During a fight Toby wishes Sarah into Underground. Still angry at her he refuses to try his luck in the labyrinth. This leaves Sarah trapped in Underground forever. However this is not the end to Sarah's woe. After a visit from Jareth's sister, she discovers there may be something about her that Jareth is keeping a secret.

From the moment Sarah left the Labyrinth, Jareth knew he needed to get her back. He didn't know what human love was, but he knew he would die without her. Karen knew it too.

Fifteen years after Sarah's run through the Labyrinth, her niece is wished away to the goblins. To earn the child's freedom, Sarah has no other choice but to make a trade with Jareth.

Ten years have gone by since events in the Labyrinth. Sarah's life has taken a turn for the worse, and Jareth is tormented by memories of her. All is not as it may seem in the Aboveground, or the Underground...

It's been four years since Sarah conquered the Labyrinth and the newly graduated senior finds that no matter how hard she's tried, she can't seem to forget her friends or the man that's been haunting her dreams ever since she came back. Will her need to see him again overcome her fear of what will happen if she returns to the Labyrinth?

Gothel escapes with Rapunzel after she heals Eugene, and the two head to Narnia, where the Kings and Queens are ruling over Narnia during attacks by an unknown force.