Author's Note: I don't own Star vs the Forces of Evil or its characters, but only my OCs

Star vs the Forces of Evil belongs to Daron Nefcy

Enjoy!


The Untold Story of Serena Butterfly

Chapter 73: Ponymonium

Star and Serena stood outside the gate of Pony Head's cloud castle home.

Star wore a short peach pink dress with a white lace collar, a tied string around the waist and two layers of pale pink lace at the bottom, a baby blue jacket with a white collar and lapel, hem and sleeve cuffs and a red white spotted mushroom on the back, peach pink and baby pink striped leggings, mauve and white sneakers with white laces and soles with green wings on the backs of them. On her hair, she wore a lime green headband with two small red and white spotted mushrooms on each side.

Serena wore a pink off the shoulder top with a grilled white trim around the top and frilled sleeves. She wore blue overalls over the top with a pink gold belt and frills at the edge of the shorts along with dark pink sneakers with frilly purple socks. Around her neck she had a purple daisy symbol pendant.

Star was holding a casserole dish in her hands and Serena was holding a tray of rainbow cupcakes.

"Why did you have to drag me along, Star?"Serena asked with a frown.

"Rena, you promised to come with me to hang out with Pony Head and her sisters the next time I went."Star reminded.

Serena sighed. "Right."

Star looked to her left and noticed a pony shaped intercom with a button.

"Hmm...is this the doorbell or..."Star started.

Star pushed a button, causing a loud buzzer to go off along with horse neighing noises.

"Star, what did you do?"Serena muttered bitterly.

"What are you doing?"Pony Head questioned through the speaker.

"Uh, I–I'm sorry."Star apologised. "I just rang the doorbell."

"That's not a doorbell."Pony Head admitted. "I'll come down and get you."

The door opened revealing Pony Head.

"Oh my gosh, Star, Rena!"Pony Head remarked.

"Pony Head! Good to see you, girls."Star commented. "Check out what we brought."

Pony Head looked at Star's casserole and Serena's cupcakes.

"Oh, my goodness! That is the finest casserole and cupcakes I have ever seen, girls."Pony Head chuckled. "Hmm, maybe this night might not be a total disaster after all. "

"Right!"Star laughed. "Wait, what?""

"What do you mean by disaster?"Serena asked.

Pony Head walked Star and Serena inside her home.

"I've been trying to spare you two from my sisters, I really have, but at this point, I need back-up."Pony Head stated.

"Your asking us for help?"Serena chuckled in disbelief.

Star elbowed Serena for her to be quiet.

"What?"Star said. "They've always been so nice to me."

"You do not know them like I do, Star. They're like peanut butter and jealous."Pony Head explained. "They have been trying to take me down for years, all because I'm next in line for the throne. Not to mention that I'm so beautiful and talented and humble."

"Oh yes, your very humble."Serena muttered with a smirk.

Star elbows Serena in the gut again.

"Oh, Pony Head."Star said with a smile. "I'm sure they're not that bad. "

"Star, look at me."Pony Head instructed. "They are long-faced, two-faced monsters."

Pony Head, Star and Serena arrived at the dining room.

"All right, listen up, people!"Pony Head shouted. "Okay, my friends Star and Serena are here for our meal and we are going to act like normal, like a not, like a normal family that spends time together. Like normal."

Azniss had a fork in her mouth with which she was scraping the wooden table.

"Hey, Azniss!"Pony Head called out. "No. Okay, that is not normal. This is what I'm talking about, people!"

Star and Serena sat at the table.

"Oh, no, it's fine."Star assured. "You guys don't have to do anything special for us. Just...act like we're not even here."

Azniss growled and continued to scrap the table.

Serena cleared her throat.

"Oh right."Star whispered and looked at Pony Head. "Pony Head, Rena haven't met your sisters and I forgot their names."

"Oh hey, Star forgot y'all's names and this is Rena's first time meeting you all!"Pony Head shouted.

"Ooh-ooh-ooh-ooh-ooh!"Hornanne responded happily. "Roll call!"

"No!"Pony Head snapped. "Oh, no!"

"Baby Pranciss."Baby Pranciss sang.

"Hornanne."Hornanne sang.

"Jan-Jan."Jan-Jan sang.

"Pamanda."Pamanda sang.

"Khrysthalle."Khrysthalle sang.

"Angel."Angel sang.

"Azniss."Azniss sang.

"No! Get back to the table right now!"Pony Head shouted. "You don't introduce yourselves with a musical number. You say your name. Just say your name. Where are the twins? Shonda and Shinda."

Shonda and Shinda poke their heads up from the couch.

"Yes?"Shonda and Shinda asked creepily.

