Maya is in her last year of college and has been given the internship of a lifetime. Suddenly, Joshua Matthews is back in her life. Now that they're older, will anything be different? Eventual Joshaya.

When the school dance comes up, Riley finally has a date while Maya is left all alone. Determined to prove that love is worth it, Riley decides to find Maya her prince. But it turns out, love isn't as simple as Riley thinks it is. Meanwhile, Maya plans to stay away from boys but when Uncle Josh comes to visit, Maya's feelings resurface for more trouble. Will true love prevail?