Spencer always hated her sister but she had Toby. Then Toby does the unforgivable by sleeping with her sister. She finds out Aria knew all along but never said a word about it. She and Mike are both alone on Christmas and Spencer plans to get revenge on Aria by sleeping with Mike. However, she realizes quickly that she is falling for him. Will they make it?

Spencer finally returns home, with a mission to destroy those who once took away her childhood and destroyed her life. Can love help her to forget and forgive, or will she head down the stony path of revenge? Spencer/Toby, Hanna/Toby friendship, AU, rated M for future chapters.