On Bonnie's 19th birthday, she makes a subconscious wish to alter her life's circumstances so everyone she loved could just be safe. But when she's given the chance to start over, it all comes down in an avalanche of unusual emotions and broken memories, especially when she finds that everyone she loves is Damon Salvatore.

Klaus claims Bonnie as she's the only person left who can kill him. He seeks to destroy the remains of the White Oak tree with Bonnie by his side. Bonnie plots to kill him in the midst of the search, both rivaling with newly-bloomed, foreign feelings.