Waverly Earp is a freshman in college, while Nicole Haught is a junior. Both come from different words and neither have ever met someone like each other. Nicole is an openly out criminal justice major who plays lacrosse and Waverly is a closeted bisexual history major who cheers. What happens when the pair meet up randomly at a party?

All Waverly wants is a happy Christmas with her family and maybe, maybe she'll get it.