Mary chose the BMoL and this time Sam is the one who suffers. They were right not to trust the Brits. Can Dean forgive his family and save his brother before the end or will Lucifer burn his old rival in the Church of St. John? In which Dean questions everything he ever held as gospel truth and everyone he ever loved to make his way to the person he loves most of all the worlds.

Characters read TheRiverScribe's By the Grace of God. Sam was God's gift to the world but he was broken. He was shattered, his soul shredded. And even though his soul had been healed, there was still a lot of healing left. So God decided to speed things up-by reading their book. Healing is hard and slow and painful, full of regrets and guilt, but it is possible, even for Sam.