"Get your creepy selves over here. You guys are so weird."Pony Head scowled. "Ugh! Are we ready to eat?"

"Food?"King Pony Head asked brightly.

"Yes, Daddy, it's time to eat."Pony Head replied with a frown. "Get down here."

King Pony Head laughed as he slides down the bannister, crashing right next to the table.

"Fooooood!"King Pony Head bellowed.

Star and Serena held onto the table as the entire room shook.

As he bellows, troughs fall on to the table filled with pink goop, pizza, french fries, hot dogs, cookies, cupcakes and other foods.

"Well, dig in."King Pony Head instructed.

The Pony Heads started to eat except for Star and Serena, who stared blankly at the troughs.

Star chuckled nervously. "Uh, hey Pony Head, is it okay if we skip the trough and...and eat this cupcake that's on a plate here?"

"Yeah, that's Teta's plate. She ran off."Khrysthalle replied. "We always make a plate for her, in the hopes that she'll come back one day. I hope she's not prettier than me, though."

"Just how many sisters does Pony Head has?"Serena whispered uncomfortably.

Star placed her hand on Serena's mouth and hushed.

"Oh she probably ran off because she can't stand your sorry butts, okay?"Pony Head asked with a glare.

"She ran off because you're always throwing her shade, Pony Head."Azniss replied.

"She's always throwing me shade by doing her homework and then being, like, "Oh, I'm gonna donate to charity."Pony Head scoffed. "You know what I mean? Like, that's very rude."

Then slow creepy music started playing.

"When you look at your twin, it is like you looking back at you..."Shonda and Shinda sang via phonography.

"Shonda and Shinda, what are you doing?"Pony Head asked.

"We wanted to play some of our original music for Star and Serena."Shonda and Shinda replied in unison.

"Nobody wants to hear your creepy singing except for dead people."Pony Head responded with a frown. "Are we at a haunted house?"

Pony Head looked at Star and Serena.

"See what I mean?"Pony Head asked.

"I don't know, I think it's kinda sweet."Star commented kindly.

"You should visit the attic in Adyson's house."Serena joked.

"I miss Teta!"Baby Pranciss cried.

"How do you even know who Teta is?"Pony Head asked. "You were a zygote when she disappeared."

"Not cool, Pony Head."Angel admitted with a frown.

"That's really mean."Pamanda added.

The other sisters at the table also complain about Pony Head's statement.

"Now, now, girls, settle down."King Pony Head instructed and nervously slurped from his coffee mug.

"I'm sorry you all can't handle how on point I am right now."Pony Head stated before looking at Star and Serena. "Can't trust anyone in this house. Not even my best friends."

Pony Head flew away from the dining room.

There was an awkward silence in the background.

"He-heh, we're just gonna go check on her."Star assured with a nervous smile and grabbed Serena's arm. "Come on, Rena."

Star and Serena headed to Pony Head's room and went inside.

"Knock, knock."Star said. "Can we come in?"

Pony Head eats some food and belches loudly.

"So...I'm really sorry you felt ganged-up on down there, but uh, you gotta admit, you were being a little intense, right?"Star asked.

Pony Head continued to ignore Star as she puts on some head phones and beat boxes to the music.

"You should tell her what's in the casserole."Serena suggested.

"Hey, Pony Head."Star said and takes off her headphones. "Guess what's in the casserole..."

Pony Head flew over to her closet.

"...that I made?"Star finished.

Pony Head puts on some funny clothes which Star laughed at and then there was silence.

"Star-"Serena started.

"Just take a wild guess."Star remarked. "Nah, All right, I'll just tell you. It is gingerbread and ice cream."

"Why don't you go eat it with my sisters since you think they're so great?!"Pony Head yelled.

"Ugh!"Star groaned. "Fine!"

Star stomped out and slammed the door.

Pony Head glared at Serena.

"Hey aren't you going too?"Pony Head questioned.

"It would be my pleasure."Serena replied simply while putting her hand up and left the room.

The two girls joined the others to eat in the dining room.

Star managed to take a bite of the pink goop while Serena nibbled on a lollipop.

"This casserole is delicious, Star."Baby Pranciss giggled.

"Yeah, I know."Star chuckled.

"And these cupcakes are out of this kingdom."Jan-Jan commented.

"Thanks."Serena responded with a small smirk.

"Was Pony Head mean to both of you, too?"Baby Pranciss asked.

Star swallowed the food in her mouth and leaned back on her chair.

"I don't get it."Star admitted. "It's seems like she just flipped out of nowhere."

Pamanda sighed. "Don't beat yourself up about it."

"She's like that all the time."Azniss said. "You haven't picked up on that yet?"

