Obey me! One master to rule them all! – Otome Sim / Dating Sim

Spoiler! Chapter 20

Disclaimer: I'm using some lines from the game.

Beel x MC x Belphie

In search of Belphie, I suggest we go look for him in the attic room.

"All right, let's go." Beel replies.

We find him sleeping peacefully and try to wake him up. But it's no use. He's fast asleep.

"He can stay here and sleep if he wants. As long as he doesn't go anywhere, that's all that matters." Beel says to me. "It's thanks to you that our family is back together again. Thank you! I want you to know that you are very important to me. Of course Lucifer and Mammon and the others are also important to me. But it's not the same. The way I feel about you is different. It's sort of like… You're more special to me. Do you understand what I'm trying to say?"

Beelzebub is gazing at me with a hopeful look in his eyes. My heart is racing and I just have to do it. I kiss him.

"Mm… Up to now, I always felt like I was hungry for something. I'd eat and eat and eat, but I still wasn't satisfied, so I'd eat more. But when I'm with you, it's like that hunger is suddenly gone. For once I feel strangely satisfied. Don't stop. Kiss me more…"

"Hey…" a voice startles us. "What's the big idea doing that in front of me, huh? Seriously…" Belphie says sleepily.

"Belphie, so you're awake…" Beel sounds a bit disappointed.

"Well, yeah. I skipped school and I've been sleeping here ever since morning. So yeah, I'd say it's about time I woke up. I can sleep in peace up here, without anyone showing up to bother me. It's a pretty useful space to have."

"We were worried about you," I tell him.

"Really? Why?" he asks and Beel explains.

Suddenly a loud growl echoes through the room.

"Wow, you scared me! For a moment, I thought Cerberus had decided to show up here in the attic." Belphie says to his brother.

"Now that I'm not worried anymore, I suddenly feel hungry…"

"Oh, in that case, run and grab some food to bring back here… and bring enough for Rikku and me as well, thanks."

"Okay. Be back in a bit." Beel nods and leaves the attic.

"Now that I've got you alone, I'll come out and ask you this: Rikku, do you have feelings for Beel? Do you like him?"

His question surprises me and I'm not sure I should answer it.

"Yeah, I do," I confess.

"Really? I have to say, you've got good taste." Belphie smiles. "I'm really impressed that you can see how special Beel is. Actually, it's no surprise. You're the one person I would expect to understand how great Beel is. I like you, Rikku. I really like you. So listen, why don't you, me and Beel all live together? All three of us living happily ever after… What do you say? Would you give it a try?"

Belphegor leans in toward me. His question warms my heart and all I want to do is say yes… but I remain silent. And still I can't help myself. I kiss him.

"Is that a yes? Or is it a no, and you're just trying to make me feel better?" He asks confused. "Are you just going to leave me with only this one final memory of you stuck in my head? If so, then I want to do the same to you. I want to leave you with a memory so vivid and lasting that no matter where you may go or how much time passes, I'll always be stuck right there in your head. I want to do more than just kiss… A lot more. I want to know you more intimately then anyone ever has."

He takes a step forward, backing me against the wall. Taking my wrists and pinning them above my head, he kisses me hard. His body is holding mine in place. There's no escape. Not that I want to. I return his kiss and my body responds to his actions.

"I'm back!" Beels voice startles us.

"D'ah, you scared me…" Belphie lets go of my arms. I look down at the floor, a bit flustered from getting caught in this position. Beels eyes go wide, seeing Belphie still standing pressed against me. Putting down the food he brought, he strides over to us. He grabs my hand and forcefully pulls me away from his brother's touch. I slam into his chest hard and look up at his face. He's glaring at Belphie over my shoulder. When his gaze turns back to me, his eyes soften. His hand on my back keeps me close. I see him leaning into me and his lips find mine. It feels more passionate than his brother's kiss. I realize I like them both and I'm not sure what to do.

"I'm willing to share her with you, dear brother," Belphie chuckles. His voice sounding closer than I expected. I feel his hands on my hips and his body pressing against my back. His breath on my neck makes me shudder and his mouth grazes the skin. I can't stop myself from moaning. Beel pulls away from me and strokes my hair.

"Are you okay with that?" he asks concerned.

I look at him while pondering over the question. I then take a glance over my shoulder to see Belphie looking at me in expectation. My mouth is slightly ajar with indecision. I turn my face downwards and notice Beels chest in front of me with my hand on it. I flex that hand, biting my lip, and feel his muscles. I let out a sigh. At the same time I'm fully aware of Belphie's waist against my backside.

I think I want this. But can I really?

