Max and Kate have been speaking to each other for two years. Meeting online, they wanted to keep their identities, face and name, a secret until they met in real life. But, Max has moved to Blackwell Academy, where Kate just happens to be. With knowing everything yet nothing, both wonder why they find each other so familiar. Marshfield. Rated T for language.

The story takes place right at the end of episode 5. Max chose to sacrifice Chloe in order to save Arcadia Bay. But what if Max couldn't do it? What if she found a way to save her best friend and Arcadia Bay? What would change or what wouldn't change?

Set after the death of William Price, Max is convinced it's her fault. She comes to realise maybe the best thing she can do for Chloe is something she never thought she'd have to do.