A/N: I'm back again! I have so many plans with this sequel and unlike my other fanfic, I'm still working on it, so please don't be disappointed that I can't upload many chapters at once anymore. Like my previous story, it won't be completely AU because I don't want to rewrite the whole series, but I will change a few things (like Finn's death, he probably won't die because that totally sucked). I hope you will like it...
Anyways, enjoy!
Disclaimer: I still don't own anthing.
Chapter 1
Previously on "Mermaids Don't exist!":
"[...]Him and Blaine are always heading to the beach and then they just disappear to god know where!" [...]"Are you talking about that weird behavior of my white boy? God, I thought I was the only one noticing it. Since that sleepover back then, I noticed that something is very wrong with boo"[...] "Artie and I created a dope app where you can track down all of your friends' phones in no time, without them noticing."[...]"According to my laptop, Kurt and Blaine are both on that island where we did that midnight hiking last year."[...] "Gather your stuff, we're heading to that island your stuff, we're heading to that island again."[...]""Santana? Rachel, Mercedes, Finn, Puck, Artie and Mike are going to a rescue mission to find Kurtsie and his hobbit boyfriend. Can we join them?"[...]"I want answers, and I want them now! We didn't get them when the New Direction gang and I were freaking stalking you yesterday and fell into that creepy, blue lake! I'm beyond pissed because of that!"[...]And when all of the New Directions fell into the moon pool, then they will be affected too!" [...] "What do you wanna say, Hobbit, that I'm a mermaid now?!" "…well, probably?" [...] "Oh, shut the fuck up you two! I can't believe you're not man enough to tell me the fucking truth! I hate lies more than everything AND I'M SO GONNA GO ALL LIMA HEIGHTS ADJACENT ON YOUR ASSES RIGHT N-[...] AY DIOS MIO! Where the heck ARE MY LEGS?! I CAN'T FEEL MY LEGS! LADY LIPS?! HOBBIT?!", Santana screamed as she horrifiedly stared at her newly acquired tailfin which was shimmering bright orange. Kurt and Blaine once again exchanged worried glances. [...] "Oh my gosh, Santana, you are a mermaid! Are you related to Ariel the mermaid? That's soo cool! Why didn't you tell me?", Brittany squealed delightedly. The newly turned mermaid struggled to stay afloat with her new body part. "Not now Britt, I'm kind of freaking out right now! I turned into a freaking fish!"
-Now-
"So, Santana… you believe us now? Mermaids do exist!", Kurt smirked. " Shut up and help me out of the water!", Santana screeched desperately. "Ehmmm…" The boys didn't move. Santana rolled her eyes. "What are you two waiting for? Man up and help me for God's sake!" "I will help you, San!", Brittany offered. "NO! Don't touch her, Brittany!", Kurt and Blaine shouted in unison. Santana shook her head. "Are you two OUT OF YOUR FUCKING MINDS?!" "You see, we can't get wet or we will all grow tails…", Blaine explained. "The heck?!"
"Wait, Blaine. Can I dry her?", Kurt asked after they somehow got Santana out of the water. "Do you remember what happened when you tried to dry the towel with your new powers? You burned it down!", Blaine reminded him and smiled at the memory. "Wait WHAT?! You never mentioned you got powers! Don't dare to even burn one tiny scale of mine, Porcelain, do you understand? I can't believe I just said that…" Santana shook her head. How was it possible her life went from normal to this within some minutes? "Let me handle it." Blaine carefully kneeled down and used his powers to dry off Santana's tail. "We still have to figure out why we suddenly have all these powers. We were about to, but then a certain person disturbed us -" "- Hold up. If you two have powers, what about the rest of us? Oh my gosh, how the hell did you get me my legs back, Blaine Warbler?! I want an explanation for all this shit, and I want it now!", Santana gasped as her legs reappeared. "Alright, Blaine can make things hot or even burn them down and turn invisible, I can freeze things and manipulate water. But since today, we acquired more powers without knowing why. Are you happy now, Satan?" "No, you didn't answer whether…wait…where is Britt? I haven't heard or seen her for I while now!", Santana wondered. Suddenly, they heard a splash and Brittany surfaced. "That was so cool! Have you seen my tailfin, Santana? Can we show Quinn and the others?", Brittany asked excitedly while swimming to the shallow water, showing off her shiny yellow tail. "Britt! Where were you? And why did you turn into a mermaid?", Santana wanted to know. "I accidently touched a wet rock when I was about to pet a seagull, then a felt a tingling sensation on my legs and fell into the water because I couldn't stand anymore. My fin glittered underwater and I went swimming with the fishies and even with a dolphin, that was a lot of fun! I was gone for about ten minutes and I didn't even need to come up for air!", Brittany beamed. "Stop joking around, Britt. Don't tell me you spent ten minutes underwater without needing to breathe! Last time you tried to hold your breath; you gave up after twenty seconds." Blaine shook his head. "She isn't lying, Santana. Kurt once spent more than six hours trapped in a pool and he didn't drown." Santana's eyes went wide. "Shut up! So Britt here is telling the truth?" "I mean we never really tried, but theoretically, we could spend half a day underwater.", Blaine theorized. "That's…that's…" Santana