(Sequel to Lurking in the Shadows) Its been about three weeks since Jack was found, and now he's back. But with the atmosphere becoming thick with tension after some portraying dream, an unexpected surprise comes. Anti and Dark have a little friend on their side, and a plan for sweet revenge. (No Youtuber Shipping besides MarziaXFelix)

Jacksepticeye gives a surprise visit to Markiplier, though more than just fun will ensue. A few nights in, Jack vanishes, and something best kept hidden arises. (Bad Summary DX) (Second Title Change)

Jacksepticeye, Markiplier, and Pewdiepie find themselves fighting for their survival against their alter-egos, Antisepticeye, Darkiplier and Pewdenheimer. They acquire special powers and some friends along the way to help fight the evil that is trying to take over the bodies and destroy the weak. Will they win? Or will their worst nightmares prevail? (No Septiplier or Jelix)

Anti sees Sean's Halloween Shenanigans and is not happy. He devises a plan to rid himself of his problems. His problems being Sean and Dark. There is a problem with his plans though. Dark doesn't want to be rid of Anti. He, himself, will go to a few lengths to make sure of that. Poor Mark and Sean just want to live while trying to hide their feelings for each other.