All right, let's get started on this! And just a heads-up, we're about to reach the turning point of the story! So hang back and relax!

Mr. Sawyer gave a casual hum to himself as he was driving all the way back to his lovely home. Sure, it wasn't much, but he liked to call it home. He looked back with the mirror as he was about a few miles away from the train station. He knew it was a little hard, saying good-bye to one of his little girls before she departed back to her mother, but it was nice of her to visit while it lasted. He just hoped Lila and he weren't out of the city this year. That was one problem when it came to getting new addresses, every time he and Lila had to move to a new place, he always had to send his ex and his daughter the new address.

As the man started to drive, he heard the loud wailing of sirens nearby. He slowed down and went to the side of the road to let them pass. Mr. Sawyer watched as a few police cars started to run past... but then his eyes widened as his eyes caught something strange... his little girl, Lila? Was sitting in the back of a police car? It couldn't be... could it?

Looking concerned, he started to swerve into a U-turn as he followed the cars, wondering what was going on... and it was there and then that he noticed that they were heading and stopping right at the train station. His eyes shrank as he muttered, "Oh no... Lulu's not... she wouldn't dare... her mother promised she wouldn't... no..."

The minute Lila said that sentence, all of Arnold's motions had stopped. His hand stopped tugging at the skirt, Arnold's other hand stopped rubbing Lila's breast, and even his brain had caught on to what he just said. Arnold slowly blinked in shock as he said, in a confused voice, "Wh-what? Lulu, what are you-"

As Arnold retracted his hands away from "Lulu", Lila sighed as she tried to explain, "Oh, Arnold, you're ever so wonderful, and you deserve a lot of happiness in your life, but... I was actually seeing your cousin. I know I said I didn't know him... but I did! He lives in the same town as me, we go to the same school together, we've even been dating for the last few months!" Lila paused. "When I saw you, I was... well... reminded of Arnie, and... and... I'm sorry. I've been using you to cheat on him."

Arnold's mouth dropped in wide-eyed horror as on his shoulders, Arnold's devil stared flabbergasted, looking like he was about to sputter. Arnold's angel, on the other hand, looked very elated as the horns on his head was slowly retracting back. Arnold's angel laughed as he pumped his fist. "YES! YES! I knew it!"

"Our boy... was just a pawn...?" Arnold's shoulder devil said as he tried to pound his head. "No... no it can't be true!"

"It HAS to be true!" Arnold's angel laughed. "There's only two things that we would never hurt, devil boy! Our friendships, AND close family! Arnie's close family, and if he ever found out we hurt him..."

"No, no, no, it can't be true, it just can't!" Arnold's devil looked like he was going to breakdown.

"Face it, reddy, if Lulu actually confessed to this, then I was justified in being right about her! Nothing more than a slink!" Arnold's angel grinned.

"There's a catch! There has to be a catch!" The devil said in concern.

Arnold wasn't paying attention to the antics of his invisible shoulder angel and demon as he looked straight at "Lulu"'s face, trying to process what she was saying. "But... all those times we spent together... the sleepover, the time on Lila's bed, the island."

"It wasn't real, I-" Lila started, before stopping. "Wait, what was that about my- er, Lila's bed?"

Arnold felt terribly confused as he stared at his "girlfriend", but before he could answer...

SLAM!

"Everybody, hands up in the air! Don't move an inch!"

Arnold and Lila jumped in confusion as they saw a number of police officers running in. Lila looked confused, but held her hands up as did Arnold, who was looking terribly confused by the events of which was going on.

Before Lila could wonder what was going on, she heard a very familiar sounding voice.

"THERE THEY ARE! THERE'S MY HORRIBLE SISTER TRYING TO TAKE AWAY ARNOLD!"

"Huh?" Lila asked as she turned to see that, in her own clothing, was a sobbing Lulu, pretending to be horrified. "Wait, what's going-"

"Lila?" Arnold asked as he noted the sobbing Lulu standing next to the police.

"Lila!?" Lila said in confusion, but not before one of the officers grabbed the red haired girl's hands.

"All right, you're under arrest young lady, for sexual harassment and kidnapping." The officer growled as Lila was being held.

"Wait, what's going on?" Lila asked in confusion.

"Nice try, Miss Lulu, but your days of kidnapping young boys is over." The officer said as Arnold was looking more confused.

"What the- what do you mean, kidnapping?" Arnold asked in confusion.

"It's okay, Arnold, everything's going to be okay." Lulu said as she started to go over to Arnold, about to engulf him in a hug.

Lila, on the other hand, shook her head as she called out, "Wait a minute, you got it all wrong! I'm not Lulu, I'm Lila! The girl going over to Arnold is MY sister! I don't know what she did, but if it's something bad, I didn't do it, I swear!"

The officer frowned as he looked at Lila in doubt, before turning to Lulu. "Miss Sawyer, can you confirm you are you?"