was at a loss of words. "Great, right? Being a merperson definitely has its perks. But it also has its price. We can't touch water without growing a tail, which is really inconvenient considering that we are surrounded by wet things constantly. Kurt and I needed to get used to that." "That's why Hummel's face was so unusually dry some months ago! And you, Anderson, stopped using hair gel for a while!", Santana reasoned. Kurt shrugged. "I will never know how Blaine applies hair gel without getting wet. Concerning my skin care routine, I continued doing that after a while. I don't care if I have to lie on my bed with my tail for hours until my face is dry again and risk getting caught by Finn or my parents, but my skin is one of my most precious things in my life!" "Alright, alright. What about the other guys? Shouldn't we warn them before they get the shocks of their lives after they turn into Ariels?", Santana asked. Blaine nodded. "Great idea, Santana! Let's head back to the hotel before they get the shocks of their lives"
Later that day, the ND's were gathered in Santana's and Brittany's spacious hotel room after Kurt sent an emergency text into the ND's What's App group. "What are we doing here, guys?", Tina asked and sat down on the king size bed. Kurt cleared his throat. "Santana and Brittany told us that you were stalking us yesterday. Blaine and I had a date and you disturbed us!" "You were the people with that picnic, right? But why did you have a date there?", Rachel wanted to know. "Because that was the place where our lives changed forever.", Blaine answered. Quinn groaned. "What do you mean by that? Just spit it out, I don't have time for that nonsense." "Did anyone of you notice some…weird things happening?", Kurt asked carefully. The others all went unusually quiet, avoiding each other's glances. Kurt cocked one eyebrow. So they all must have experienced the same thing. He exchanged a questioning glance with Blaine, who just nodded. Apparently, his boyfriend must've had the same thought. Eventually, Brittany broke the ice. "I did! I turned that water in that vase into jelly!", she deadpanned. Quinn turned to Brittany. "Wait, Britt, you did what?" "I don't know how I did it, but that is awesome! And Quinn, did I mention that Santana and I turned into mermaids?" "Britt! We shouldn't just break the news to them like that!", Santana said. Quinn shook her head. "Okay, that's it! I'm leaving now, you'll find me in the spa section of the resort. Talk to me if you are sane again." "Quinn, wait! Spa means water, right?", Blaine asked her. "You can't be around water like that, it's dangerous!", Kurt added. "Oh my gosh, I can't believe it! You are all starting to talk like Brittany, what's going on with you? THE HECK? Satan, why did you just splash me with your coke?!", Quinn screamed exasperatedly. Santana shrugged. "Sorry, Porcelain and Hobbit, couldn't wait any longer. Three, two, one…" Quinn cocked one eyebrow. "Why are you counting, Lopez?" Santana started smirking. "Showdown!" As if on cue, Quinn suddenly fell to the floor. The others gasped and Quinn's eyes went wide. "HOLY CRAP! What just happened to me?!", Quinn screamed as she stared down her soft red tail. Santana snorted with laughter. "That's too hilarious! Did you feel like that too when you turned me into a fish, Klaine?" Kurt shook his head. "I can't believe you find joy in others misfortune, but I shouldn't be surprised, Satan. Here, let me help you.", he said to Quinn, kneeling down next to her and balling his right hand into a fist and Quinn's tail started to get dryer. Blaine apprehensively looked down at them. "You are sure you can handle your powers, Kurt? I don't want you to hurt Quinn!" "I have to learn it eventually so why not start now?", Kurt answered. Quinn gaped at Kurt. "Wait, what? Powers? What are you doing? It's so hot…How is that possible? And why are my legs back now?", she asked, as she wiggled her toes. "We know you must have a lot of questions, that's why we invited some old friends to help us out.", Blaine said. There was a knock on the door and when Santana went to open the door, three middle aged women entered. Kurt hugged each one. "I'm so grateful you made it to this place that quickly!", he said. "I have my own advertising firm, Kurt darling, that means I also have my own jet.", Pamela laughed and clapped her hands. "Okay, kids, focus! I'm Pamela, and my friends over here are Gwen and Alice and we will give you a crash course on how to be a merperson." Finn started laughing. "You must be kidding, right? Did Kurt and Blaine pay you to be part of their prank or something? I have never heard of those friends of yours." Kurt glared at his stepbrother. "That's because they were my mom's best friends, Finn. They didn't make it to the wedding back then, so you probably see them for the first time." "And are you two also…mermaids?" Mercedes asked hesitantly. Pamela cocked one perfectly shaped eyebrow. "What do you think, Mercedes?" "And how do you know my name?" "We wanted to make sure Kurt has good friends, so we checked the backstories of everyone who befriended him. We know everything about you, and we won't hesitate to use that knowledge against you if necessary. But you know, we don't want to hurt you." Alice reassured the group. "It's the opposite: we are here to help you because your lives just got more complicated. From now on, every time you touch water, the same thing that happened to Quinn will happen to