Disclaimer: All Gilmore Girls content belongs to Amy Sherman-Palladino.

Chapter Thirty-Two: Of Princess Bride Past

Rushing up the stairs to the apartment, Ella almost tripped more than once. The main floor of Truncheon was empty, books shut and the sign on the front door turned to Closed. Rain showered down hard, and all manner of umbrella patterns could be seen on the sidewalk outside. Her own umbrella, collapsed and dripping, sat next to the front door. She'd practically thrown it down in her hurry. Biting down on her cheek, she was nearly out of breath by the time she made it through the apartment door. Everyone was mingling in the living room, nursing beers and waiting for the last member of the group to arrive. They looked up at the sound of her huffy entrance and offered greetings.

She barely gave anyone a glance as she hung up her raincoat and began undoing her french braid on her walk to the bedroom. "Sorry, sorry. Just give me five minutes and I won't look like a bank teller anymore."

Seven o'clock had come and gone, and she had still been stuck in the lecture hall, while her advisor gave her notes on the presentation in art history. All in all, her advisor had been impressed. But she was not one for brevity, and Ella had taken several anxious peeks at her watch during the review. It was the last day of class before spring break, and Ella was eager for the week off. She'd been so busy with midterms, she hadn't been able to make it to any of Leo's recent gigs. But he was due on stage at Keeley's between eight and eight-thirty. And there was no way she was going to the show dressed in her blazer and pencil skirt, gray and stiff. She'd worn it only because one of the oldest men on the entire faculty had been sitting in on her presentation, and Ella had heard about his penchant for professionalism.

Ella thought she heard Chris yell some crack at her outfit after her, but she had already slammed the bedroom door. She stripped out of her clothes, throwing them in the hamper with disdain. She hoped it would be some time before she would have to wear anything of the sort again. Opening up a dresser drawer, she ran her eyes over prospective outfits for the night.

Breathing a frustrated sigh, she pulled a grayish-purple babydoll dress over her head and went to sit down on the bed to tug on her fishnets. After having appraised herself in the mirror above the dresser, she decided her makeup was decent enough and touch-ups would be unnecessary. She was wearing far less than normal, anyway. She had a feeling the ancient history professor who sat in wouldn't exactly smile upon thick eyeliner or dark lipstick. The need to change her look simply to please the man made her skin crawl, but she could see no other way out. He had once ordered a graduate student out from behind the podium because his shirt had a stain.

The next time she was in class, though, she would be back in her grungy attire. Just putting on the fishnets made her feel more comfortable than she had been all day. She reached under the bed, grabbed her Doc Martens, and laced them up faster than she previously thought was humanly possible.

She was about to go back out into the living room, prepared to return to the flooded streets at a moment's notice. But then she passed the mirror again and, on second thought, decided she simply couldn't stand not doing something interesting with her face. She swiped on some dark wine-colored lipstick and gave herself a tiny cateye with a trained, precise hand. Having done winged liner on and off since high school, she found practice had made her skilled enough to get it right on the first try about half the time. It was perhaps her greatest accomplishment in life.

Grabbing her secondhand leather jacket, she trudged back out into the living room. She ran her fingers through her hair a few more times, untangling the remnants of her braid and smoothing down the dark blonde waves.

"We wouldn't have been late even if we left thirty minutes from now," Matthew said, standing up with Mabel by his side.

"Well, on time is late, and early is on time," she replied, crossing her arms over her chest.

Chris rolled his eyes as he also rose, from his armchair, and made his way to the coat rack. "Were you the hall monitor or something in high school?"

Jess snorted a laugh, his nose still buried in a Hunter Thompson book where he sat on the couch. "Far from it."

"The hell's that supposed to mean, Mariano?" she asked, furrowing her brows.

Smirking, Jess shut his book and tossed it on the coffee table. He went to grab his black jacket, while everyone mingled by the door, ready to brave the weather on the short walk to Keeley's. "You threatened to stab me the first time you met me."

"With a butterknife," Ella countered defensively.

The rest of the group snickered, exiting the apartment and filing down the stairs.

"Ah, young love," Chris teased. His pale cheeks were rosy, his blue eyes wide with excitement. Despite how much of a pain in the ass he could be, Ella felt her heart warmed to see how proud he was of his boyfriend.

"I thought he was trying to rob the diner," Ella continued, grabbing her umbrella again before they went out onto the grimy, damp streets.

The rain had lessened slightly, to a chilly drizzle, but was still wet against her face. Jess took the umbrella from her, then interlaced their fingers with his free hand. She glanced up at him in thanks, and he winked in response. She could feel the scar from where the knife had sliced him the night they planned for their first date.

"Quite the menace, was he?" Matthew asked over his shoulder. Mabel had her arm linked with his, following along with the conversation. They had known her for a few weeks, but Ella suspected she hadn't quite become comfortable. She was more timid than Ella expected for an actress, but she was truly sweet. Wore her heart on her sleeve, a quality Ella also recognized in Matthew.

"Oh yeah. Dennis was his middle name," Ella smiled nostalgically. "Think if Sid Vicious and Elvis had a baby. Whose big moves are stealing gnomes and doing close-up magic."