"Oh, I have."Serena assured bluntly.

"I guess she can sometimes be a little–"Star started.

"Bit of a party pooper?"Khrysthalle finished. "We know."

"She's pooped on our parties more times than I can even count."Baby Pranciss added. "And then, she makes fun of me 'cause I don't know all of my numbers yet."

Tears began to appear in Baby Pranciss eyes.

"You poor thing!"Star said in pity.

"And guess who's developed a complex?"Baby Pranciss asked.

Star and Serena looked at each other.

"All of us. We all did."Whistine complemented. "She messed us up real good."

"It's true."Khrysthalle agreed. "Because of Pony Head's attitude, I became terribly insecure and now, I have to compensate by putting all of my self-worth into my jaw-dropping beauty."

Khrysthalle began to cry as she looked at Star and Serena.

"It's real hard, you guys and I do it every day."Khrysthalle sobbed. "Every day."

"I've never known Pony Head to be so horrible."Star said.

"Same with me."Serena replied.

"But at least we have each other."Shonda and Shinda said in unison.

"Yeah, we don't need no stinkin' Pony Head to have a good time."Azniss remarked with a smile. "We can show you both how a real pony head parties."


Afterwards...

The pony heads were styling each other's manes as well as Star and Serena's hair.

Star's hair was braided into two pigtails while Serena's hair was styled with a bit of silver glitter.

"Now you look fierce."Baby Pranciss said kindly.

"Thanks, Pranciss."Star answered.

Hornanne added blue dye on one of Serena's hair streak.

"Hey, not bad."Serena complemented and looked herself on the mirror.

"Yo, Star, Serena, check this out."Jan-Jan remarked.

Jan-Jan knocked her glasses off her head and onto her face.

"Oh, cool."Star commented. "Fun tricks."

Star does the same trick with her headband.

"Huh?"Star asked. "What do you think?"

"I wasn't done."Jan-Jan said.

Jan-Jan groaned as she flipped herself inside out, ending up upside-down.

"I got no idea what just happened."Serena stated.

"You two should be honoured."Baby Pranciss admitted. "She only does that for her sisters."

"Heh."Khrysthalle chuckled. "You're, you're both totally like members of the family now."

"We are?"Star and Serena asked in unison.

"Absolutely."the pony head sisters answered happily.

"Oh, yay!"Star gasped excitedly. "I've always wanted sisters."

Serena looked at Star for a moment but didn't say anything.

"You know what's the most awesomest thing about having sisters?"Whistine asked.

"Arguing over the remote?"Star guessed.

"Going shopping together?"Serena suggested.

"Those are good guesses, but it's actually the secrets."Azniss complemented. "Do you like secrets?"

"Usually."Star replied.

"Do you like projects?"Azniss asked.

"Yes."Star said hesitantly.

"What is this about?"Serena questioned.

"We've got this super secret project we've been working on and we'd love to get your thoughts on it."Azniss admitted.

"Sweet!"Star giggled.

Azniss sticked her tongue on a scanner and opened up a locked drawer.

She grabbed a folder with the title Top Secret before showing it to Star and Serena.

"Check it out."Azniss instructed.

Star and Serena looked through the folder.

"Is that Teta?"Serena said.

"Wait, Teta on Ice?"Star asked. "I thought Teta ran off."

"Oh, baby, we're hatching a plot to depose Pony Head as heir to the throne."Azniss commented.

Serena stared at Star in shock.

"Nah."Star chuckled.

"Yeah."Azniss laughed slowly.

"You both saw how she is."Khrysthalle reminded. "She's unfit to lead."

"Yeah."Pamanda explained and opened a law book. "Look, we've got it all figured out."

"Pony Law states that if a pony princess puts one of her sisters...ON ICE, she can never be queen."Azniss explained.

"So we're putting Teta on ice and framing Pony Head for it."Jan-Jan commented.

"You guys properly mean dancing or skating on ice."Serena suggested.

"Well that sounds fun."Star remarked.

"No, no, no, no, no, honey."Azniss responded. "We mean..."

"On ICCCCCCCCCCCCCCE."Azniss, Angel, Khrysthalle, Jan-Jan, Pamanda, Shonda, Shinda, Hornanne, Chezna, Whistine and Baby Pranciss corrected.

Star and Serena paled, now knowing what Pony Head's sisters meantZ

"Oh, no."Star whispered. "No, no, no, no, no, no. Hey, you guys, ice is supposed to be cool, and what you're talking about is bad ice."

"Not really."Baby Pranciss refused. "We're just gonna pretend Teta's on ice."

"Ain't that right, Teta?"Jan-Jan questioned.

A pair of eyes were looking out from a closet.

