The following Monday.

Donna walks in to Josh's apartment

Donna: "Hey!"

There's no answer. She looks down at her phone – no messages.

She walks over to Josh's computer and looks at it for a second. She sits down and turns it on. She stares at the screen and then shuts it down and stands up. She hovers behind the desk chair, nervously biting her lip. She sits back down, starts the computer back up and quickly navigates to Josh's contacts. She scrolls quickly through until she lands on "M."

Donna: (talking to herself) "Marbury, Mathis, Masterson, McBride, McGarry."

She stops. She reads Leo's cell phone number.

She turns off the computer and stands up.

That same night...Annabeth walks in the door of Leo's house

Annabeth: "Hey, Leo!"

Leo: (walks towards her from the kitchen, a dish towel in his hand) "Hey."

He cups her chin in his hand and kisses her.

"I hope you're hungry because I have made what can only be described as the world's most perfect dover sole meuniere…"

He starts to walk back towards the kitchen.

Annabeth: "Sounds amazing."

Leo: (calling from the kitchen) "One day you'll be asked, 'if you could eat one thing for the rest of your life…' and you will remember this night and you will say 'Leo McGarry's dover sole meuniere'"

Annabeth: "You worried you're overselling it?"

Leo: (walks back into the room, two plates in his hand) "Not in the slightest. You want a drink?"

Annabeth: "Yeah. The hard stuff."

Leo: (smiles and pours her a glass of water) "You sure you don't miss alcohol?"

Annabeth: "I never really drank anyway."

Leo: "A fact I'll never understand."

They sit down at the dining room table.

Leo: "How was Texas?"

Annabeth: "It was good. It was nice to see Helen at home. The transition to the White House, public life, the whole First Lady thing. It's been hard, I think."

Leo: "Yeah. Matt's struggling to help her."

Back at Josh's: Josh walks into his apartment

Josh: "Donna!"

Donna: "I'm in here!"

Josh walks into his bedroom. Donna is sitting on the bed surrounded by a bunch of papers.

Josh: "What are you…" (he looks down at the papers) "Are those our campaign schedule sheets?"

Donna: "Yeah."

Josh: "You kept those?"

Donna: "You did."

Josh: "I did? Okay. But why are you looking at them?"

Donna: "They're memories, Josh."

Josh: "Yeah, of sleeplessness and panic."

Donna shifts the papers around.

Josh: "What are you looking for?"

Donna: (looks up) "It's stupid."

Josh: "What's stupid?"

Donna: "On the campaign trail. I thought there was something going on with Leo and Annabeth."

Josh: (stops undoing his tie) "Leo and Annabeth?"

Donna: "Yeah"

Josh: "Why did you think that?"

Donna: "Intuition, Josh. It's one of my many gifts."

Josh: "Uh-huh. And what do these campaign schedules have to do with that?"

Donna: "I don't know. I was just looking. They spent a lot of time together."

Josh: "Leo and Annabeth."

Donna: "Yes."

Josh: "And this matters to you why?"

Donna: "I like to know when I am right about things!"

Josh: (laughs) "Okay. Well, this wasn't something I could tell you before because…because Toby, because Toby thought it could be a John Hoynes thing and I had to not say anything."

Donna looks very confused.

Josh: (sits down on the bed and smiles conspiratorially) "Anyway, that doesn't matter now…on Election Night. I walked in on Leo and Annabeth."

Donna: "Walked in on them?"

Josh: "Yep"

Donna: "Like they were…"

Josh: "Well it wasn't like full frontal or something, but…yeah."

Donna: "Josh!"

Josh walks back over to his closet and starts taking off his jacket, tie, shoes.

Donna: "But that's not why…I mean that doesn't have anything to do with Leo's resignation, right?"

Josh: "Nothing to do with it. First of all, Leo's reasons are health stuff. But, also, it was just that one night."

Donna: "How do you know that?"

Josh: "Because I know things. And look, from like early January on, I was spending a lot of time with Leo and she was not…there was no one in Leo's life except some burly Secret Service dudes."

Donna: "She talks to him."

Josh: "What?"

