Nathan's life is falling apart slowly. Haley can't seem to let it go. What happens when your partner won't stop digging into your past? Nathan never wanted her to know the truth but she just had to keep looking. AU

Haley James had the perfect life. Just starting her junior year at Duke everything’s about to be turned upside down. She never thought that this would happen to her. But here she was in love with two different men. Naley!