Spencer goes on vacation she meets Toby, an older boy that will move to Rosewood, they start dating and Toby give Spencer something she haven't felt for forever. Happiness. A Spoby story, a little Haleb and Ezria

Spencer is completely lost in life. Toby has his life together, he has everything in order and everything he could ever want. What happens when they meet? Spencer finds herself healing because of him. But Toby gets the exact opposite, she ruins him. Please read to find out more. Bad summary I apologize.

Toby has a girlfriend, and Spencer has a boyfriend... Their friendship soon leads to an eventful night that changes their relationships. How will they deal with their lovers while they have a secret? And what if Spencer and Toby WANT to be together?

AU. After an almost fatal accident, Spencer is unable to remember the time she's spent with Toby and the love she feels for him. Will his love prevail and bring back her memory, or will Toby have to face the possibility that he's lost her forever? Spoby.

Spencer Hastings has never believed in fate, true love or soul mates, but one night she meets a handsome stranger and everything she believed in starts to change.

This is the story of a broken girl and the boy who falls for her. [AU Spoby.] *ON HIATUS, NOT YET COMPLETE BUT WILL BE EVENTUALLY*

Toby meets Spencer when his daughter is assigned to her kindergarten class...

Starts the summer before The Jenna Thing... what if Spencer and Toby had met in a different way? What if they were together BEFORE The Jenna Thing/Ali went missing? With Alison's murder unsolved, Jenna blind, and the girls being buried under secrets and lies that A tortures them with, can true love really conquer all? Spoby. Multichapter. COMPLETE.

As one of PA's top lawyers, Spencer's firm doesn't want her to taunt her reputation by taking on a sketchy client who's the number one suspect in a murder investigation. Contrary to what everyone in Rosewood thinks and the evidence mounting up against him, Spencer thinks otherwise. Maybe it's the magnetic force enchanting her feelings towards him like... When opposites attract.

It wasn't until a random Wednesday three weeks before the end of her junior year that everything changed.