When Elphaba accidentally casts a spell to save Fiyero's life, the spell misfires and hurls her back in time to the catacombs beneath the ruins of the Paris Opera House. There she meets the Phantom of the Opera. Together, in the darkness of the night, they'll mend each other's broken hearts. But can two people, hated by society and shunned by their outward appearance find love?

It is the first anniversary of Elsa's coronation, and the queen is, at best, unenthusiastic. That is, until a mysterious prince in green catches her eye across the ballroom. By then, she is simply unimpressed.