At the moment of final death, Tigerstar is given a second chance at life. He is thrown back in time to the moment that started it all- Redtail's murder. With the knowledge of his entire first life and his time in the Dark Forest, Tigerstar has a decision to make. Will he right his wrongs or take the chance to rule the forest once again?

The day before Bluefur gives up her kits, she changes her mind and decides to raise them as her own. But as time goes on and Thistleclaw becomes leader, Bluefur realizes that her choice may have sent ThunderClan on the path to its downfall.