I just started watching anime 3 years ago and so far I've watched:

Black Butler,

School Days,

Kotoura-san,

Maid-Sama,

Heaven's Lost Property,

Mayo Chiki,

KissxSis,

Angel Beats,

My Hero Academia,

Sankarea,

Rosario Vampire,

Tsuritama,

Sekirei,

B gata H kei,

Chobits,

Death Note,

Un-Go,

Welcome to the NHK,

Seikon No Qwaser,

Say "I love you",

Attack on Titan,

My Little Monster,

Boku No Pico,

Deadman Wonderland,

Your Lie In April,

Kimi Ni Todoke: From Me To You,

Anohana: The Flower We Saw That Day,

Highschool Of the Dead,

Toyko Ghoul,

Kotoura-San,

Order A Rabbit,

Blue Spring Ride,

Oreimo,

Nana,

Silver Spoon,

Soul Eater,

Mirrai Nikki,

Durarara!!

and Itazura Na Kiss.

I love anime so much, but I'm having trouble finding good ones to watch (I'm picky). If you have any suggestions PM me