Spencer Hastings has been in love with Toby Cavanaugh ever since the Jenna-search. Since then, the two of them have been a couple. For months, the two were a couple. Yet at the same time, Spencer was battling an unknown 'A'. Or was she..? Spencer starts out by stealing Malcolm from Aria, and brings him to the carnival, but what more will she do to be with Toby? To satisfy herself?