Noticing my doubt, Beel lifts up my chin with his index finger, making me look into his eyes. He smiles back at me.

"We don't mind," he reassures me. "Just tell us what you want."

"I… I want both of you…"

His lips crash into mine again and I can feel his hunger for me. Meanwhile Belphie pushes his hips into me further, making me press into Beel even more. I hear a moan but I can't tell who it was. I can feel them both getting excited. I'm a bit starstruck at the thought that they both want me.

Belphies hand slides down my arm softly, before grabbing my wrist with a little more force. Suddenly he tugs at it, hard, making me spin around to face him. Beels kiss is immediately replaced with his. Again I am pressed in between both brothers. Beels hands glide along my legs, slowly lifting up my dress. Both thumbs trace along my panties and I push back against him. He's already so hard. I moan into Belphies kiss and when he pulls away, he flashes me a wicked smile. I bite my lip in anticipation. He sees Beel lightly nibbling my neck and his hand reaches towards my shoulder. He pushes aside the strap of my dress which falls down my arm. On the other side, Beel does the same. Belphie traces his fingers down my front until he reaches the dress that is just barely clinging onto my body. His hand caught on the fabric, continues his way down. My dress falls off, resting at my hips, where Beels hands are still on my skin. He lets go of me and tugs the piece of clothing further down. Lifting up my feet one by one, I kick it to the side.

I notice Belphie staring at me with longing in his eyes. I suddenly remember that I wasn't wearing a bra and I try to cover up. Belphie grabs my wrists to stop me. Beel traces one hand from my hip to my belly and slowly works his way up towards my breast. He takes my nipple in between two fingers and starts playing with it. His other hand also glides to the front, but instead of moving upwards, it slides down my panties. I gasp in surprise.

"Mmmm…." He groans, while he moves his fingers up and down my wet folds.

Belphie was watching this all happen and started stripping his clothes off. I can't help myself from thinking how hot he looks. I bite my lip when I see him stand in front of me, completely naked. He steps towards me and pulls me against him. I moan as Beels finger runs over my sensitive spot while removing his hand. It feels cold when he takes a step back. I try to glance over my shoulder but then Belphie demands my attention by kissing me again.

I hear a rustling of clothes behind me and imagine Beel taking them off. Meanwhile Belphie starts kissing me all the way down my front, lingering at my nipple and lightly pinching the other one with his fingers. Feeling the warmth at my back returning, Beels hands replace Belphies tugs on my nipples. He continues kissing me all the way down. He pulls down my panties and throws them to the side. I arch my back at the sensation of one brother playing with my nipples and the other licking and nibbling me down there. My moans are coming faster and I feel my pleasure reaching its destination point. With one final moan, I climax. Getting lost in the sensation, my knees go weak. Luckily Beel is holding me. Belphie gets back up on his feet and both brothers lead me toward the bed. I'm already out of breath but I know they're not done with me yet.

Placing me onto the bed, Beel crawls on top of me, while Belphie lays down beside me. The latter taking my chin in his hand to make me face him. His tongue finds mine and I moan into him as I feel Beel entering me. One hand squeezes on his muscular arm, while the other is looking for his brother. I start stroking him and I see him closing his eyes, enjoying the feeling. Beel grunts as he picks up the pace and I turn to him, wanting to feel his lips on mine again. He leans in for a kiss as he keeps pounding inside of me. His movements become more intense and I know he's on the verge of release. One final thrust and he eases into me, trying to catch his breath.

He makes way for his twin, who is more than ready. Belphie turns me around on all fours and positions himself behind me. I can feel him exploring – teasing – before he pushes in. He's more rough than Beel and I cry out with pleasure at each thrust.

Next to me I can see Beel getting hard again. He gets up on his knees to sit in front of me. One of my hands finds him while I keep the other one in place for support. I start teasing him with my tongue. He groans. I open my mouth further and slowly take him in. He throws his head back in arousal and grabs the back of my head with one hand. He tugs at my hair. I feel excited having them both inside of me, moaning in pleasure. Belphies hand reaches down my front to find my sweet spot again. He starts rubbing it in sync with his movements. Still sensitive from before, I feel the tension building up quick. It doesn't take long before a muffled cry escapes my lips. Turned on by the sight of my orgasm, Beel reaches his as well. I swallow him down and he stares at me dumbfounded with his mouth hanging open.
Belphe keeps ramming into me harder and harder until he too finds his release. He leaves me and lays down next to me. Lowering myself onto the bed, they both cuddle up to me on each side. I feel safe in their arms. Closing my eyes, I let the exhaustion take over.