Before his fifth year Harry wakes and finds himself in a world where his parents are spared by Voldemort and he has the family he always wanted. But stuck between the new world and his own where both need him, Harry is left with an impossible choice. Which world should he stay in?

What if Voldemort wasn't defeated that fateful night? And no, it wasn't because Harry had died or anything, it was a bit more simple: Sirius was being his usual hot-headed self, and somehow convinced the Lily to let him take Harry out trick-or-treating.