Boy King's Toybox: Sam's Harem

by SetsunaNoroi

Sam is now the Boy King of Hell but war with Heaven holds no interest for him. So he just runs the place sufficiently and keeps evil productive, you know, balance of nature and all that. He still has his dark hobbies though, and the demons downstairs are too terrified and intrigued to argue about it. Featuring a dark but not evil Sam playing with his subjects and them craving it.

20. Andy

At first Gabriel was pretty much the only guy I had with Sam, but honestly the Boy King could use some more male company. All the ladies are nice, but every once in a while you just need another guy to spend some time with.

Chapter 20: Andy

Sam was always sure what to do about the other special children from the second he took over Hell. Ava he's fine with seeing tortured, and Jake is right there with her. He has his reasons for having killed Sam, but the bastard is the reason Dean had to sell his soul to save Sam's life. The Boy King is petty and vindictive enough to see the both of them suffering, sometimes watching and sometimes indulging in it himself. He saves the occasion for when he's had a particularly stressful day and putting body part of his into someone else just won't cut it.

He particularly likes it when they scream and beg and try to explain to him why they did what they did, that their reasons are understandable. Honestly, they aren't wrong, but he doesn't understand why they think that would make him stop. If anything, Jake doing bad things for a good reason just makes it more fun to cut into him, so he knows deep down he's going to suffer forever for daring to put his family above Sam's. The Boy King doesn't have to pretend to be a good person anymore, and it's so freeing that it's actually a turn on just how deep into sadism he's allowed himself to go.

Only on special occasions though, or when he's really pissed off. Eat cake too often and it stops being sweet after all.

Andy is a completely other case. Too selfish to have really gotten into Heaven, but not bad enough to deserve the pits. Sadly Heaven was a perfect grade or you didn't get in sort of place. It sucks but Sam feels he does enough to keep it relatively fair. He can't make Hell into a party club of strippers and booze, but there are still hedonistic pleasures that can be gotten a hold of.

Time with Andy is fun, a more relaxed pleasure than torture. He can't enjoy drugs with the amount of power his body has, but he enjoys seeing Andy strung out and relaxed as he strips him slowly and plays with his flesh. The man knows such good positions and tricks, no shame either. The special child is nonchalant about their affair, groans guttural as he's filled in every possible way and seems half out of his mind by the end of it, limp and leaking all over himself.

A casual smirk at the end of it is all the thanks Andy gives him for the visit, but it's also what Sam needs. Sometimes he has to torture and tear something apart. Sometimes has to just play with a toy so relaxed out of his mind it's almost like he isn't even really there. Either way, he has the special children for something.

End of Chapter 20

I think Andy would be pretty chill no matter where he ended up.