AU without A. Ali very purposely composed her group of Liars to include one who was smart, one who was loyal, one who was admiring, and one who was compassionate. But what if Spencer wasn't the Brain that Ali chose and went through life as one of Ali's prey? What happens when she strikes a deal with popular Toby to play a game of Pretend...? What happens when the game ends? Spoby.

She presses her finger up to her lips and tells you to be quite. Tell nobody that you saw her here. She kisses you goodbye and that's the last time you saw her. Many years pass and some force brings you back together, but not in a way you thought it would. This is not the girl you used to know. FULL SUMMARY INSIDE

Spencer is a single-mother trying to take care of her four-year-old daughter. Spencer and her daughter are at a bank when three robbers run in. Toby is single trying to make a living as a cop. He gets called on to the scene of a robbery. What will Toby do in order save a poor, young woman and her daughter?

Three friends, one girl, and a bet. Toby and his friends, Andrew and Noel, are about to wrap up their senior year. But they want to end it with a big bang, so why not make a bet? Get Spencer Hastings in your bed before spring break vacation. Sounds easy enough, but when doors are opened and feelings emerge it becomes clear it's not just about winning. It's about falling in love.

Toby is familiar with the colors black and blue. He understands the true meaning of 'pain'. He faces it at school and at home, so he's no stranger to pain. Most of his life consisted of black and blue until she showed up. Bad summary hopefully the stories better. Rated T, may contain some minor violence and sexual content in future chapters.

He's a well-known singer/songwriter/and guitarist. He has millions of fans. She is a school girl in high school. Her friends are huge fans of Air Toby, she's not. When Toby decides to take a break from his world tour to go back to high school, these two meet. Will Spencer end up falling for this guitarist, or will her fear of getting hurt keep her away? Bad Summary, but hopefully t

Toby Cavanaugh's life was hell and not too many people knew. Drowning himself in women and alcohol. His therapist thought it was unhealthy the way he was living his life and blocking out the past. But he didn't want to relive anything that went on in his childhood home. He knew he was a lost cause and there was no hope for him until her. Spencer Hastings was going to give him hope.

You can bring lightness into the dark just by lighting a candle. Lighting someone else's candle won't make yours go out, it just makes more light. Toby and Spencer find light in one another. AU without A, Ali is really dead. Ian tried to kill Spencer in the Bell Tower because she knew he killed Ali, and she thinks Toby saved her. The first of many sparks. Spoby love story.

Toby Cavanaugh's been nothing but trouble lately. He's been using guns, hanging out with his gang, and going against the wishes of his parents. When his parents are fed up, they send him to a school program that steers students straight by giving them a good influencing guide. What happens when Spencer Hastings is his guide? They may have to spend a little too much time together...