Chapter 23: Lost and Found

"What? B-but that's not possible!" Wybie exclaimed as he stared flabbergasted at the old cabin in the giant tree. "We walked away from it! In a straight line! How can we be back here?"

Coraline placed a hand on his friend's shoulder. "I know, Wyborn, believe me, I know." Coraline looked miffed, but not quite as freaked out as her friend.

"This doesn't make any sense!" Wybie continued in frustration. "I built this compass myself and we only traveled east! We couldn't have made it back here!"

Dipper rubbed the bridge of his nose. "This happens sometimes, but don't freak out. Actually, we're lucky. In this forest, we could have ended up in worse places than here."

"What do you mean?" Norman asked. "Has this happened to you before?"

"A few times," Mabel said with a shrug. "It happens sometimes when we get lost or when we go too deep into the forest. It's like the forest doesn't want us to leave."

Mabel's tone was as cheerful as always and it seemed out of place for the situation. Raz wasn't sure if it was comforting that she wasn't worried, or if the girl just had an underdeveloped sense of danger.

"You two talk like the forest is alive or something," Wybie said.

"It is alive, genius," Lili said while rolling her eyes. "The forest is made out of trees and trees are alive."

"That's not what he meant, and you know it," Coraline said, jumping to her friend's defense. "He meant the twins talk like the forest has a conscience."

"I wouldn't go that far," Dipper said, "But sometimes it sure seems like it… wants to keep us here."

"What do you guys think we should do?" Norman asked the twins. "You two know the forest better than we do."

"Well… we have to stop relying on our eyes," Dipper said. "It's only going to confuse us more."

"And forget about common sense," Mabel added. "It's useless here. Right is left and left is right. Backwards can be forwards and going in circles might as well be going straight."

Dipper nodded. "The best thing to do would be to wait for nightfall so we can use the stars to guide us out. If we try and get out the conventional way then we'll end up wandering around the forest until we pass out or get lost somewhere worse. We're lucky we keep coming back to this tree. One time Mabel and I wondered so far it became dark in the middle of the day."

Mabel's smile faltered. "It wasn't a normal kind of darkness. There were no clouds or stars."

"How did you guys get out?" Neil asked with rapt attention.

Mabel glanced at Dipper, who has a far-off look in his eyes. "We're not sure…" Dipper admitted. "To this day we still aren't sure what happened. It was so dark that I couldn't see Mabel even though she was standing right next to me. Luckily we had flashlights so we could walk without running into the trees. We were walking for about an hour, probably getting even more lost, when we heard a scratching sound coming to our left. When I shined the flashlight on where the noise came from we saw a small arrow scratched into the bark of the tree. It was fresh, so we knew something had just been right next to us when it had made the arrow."

Did you follow the arrow?" Neil asked.

"We didn't have much choice," Dipper admitted. "Up to this point we were wandering aimlessly and I don't think we could have gotten more lost. A few minutes later, we heard another scratching sound off to the side, but when we turned our flashlight towards it, we couldn't see anyone. When we looked closer at the tree, there was another arrow carved in the bark. This continued to happen and we kept following the arrows until the sky started to lighten again and we could see the sun. No matter how hard we tried, we never saw who…. or what helped us."

"I saw fur!" Mabel exclaimed eagerly. "I'm pretty sure whoever helped us had fur...I think. It was pretty dark."

Dipper shrugged. "Those are the only things we have to go on. It might have had fur and it was obviously agile enough to avoid our flashlight."

"You guys have seen a lot of strange things, haven't you?" Raz asked thoughtfully.

"It's this town," Dipper admitted. "It's weird… really weird. Mabel and I have seen things we can't explain. I've been trying to learn as much as I can, but I didn't want to drag you guys into it. As you can see, it can get dangerous."

Raz entertained the possibility of searching through Dipper's memories the way he had Coraline's. There may be something in Dipper's memories that would lead them to the disturbance they were searching for. However, something gave Raz pause.

He was still feeling guilty about the way he rummaged through Coraline's memories and caused her to have a nightmare the previous night. He had wanted to find information that might lead him to the psychic disturbance, not retraumatize her.

In addition, Raz didn't really know what he was looking for. He knew Dipper and Mabel had seen weird things in the town, but would they really have information about the psychic disturbance they were looking for? There were also restrictions around looking through civilian memories, especially minors, Unless Raz had reason to believe they had information related to his mission, he wasn't supposed to go through a civilian's memories.

Raz decided that he would first try to ask Mabel and Dipper more questions about the mysterious things they have seen in Gravity Falls, as well as try and look around the town. If Raz discovered that Dipper or Mabel might know something related to the disturbance, and refused to share, then he would search through one of their memories.

"So, assuming we aren't going to be saved by a potentially hairy monster that carves arrows into trees, what should we do?" Coraline asked.