"Yep."Teta agreed and took out her ID card. "They got a new life set up for me and everything. I'll have a moustache!"

"What you guys think?"Azniss asked.

"Well...um..."Serena said with a unsure look.

"I got...a lot of questions."Star answered as she stood up. "I know Pony Head has got some issues, but don't you think maybe framing her is a bit much?"

"Ugh, everyone knows Pony would be the worst queen ever."Khrysthalle retorted. "She just won't admit it to herself."

"This way, the right pony gets to inherit the throne."Azniss stated and lept over to a crest with battle axes screaming. "ME!"

"Wait a minute...who said you were gonna be queen?"Khrysthalle demanded.

"Yeah, I thought I was gonna be queen."Pamanda stated.

"Pamanda, really?"Azniss and Khrysthalle asked in disbelief.

"No, you're right."Pamamda said sadly and read the law book.

"Uh, I should be queen."Jan-Jan suggested.

"No, I should be queen."Hornanne argued. "I'm perfect."

"No, I should be queen."Angel commented.

"I think I'd do a good job!"Teta called out.

"That makes no sense."Azniss insulted. "You're supposed to be dead."

"We talked about this..."Pamanda started.

Star and Serena exchanged looks.

Star and Serena started backing away from Pony Head's sisters, but they bumped into the twins.

"Where are you two off to in such a hurry?"Shonda and Shinda asked in unison.

"Oh, oh, oh."Star chuckled nervously. "Oh us?"

"We are just going to explore around the castle."Serena assured.

"You two weren't planning on telling Pony Head now, were you?"Azniss asked.

"No."Serena lied with a weak smile. "Isn't it, Star?"

"Of course not."Star agreed. "Never. No."

"Cause, uh, we can't allow you to snitch, sugar boogers."Azniss laughed. "You're with us now, sisters."

The whole family glared at Star and Serena.

"And if you betray your sisters, you're gonna get disappeared, too."Baby Pranciss warned holding an axe. "Just like Teta."

A pony whinnied loudly and everyone saw Pony Head looking in through the doorway.

"Bam!"Pony Head responded. "You are busted!"

Pony Head smashed a book case and a cloud lamp.

"Pony, what is going on?"Star asked.

"Star, Rena, you beautiful angels, I am so sorry you've been put through this trauma, girls."Pony Head apologised. "I knew these no-class-having wanna be queens were up to something. I just didn't know what. And, now I have it all on video."

Pony Head spits out her phone on her tongue while it plays a video of Azniss confessing.

"This way, the right pony gets to inherit the throne."Azniss stated smugly.

"Okay, thanks for having us."Star admitted with a frown. "Because we definitely feel like we've been had."

"And thank you for making my first time here, very welcoming."Serena said sarcastically.

Star and Serena walked out of the room.


Outside...

Star and Serena went to the front door of the house.

"Oh, unbelievable."Star said with a frown.

"They fooled us, good."Serena responded bitterly.

Star summoned Cloudy with her wand.

"Yeah, so anyway, thank you, girls, for coming over."Pony Head remarked. "I know you both probably feel used, but I couldn't have done it without either of you. Thank you so much."

"What, are you kidding?"Star asked. "Pony Head, this is one of the most stressful experiences of my already very intense life."

"I'm sorry."Pony Head apologised. "My sisters are totally insane."

"Oh, totally insane."Star agreed.

"Whoa, hold up."Pony Head ordered. "You cannot just be sitting up here talking about my sisters like that."

"You just said it yourself."Serena reminded.

"Star, Serena, I love my sisters."Pony Head admitted. "We do this every meal."

"I guess I don't get this whole sister thing."Star responded sadly.

"Come to think of it, this reminds when I had a sleepover with Adyson and her friends."Serena commented. "But they are nothing compared to the ones we have together."

Star smiled at Serena.

"Besides you guys have one of the best sisters a girl could ever need, 'cause you two got me, B-fly and Rena, ha ha."Pony Head replied with a smile.

Pony Head moved to hug Star and Serena before kissing them.

"Aww, girl."Star cooed.

"That's sweet."Serena chuckled.

King Pony Head floated next to the three girls.

"Star, Serena, you both weren't trying to leave without saying good-bye, were you?"King Pony Head asked and whispered nervously. "Take me with you."

Star and Serena drifted out through the gates riding the cloudy charm.

"Bye Star and Serena!"Azniss, Angel, Khrysthalle, Jan-Jan, Pamanda, Shonda, Shinda, Hornanne, Chezna, Whistine and Baby Pranciss said happily.

"Bye-bye."Star giggled.

"See ya."Serena responded with a wave.


Hope you guys enjoyed this chapter:)