Description: Butter's favorite frosting flavor is no longer in production, so the kids make a new flavor, with bad results.


It was the school bake sale. Everyone around South Park were lining up to buy baked goods. Wendy was in charge of it all and things were running smoothly. Over to her right, she could hear Butters grumbling.

"What's wrong, Butters?" Wendy said.

"No one's making butterscotch frosting on cupcakes and it's my favorite." Butters said.

"Oh, because your name has Butters in it." Wendy chuckled. "I'll go ask."

Wendy went up to the bakers.

"Do we have any butterscotch frosting?"

"No." One of the bakers said. "They stopped production. They told Mr. Mackey about it."


"What?! No more Butterscotch pudding?" Butters said.

"It's not popular and we can only get it from... Nevada."

"AH!" Both Butters and Wendy screamed hugging each other in fear.

Peter came running into the room.

"What's the problem?" He asked.

"Butterscotch frosting is no longer!" Mr. Mackey said. "We can only get them from Nevada."

"Dude, what's the issue with Nevada? I keep hearing horror stories like being a boring place but they never proven."

"So!" Mr. Mackey said. "You're going to get butterscotch pudding in Nevada?"

"Yes." Peter said.

"You're literally signing to kill yourself from boredom!" Butters pleaded.

"Who told you this?" Peter said.

"My parents!"

"Me too!" Wendy said.

"Yeah, say what you want, but I'm going anyway." Peter said, walking out the door.

"May all mighty have mercy on you." Priest Maxi said as Peter walked out the door.


"Turn back, Peter! Don't do this!" Randy said.

"Can you at least tell me what I'm facing?" Peter said.


After Peter left, one of the police officers plays taps on his trumpet.

"Let's get back to the bake sale." Clyde said.

Wendy and Butters were instead went to Dr. Mephesto to try different flavor combinations. After a lot of testing, they needed one more kind of fruit.

"Rasberries?" Wendy said at the town's raspberries fields.

"I heard they make a delicious side." Mephesto said as he picked a handful.

Mephesto then placed the berries in the mixing bowl. Butters tasted it. It was heaven to him. And to the baker's at the bake sale too.

"It's my favorite flavor!" Butters said.

"Mine too." One of the bakers said.

The baker then got on a megaphone.

"Everyone stop what you're making and now make..."

Wendy whispered into his ear.

"...Yum frosting!"

Everyone cheered. For about 5 seconds.

"We don't know what that is!" said another baker.


Yum frosting proved to be very popular.

"One cupcake with Yum frosting please." Stan said.

Stan got his order. Cartman then ran up.

"I'd like one Yum Cake, extra Yum, hold the cake!"

Cartman got a compressed hose spraying him with frosting. As the camera pans across the school, everyone is shown enjoying Yum. Except for a few.

"Why didn't you ask for Yum, Newton?" Wendy said.

"Um, because it's too popular?" Newton said. "I like to stick with chocolate here."

As Newton walked away, Mephesto came up to Wendy.

"We got bad news, Wendy. Because of the lack of raspberries, we're almost out of frosting."

"Uh oh." Wendy said.


Wendy then made an announcement on the mic.

"Excuse me everyone!"

Everyone turned to her.

"I've just been informed that we're running low on raspberries. If we don't stop eating Yum now, we're gonna run out."

Everyone was in an uproar.

"Whoa! Whoa! Don't panic!" Wendy said.

"You heard her! Panic!" Karen shouted.

The students all panicked.

"No! I said, Don't Panic! It's just one flavor!" Wendy said.

"But it's the best flavor!" Butters said.

"You expect me to eat vanilla, like a savage?" Kyle added.

The students continued panicking.

"How did this all go wrong?" She said.

"Easy." A voice said.

Wendy looked up to see Newton standing in front of her.

"You gave Butters a brand-new flavor he can enjoy but it became everyone's. There's a danger of having too much."

"Too much! Newton, you gave me an idea!"

Wendy then got on the mic again.

"Attention everyone! There's been a mistake."

Everyone stopped panicking.

"We miscounted. We have plenty of Yum!"

"WHAT?!" Newton said. "But you just said-"

"Don't listen to Newton!" Wendy said.

More Yum came.

"How's this supposed to work?" Newton said.

"Trust me..." Wendy said.


Soon, the kids ate so much Yum that they all turned obese.

"Holy crap." Stan said, watching it all.

"You didn't finish your Yum?" Newton said.

"I got tired of it." Stan said. "Those guys must've been tired too."

"No... more... Yum..." Cartman said hoarsely.

"See, everything worked out at the end." Wendy said.

"Yeah, very quickly too..." Newton said. "It's almost as if the problem was too easy."

Butter grabbed his Yum.

"You know, I don't think that everyone's tired of Yum." Stan said.


Newton went back home.

"Hey, Peter? I saved something from the bake sale." He said.

Peter was nowhere to be found. Newton decided to call Peter.

"Hi, please leave a voicemail." said an automated tone.

"Peter? What are you doing?" Newton said, nervously.


The final scene shows Peter hiding out in a dumpster in Nevada. When his phone made a sound, he quickly turned it off just as clicking noise can be heard.

THE END?


I wonder why Peter's hiding out there in Nevada? Doesn't he have a thing to do?