The cloaked figure in black stalked up to the arguing duo but the deck creaked and groaned under their weight alerting the two to its presence. Uma glared angrily once she realized who this was. This is the same person who attacked Gil. Uma went to grab her sword as Harry, already having his grabbed his from his belt and brandished it at the figure. The two circled each other while Uma scrambled for her sword. The two locked blades and began fighting. Every clink and clank filled Uma's heart with dread as she approached. This person was good, too good. She joined in on the fighting but the figure was unmoved it seemed, easily fending both of them off, meeting blades when necessary and dodging as well. Harry slipped up and ended up with a gash across his chest. He hissed and recoiled but didn't let up, gritting through the pain. Uma tried to cast a spell but was interrupted and nearly impaled every time she spoke.

By the time Uma found a window, an opening to cast her spell, the mistake Harry made was fatal. As magic swirled and bound the figure to the deck, frozen with blade poised as Harry slumped to the deck grasping his throat which had been slit. Uma rushed to his side quickly chanting any spell she could think of but nothing seemed to be mending the wound. Harry grabbed her hand and forced her to look in his eyes before he succumbed. Harry Hook was dead in Uma's arms. Sorrow and rage filled her in equal measure as Uma turned on the frozen figure, blade in her now shaking hand. "This is for Harry," Uma says righteously, slashing at the frozen cloaked figure before her blade could meet it's target golden sparkles of magic blasted the blade out of her hand sending it skittering across the ship's deck and into the water off the side. Uma looked for the source and saw Jane waiting hands glowing and glittering with magic. Uma screamed drawing the attention of nearby guards as she charged Jane, tackling her to the deck before she could cast another spell. Uma wept as she wrapped her hands around the fairy's throat sobbing attempting to strangle her. The guards however pulled her off and set her aside, restraining her.

Everyone involved was brought into custody and Harry's body was taken care of with respect, in preparation for his burial at sea. Ben received the call that the cloaked figure had been captured. While Mal and Evie settled into one of the guest rooms at the castle Carlos and Ben headed down to the police station to find out who was behind this. When they arrived Uma had blood on her hands still and was openly sobbing in one of the benches. Ben went to her side with Carlos. "What happened?" Ben asked and Uma struggled to breathe.

"Harry is dead. That masked fucker killed him!" Uma wailed and Ben pulled her to his chest rocking her and rubbing her back as Carlos stood and went to the side by side cells where Jane and the figure were being housed. The figure sat motionless as if nothing more than a doll. Jane looked at Carlos hopelessly.

"You know I'm, not bad Carlos. I'm doing the right thing. You have to understand." She pleaded but Carlos ignored her words and looked at the figure. He had one of the officers go in with him as he pulled the mask off their face. Sitting vacantly, behind the mask was Lonnie Li. She looked empty but her eyes glowed with golden magic. Carlos looked at Jane through the bars accusatorily. Jane sighed defeated and with a wave of her hand Lonnie's eyes returned to normal. She blinked and looked up at Carlos confused.

"Carlos? Where am I? Why am… I in jail? What am I wearing? Jane? What's going on?" Lonnie asked confused bracing herself against the wall. Carlos sighed heavily and shook his head just pointing at Jane for her to explain while Carlos went back to Uma and Ben. Uma was no longer crying but she was sniffling sitting with Ben silently. The king stood and looked to Carlos.

"Who was it?" Ben asked curiously and Carlos grimaced looking into Ben's eyes disturbed and defeated.

"It was Lonnie. Jane put her under a spell to attack the VK's. She was trying to get rid of us. I don't know why beyond her anti-villain motives but it was Jane all along. She used Lonnie to kill and hurt people. Lonnie doesn't even know she did any of it." Carlos's voice broke with emotion. This was horrible. Harry was dead and his killer was mind-controlled into killing him. Ben pulled Carlos into a careful hug, the younger of the two burying his face against his chest finally letting himself cry. Ben just stood solemnly looking heartbroken and conflicted. He would have to pass judgment one way or another.

The next hour was spent talking with Lonnie to find out what happened. Apparently, Jane invited her over for a girl's night but she doesn't remember anything other than showing up. Everything after that was blank to her. Jane sat guiltily listening to the whole thing. Ben was forced to call Fairy Godmother. They used her wand to strip Jane of her magic and she would be tried for the attempted murder of the VK's and the murder of Harry Hook. Fairy Godmother was a wreck after Ben's decision had been made. Lonnie once informed of what she had done was horror-struck. She felt violated and used. She has always supported the VK's and would never have done anything to hurt them. Her own skills were used to kill someone. Lonnie swore then and there never to touch a sword again in her life. Ben after reviewing all evidence and testimonies sentenced Jane to Goodness Rehabilitation alongside villains as well as imprisonment.

Ben and Carlos headed back to the castle in silence. Harry's funeral would be in a couple of days but neither wanted to think about that. Ben felt like he was failing not only his people but his friends. Carlos felt like a fool for ever thinking he was in love with someone so blind and cruel. He slid into Ben's arms and rested his head on his chest. Both of them hurting and grieving in their own way.

It was Uma who had to inform The Court of Villains of what happened to Harry as well as tell Jay. She left it to Ben and Carlos to inform Mal and Evie. A somberness settled over Auradon that night, one that made Carlos and Ben hold one another closer and appreciate that they were still alive and still had each other. Mal and Evie were similarly grateful but none more so that Jay who knew how close Gil was to joining Harry. That night Ben dreamed of the hook wielding pirate wishing them farewell.