Riley is now in her freshman year of high school and it seems like nothing has changed, but has it? Riley finally breaks and ends somewhere she never thought she'd be. (T for suicidal tendencies)

Sequel to Please Don't Leave Me / Maya kept a secret diary where she had written in during and after she was kidnapped the previous year. When the diary is stolen, the anonymous culprit learns the Matthews' strengths and weaknesses and it's only a matter of time before the family realizes that all of the problems they faced were not over as they had thought they were.