"Lila", giving a smirk, turned to the officer as she tilted her head. "Gosh, Mr. Officer, of course I'm the real Lila. And you're ever so wonderful for apprehending my criminal sister."

"Lulu" stared in horror as she called out, "NO! I'm LILA! I came over to save Arnold from a big mistake!"

Arnold's shoulder angel and demon looked over in surprise as Arnold's devil gave a large smirk. "Oh ho! What an interesting development. Lila was attempting to throw us off!"

"Wh-what?" Arnold's shoulder angel said in shock as she turned to his shoulder devil. "Did you not just hear her say that she was trying to save Arnold from hurting his own cousin?"

"Yeah, I heard it, but..." Arnold's shoulder devil shook his head. "Are we REALLY going to be taking her word? Heck, maybe we should save Lulu and speak up for her!"

"Are you insane?" Arnold's shoulder angel argued with a glare. "Lila went through all this trouble to save our lives, and if Lulu really IS some sort of criminal... then obviously we have to save her!"

"Guys, please..." Arnold whispered, getting a little frustrated with the antics.

"Please, you got to believe me!" Lila begged as she was being cuffed, sobbing for her life.

"I thought you were a trustworthy twin sister, LULU." Lulu said as she glared at Lila. "I guess I was wrong about you."

The officer paused as he looked between the cuffed Lila and the free Lulu, as he started thinking. "Ugh, this would be so much easier if we knew which one is which?"

"I can tell you! The girl standing next to you is Lulu!" Lila begged as she eyed her sister.

"She's hysterical, she just wants Arnold for herself!" Lulu said in a mortified manner.

"Lulu!" Arnold's shoulder devil exclaimed.

"LILA!" Arnold's shoulder angel exclaimed.

The noise that everyone was making was starting to get on Arnold's nerves... in fact, they were practically shot as his emotions were all over the place, he didn't know what was right and wrong anymore... all he knew was that whatever was about to happen... it would affect everyone's lives forever. Finally, when he couldn't take the arguing anymore... he let out a loud yell.

"SHUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUT UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUP!"

Everything immediately went silent as Arnold's shoulder angel and shoulder devil looked at the boy in shock... the officers looked in shock, and even Lila and Lulu were surprised at the angry voice he provided. Arnold took a deep breath as he gave a sigh, "Listen up... all of you, please... listen up. I don't understand what's happening, but I do know that... there are two girls that look the same, sound the same, and maybe even think the same. There may not be any difference to you guys... but there may be one way to know. If I can have both the twins come over to me, please."

Lila and Lulu looked at each other as the officer uncuffed Lila. The girls gave a nod as both of them approached Arnold, slowly, but surely.

"Thank you." Arnold said as he looked between the two. "Now, I'm about to ask for a very unusual request, and you have to do that request, even if it sounds... disgusting in your minds... but..."

Lila and Lulu looked confused as Arnold said, "I want both of you to turn around... bend over... and..." Arnold groaned in embarrassment. "Lift up your skirts."

Lila's eyes widened in horror, as did Lulu's (even though she knew she had to pretend) as Lulu said, "Oh my..."

"I-I couldn't do that-" Lila started.

"We may not have much of a choice. One of you told me something earlier that I can probably easily distinguish who you girls are... and if I'm right... then I can point to the real criminal."

Lulu's eyes secretly lit up as Lila blushed in embarrassment. "But- we couldn't..."

"Let's just get it over with. We're not getting anywhere with this." Lulu rolled her eyes as she turned around.

"B-bu-" Lila started as she sighed and turned around. The officers watched as both girls bent over and lifted their skirts up, both their eyes shutting.

Arnold looked under both skirts as he noted the panties. One girl was wearing white panties, and the other girl was wearing... panties that were green with blue stripes.

Arnold's devil grinned as he pointed to Lila, who was in the Lulu dress, but had the white panties. "Well, I guess that proves one thing. Lila was trying to deceive us away from OUR Lulu!"

"Or... she may have been trying to save our lives!" Arnold's shoulder angel frowned as he pointed to Lulu, in Lila's clothing, but had the green panties with blue stripes. "If the police are here for Lulu, then she's the one they want."

Arnold's shoulder devil groaned as he held his head. "Ugh... what are we going to do? I want Arnold to be happy..."

"Well, so do I." Arnold's shoulder angel said. "But if we make a mistake, we may have to live with that for the rest of our lives!"

"Ugh..." Arnold's shoulder devil groaned as he turned to Arnold, who was looking thoughtful. "Well, kid, we leave it to you..."

"Arnold... whatever you choose... we hope you can live with the choices..." Arnold's shoulder angel said as the football headed boy looked between the panties of Lulu and Lila, as he bit his lip.

And with that... we're going to be at a good stopping point! And as promised, I'm going to make TWO endings for this story, one good and one bad! I'm going to focus on the good ending first, just so we can have that taken care of, then we'll get to the bad ending! Anyway, it might be a while, but stick around. If you want some details on both endings, feel free to PM me with some questions! Tune in next time!