"We are just getting ourselves more lost by wandering around," Dipper said. "As much as I hate to be in this forest at night, we might have to wait for the stars to guide us out. That's usually the safest way once we are already lost."

"We have to stay out here until it gets dark?" Wybie asked nervously, glancing around.

"I know it's not the best plan," Dipper agreed, sounding just as worried. "But it's the only thing I can think of that wont get us more lost."

"Actually, Lili is really good at reading a forest," Raz spoke up. "The tree's look different the farther you go in, and Lili can notice little differences like that. We don't have to wait. We can follow her out of here. After all, she was the one that knew we were going in the wrong direction from the very beginning."

Lili didn't react to Raz's vote of confidence, but he could tell she was pleased. Raz knew Lili could use her herbaphony to get them back home easily.

At least, he hoped it would be easy. They had used a compass, gone straight, and still ended up back where they started.

"Hold on, it's because of Lili we're out here in the first place," Coraline pointed out. "How can we trust her not to get us more lost?"

"Listen, Blue." Lili sneared. "I'm the only one that can get us out of here within the next few hours. So unless you want to wait until it gets dark and the Little Dipper has to use the Big Dipper to get us home, then you'll shut your trap and follow me."

Coraline raised an eyebrow at Lili at the same time Mabel broke into a fit of giggles.

"Mabel, it wasn't that funny," Dipper said in annoyance.

"No Dip, it was hilarious!" Mabel choked out, barely able to breathe. "Little Dipper!"

"Well then..." Coraline said, a smile tugging on her lips. "I guess anything is better than nothing. Lead the way."

Lili turned around and walked past the giant tree. She was heading in the opposite direction they had been traveling in. There was hesitation from the group at first, but then everyone began following her. Raz tried to suppress the feeling inside of him that told him they were going the wrong way. He trusted Lili and she knew what she was doing.

Lili led them west, then north. Raz swore they passed the same trees that they had just minutes ago, but he kept quiet. There was one point where Lili led them around in what he thought was a definite circle only for them to end up in a completely new area.

Lili was frowning the entire time, a confused look on her face. She looked as lost as everyone else, but she seemed to put her faith in something other than her sense of direction.

They were traveling for a half an hour, but even Coraline held back her sarcastic commentary. Raz knew what Coraline was thinking without having to read her mind: Lili had either gotten them closer to home, or twice as lost.

Finally, the trees began to thin and Dipper let out a squeak of excitement. "I know where we are!" he shouted. "We're almost to the town!"

"How did you do that?" Neil asked Lili in awe.

"Like Raz said, I'm just really good at understanding plants," Lili explained with a shrug.

"Man, I it's going to be so easy navigating the forest with you around!" Dipper said with a laugh.

Lili glanced at Dipper from the corner of her eyes, her eyebrows twitching upwards in surprise.

"Yeah, not bad Plant-girl," Coraline said, nudging Lili with her shoulder playfully. "Looks like you are useful for something."

"At least one of us is," Lili said with a smirk.

Coraline rolled her eyes, but she was smiling. After a moment, Coraline's expression faltered. "So umm…" she began awkwardly. "I guess I should have trusted you earlier when you said you knew the right way to go. That was my bad."

Raz had a feeling that was as close to an apology that Lili was going to get, but from the look on Lili's face, that was more than she had been expecting.

Lili shrugged. "Whatever, Blue. One of these days you're going to figure out that I'm always right."

Rax placed his arm around his girlfriend's shoulders. "And if she's ever wrong, we'll get the bravest or the most gullible person we know to break the news to her, so the rest of us can run for cover."

Lili gave him a shove. "Shut it, Raz!"

Raz chuckled, stumbling a bit. He grabbed Lili's hand in his own as they walked, and she allowed him to. This was the first time Raz noticed that Lili was slowly starting to relax around the other kids.

Raz glanced at his girlfriend and then back at the other kids. Raz knew this mission wasn't anything like what he and Lili had expected. They went into this thinking it would be a simple recon mission. They were just supposed to find the psychic disturbance and report back to Agent Nein.

Now, they were no closer to finding the psychic disturbance, but they did find a ghost of a psychic kid with false memories, a blue haired girl who was being hunted by a terrifying otherworldly creature, a magic cabin that used to belong to witches, and an even stranger forest.

Raz hoped that whatever happened next, he and Lili would be able to handle it on their own, and the other kids wouldn't get themselves involved. However, with this group's track record for seeking out dangerous and unusual situations, Raz wasn't holding his breath.

End of Act 1

I actually finished act 1? It's been how many years and act 1 is finally complete?! I'm still having trouble believing it. This story still has two more acts to it. I have a lot of Act 2 written, but it was written a while ago, so I have to do a lot of rewriting. But at least I have a pretty good outline.

Thank you all for all your comments, they really keep me going and inspire me to continue to work on this story. Let me know what you guys thought of act 1.

If act 1 is all about meeting each other, then act 2 is about learning to trust each other, and act three… well, I wont say too much there.