Erik and Christine share a lovely night together in the dark, but instead of leaving, he invites her on the ship with him. When Christine finds out she's pregnant, and when the baby is born, chaos starts slowly.

What happened if Christine accepted the Phantom's proposal when they were on stage? They start a new life together and have a child but will Raoul set out to ruin their happiness or can they live together whereby Love Never Dies? I would like to thank CLASSICDUH for giving me the idea for this story :) Hope you like it :D

An alternate LND - Christine couldn't help but return; she'd shattered his heart, any pain he'd endured was down to her. But what was supposed to be one night of passion ends in life-long consequences...

He'd waited years for this moment, to wake up and see his angel of music, Christine Daae, lying next to him. A happy woman lying next to him, deeply in love with the man behind the mask. But what if a not-so-happy fiancee was out to catch them and end the Phantoms life once and for all? Takes place after the night beneath a moonless sky, with the Phantom choosing to stay with her.