While working a case at a couples resort in Vermont, you enlist the help of the Winchesters to get yourself inside. But when you and Sam find yourselves having to go undercover as a married couple, long-buried feelings arise and make for an uncomfortable situation. Cue sexual tension, slow build, and eventual smut.

Dean and Sam have a little sister named Melanie. One night the three Winchesters and Castiel drive out to a hunt, but only Dean and Sam go in. Alone together in the impala, Castiel and Melanie find themselves playing 20 Questions to kill the time and the awkwardness, but soon enough, the game leads to an unexpected turn...