you. We kept that secret for generations, for centuries, now it's your turn to share a secret like that. But don't worry, we will help you through the first days, and after your holiday, you are in control of your powers-""-Whoa wait. We also have powers? Like, real powers?", Mike interrupted Gwen. Sam's eyes lit up. "That is so cool! My life just went from awkward to great!" "Guys stop it! Or do we need to splash you all so that you shut up?" Pamela threatened. Everyone went silent. "Good, that's better. Yes, in addition to a fishtail, you all gained powers which will help you to keep that secret a secret. Kurt, Blaine, Gwen, Pam and I figured out that you all gained more than one power, we are still trying to figure out why exactly. Normally, merpeople have one, maximum two powers. But you guys all have… so many more for whatever reason we don't know. Okay, now you can ask questions before we start with the training..." "Training? Oh man, I hate that! I thought we were here to relax!", Puck whined. "Well, plans changed, Puck. Would you rather train with us or end up getting cut open by mad scientists? Cause that will happen if you don't know how to control your newly gained powers, young man.", Gwen deadpanned. Puck shuddered. "Okay, okay, I think I get it." "Good. Any questions?" "How is that possible?", Artie asked. Gwen shook her head. "Unfortunately, we don't know it yet, Artie. The moonpool where you landed in yesterday manipulated your genes and turned you into merpeople, but I still didn't figure out the theory behind that. I have studied medicine and natural sciences, so I tried to use my knowledge to solve that mystery for years, but I failed. There is no formula, no theorem which can explain what happened to us. In the end, I decided to let it be and accept that we are mermaids without knowing why exactly, simple as that." Rachel rose her hand. "Okay and what do we have for powers?" Pamela sighed. "We don't exactly have an answer for that, Rachel. We don't know what each one of you is able to do, but as far as I know, there will be one power which you will master more than others, because it is your primary power. For Kurt, its manipulating water and for Blaine it's boiling liquids. Gwen's is turning liquids into crystals or make them jelly, Alice's is growing and controlling plants and I have the control over electricity. We will figure out which will be the primary power of each of you, don't worry." Tina was next to ask a question. "Can we like…breathe underwater? Like Ariel?" "And can we talk to fish or crabs?", Brittany asked. Alice groaned. "Oh my gosh, why keeps everyone comparing us to that Disney movie made by clueless humans? No, Tina, we can't, and no, Brittany, we can't talk to fish or marine animals. We don't need to come up for air for a long time, though." "Think about whales for example. They live underwater entirely even if they can't breathe, they only breathe once or twice per day. I didn't test it, but I did some research where I found out that with the right training, you don't need to come up for air for a whole day. But guys, not having to breathe underwater for half a day is amazing enough so there is no need for that.", Gwen explained. "Do you think there are sirens? Mermaids who can control others with their voices?", Rachel asked eagerly. Kurt paled and looked down. Luckily, nobody but Blaine, who reassuringly squeezed his hand, seemed to notice it. Pamela cocked her head to the side. "We never met one, but we think it's actually possible. But why do you want to know that, Rachel?" The brunette shrugged. "Just out of interest. Or maybe because I want to compel the professors at NYADA so that…" "RACHEL BARBRA BERRY! You will not abuse your powers like that, okay? We don't want to go through the whole thing like with Sebastian all over again…" "-Wait! Sebastian? As in Sebastian Smythe? He is a merman?", Mercedes interrupted Pamela. "Was, Aretha. Lady Lips told me you took away his powers or something like that.", Santana explained. "Yeah, something like that is right, but we won't go into detail because that's no option for you anytime soon. On top of that, we erased his memories permanently because his knowledge about us would be a threat to the whole mer-community." "You can do that?", Sam asked, astonished. "Yes, but it's pretty hard. It's an exhausting procedure which can be done in exceptional cases, we hope we don't have to do it ever again. Hopefully you guys are not like that Smythe kid, right?" "They aren't, Alice, I swear. I mean, Puck, Santana and Rachel are sometimes a bit…unbearable…" "We heard that, Lady! You made my list", Santana scoffed, "- but their hearts are on the right places!", Kurt finished his sentence. "Aww, I take that back, Hummel!" "We trust you, Kurt, that's why we also trust your friends. We noticed that you have each other's backs if necessary, we think everything is going to be alright. We don't want to forbid you to use your powers for you advantage because we also do that, but don't exaggerate. As long as nobody notices you using your powers or you don't harm anyone, you can always use your abilities to ease your everyday life." As everyone started talking to each other about what happened to them, Pamela clapped her hands once again. "Now that question time is over, let's start with the training now, we only have four days before we have to fly back. Okay, lesson number one: How to not get wet in the first place!"
A/N: Please tell me what you think!