Donna: "Annabeth. She talks to Leo. Like on the phone. When we were in Texas, we shared the Santos' guest room and she was on the phone with somebody and she asked them to go to Savannah with her and then when I asked her about it – something just didn't feel right. So I…I might have looked at her phone log."

Annabeth and Leo have finished dinner, and are sitting at the table

Annabeth: "That was really good, Leo."

Leo: (smiles) "Have I ever lied to you?"

Annabeth: "Too soon."

Leo: "Yeah." (he stands up) "I got you something."

Annabeth: "Like a present?"

Leo: "No, like a bomb."

Annabeth: "I miss the Secret Service."

Leo hands her a box. It's a necklace and the pendant is a small silver rhombus.

Annabeth: "Leo! This is lovely."

She starts to put it on.

He walks behind her as she lifts her hair and he closes the clasp.

Leo: "The diamond shape. It's…in mathematical logic, the rhombus stands for the possibility of an event."

Annabeth: (looks up at him) "Mathematical logic…You do know how to sweet talk a girl, Leo."

Leo: (sits back down next to Annabeth and faces her) "On Election Night. You said…"

Annabeth: "I remember, Leo."

Leo: "You've given me back possibility, Annabeth"

Josh's apartment

Josh: "Donna! That's…that's a little creepy."

Donna: "I like to know when I am right about things!"

Josh: "Okay. Well, I am never leaving my phone near you."

Donna: "Josh. You don't think it's weird?"

Josh: "Oh, I think it's weird. I think it is very weird to be discussing this. My retinas are still scarred from seeing Leo…"

Donna: "Josh, think about this. Leo and Annabeth get together while Leo is kind of her boss. You walk in on them. Within a few months, Leo McGarry, the most workaholic, political animal IN. THE. WORLD. walks away from the White House."

Josh: "You're saying what? That Annabeth Schott made him give up the Vice Presidency? That she threatened him?"

Donna: "I don't know. But does that sound much crazier than Leo giving it up on his own? It's Leo! It's like he has gills, and outside the confines of the White House or Capitol Hill, he can't breathe. And he just walks away?"

Josh: "I'm not…I'm not having this conversation, Donna. Leo had a heart attack. He barely survived. He takes one more for the team, goes through a grueling campaign, and then it's just too much. That's not impossible to believe. And it's way more believable than your crazy…gills…thing."

Donna: "Fine."

Josh: (looks again at the papers) "Where did you even find those?"

Donna: "Your closet."

Josh: "You realize that we work for the government that generally opposes phone tapping and illegal search and seizure?"

The next day: Josh's office

He picks up his phone and dials.

Toby: "Hey Josh"

Josh: "Hey Toby. Listen. I gotta…I gotta run something by you."

Toby: "Okay"

Josh: "It's a little…it's a little out there."

Toby: "I have things I could be doing, Josh."

Josh: "Yeah. Okay. So, Donna. She went to Houston last weekend with the Santos' and she and Annabeth Schott shared their guest room and Donna overheard Annabeth on the phone with Leo."

Toby: "How did she know it was Leo?"

Josh: "She…it doesn't matter. It was Leo."

Toby: "Fine. Why do I care about this?"

Josh: "Does it…do you think it's weird at all that what happened on Election Night, the thing I told you about, that it happened and I saw it and then within a few months Leo resigns?"

Toby: "You said it wasn't a Hoynes thing."

Josh: "It wasn't. I mean, Leo said it was his health. That he just wasn't up to it."

Toby: "So that's what it is."

Josh: "Yeah, but Toby. It's Leo. They guy doesn't…it's not like we're talking about a guy with a lot of hobbies, you know? What does he do when he walks away? And have you ever known Leo to walk away from anything?"

Toby: "Yeah, booze, pills, a bad marriage."

Josh: "Okay. Well, yeah."

Toby: "My point, Josh, is that Leo walks away when it's not good. When he knows that something isn't good for him, or for other people."

Josh: "So you think…"

Toby: "I think you need to let this go. I think you need to stop listening to Donna and her insane conspiracy theories gleaned from overheard conversations that may or may not have even involved the person you think it involved."

Josh: "Yeah."