Chris laughed out loud, nudging Jess in the ribs. Jess blushed, glaring at Ella.

"Aw, were you a little Criss Angel wannabe?" Chris crooned, mocking.

Jess rolled his eyes. "I was not. It seemed to charm Eleanor just fine, anyhow."

"I was young and misguided," she said wistfully.

"And you were tripping over your own feet at least once a week," Jess chimed in. "Though, not much has changed on that front."

Ella scoffed. "You worked at Walmart."

"You bought a Train album!"

"That was one time!"

"Once is plenty!"

Staring at him for a long moment, she finally uttered a defeated sigh. "You're right. Train sucks."

"Sure does," Chris chimed in with an amused grin, then shook his head at them fondly and linked up ahead with Mabel and Matthew.

"You've won the battle, Mariano," she warned, pointing a finger at him. "Not the war."

"Believe me, I know," he replied, squeezing her hand affectionately, a smirk on his face. "How'd your presentation go today?"

Ella's face lost a bit of its mirth and she shrugged, dejected. "Okay, I think. My advisor said I was talking too fast, but otherwise I did well. We'll see."

"I bet they didn't know what hit 'em, honey. I mean, we practiced like fifty times. You had it word-for-word last night," he said, growing more earnest. "I'm sure you were amazing."

She averted her eyes from him. "Maybe. I felt like I was getting suffocated up there wearing those clothes, though."

"I don't know. It wasn't the worst outfit," Jess said. "It had a certain American Psycho thing going for it."

"And that's good?" she asked with a doubtful chuckle.

"Not good, per say, but definitely interesting," he replied, nonchalant. "I can't believe you can do things like that. Just get up there and speak. I would pass out on the spot."

"Well, then I'm glad you've got a job where you can be all Phantom of the Opera and hide out in that tiny office all day," she said with a grin.

Over the past few weeks, the guys had finally turned the back rooms of Truncheon, previously just storage space, into offices. Each one could barely hold a desk, but they were enough. Jess had already collected an impressive pile of books in one corner. The Hudson River sketch sat in a small frame next to his bulky, aged computer.

"Yep. Counting my blessings," he quipped flatly as they approached the bar.

. . .

For once, the St. Patrick's Day decorations hung year-round at Keeley's were semi-appropriate, with the holiday having been only a week past. They shone, green and tacky, in the yellow light of the main room. Leo sat on a stool on the small stage, doing his final number. An array of instruments were set out around him: guitars, tambourines, a keyboard, a bass. His closing song was played on a ruan, a Chinese lute he'd bought as a teen on a trip to visit his grandparents, when he was just beginning to write his own music. Ella thought it was perhaps his versatility that made Leo such an incredible musician. As only a half-decent piano player, she couldn't imagine learning something with strings or sticks. She had no idea how he had picked up so many different skills.

Chris, Matthew and Mabel were all floating in the middle distance somewhere between buzzed and fully drunk, nursing local beers and watching Leo with thoughtful, glazed eyes. Both Jess and Ella sipped on club soda, sat in the booth across the table from their friends. No matter how much Ella insisted she didn't care if Jess drank, he never really did. He thought it was a pretty good idea, considering his own mother's history with addiction. And what was the point of being drunk if Ella wasn't going to be drunk with him? It would be no fun if he couldn't go on the ride with her, anyway.

The crowd had been lively when they first arrived, tables packed and customers chatty. But as the evening wore on, parties left, congestion dissipated. A few lonely individuals sat solemnly at the main bar. Leo had a moderately receptive audience, though the band performing before him had a bit more notoriety and a larger fan-base. By the final number, only the five of them remained at their half-table, half-booth, looking on with pride and intrigue. Ella thought she had never seen Chris smile so big as he did at Leo's gigs. The starry gaze was a bit saccharine, but most of the time it was tolerable, and even cute.

"He's really good," Mabel said softly as Leo reached the instrumental.

"Isn't he?" Ella whispered back across the table emphatically.

Mabel nodded, her bright brown eyes sparkling. "His voice kinda reminds me of The Smiths"

Ella's smile widened. "I love them!"

"Oh, they were basically all I listened to in high school," Mabel said, nodding in agreement.

"Not you too," Jess chagrined from beside Ella, his arm around her shoulders.

"What?" Mabel asked, raising one of her thick eyebrows. Ella wished she could have Mabel's eyebrows. They seemed to be shaped perfectly, and didn't even need to be filled in.

"Jess thinks he's too good for indie," Ella said.

"No, I just never find myself in the mood to listen to some guy whine into the microphone," Jess said, scoffing slightly.

Ella shook her head in disappointment. "It's poetry!"

"Even worse," Jess retorted.

She rolled her eyes at him, but didn't respond as Leo began singing again. Jess's fingers ghosted over her shoulder up and down, making pleasant goosebumps rise on her freckled skin. As Leo's voice rolled gently over the last few words of the song, Ella closed her eyes and felt the notes vibrate in her chest. Jess looked over and found her looking calm, far away inside her mind as she listened. He pressed a kiss to her hair and a tiny smile passed over her lips, though she didn't open her eyes until the final chord finished its reverberation through the room. The five of them erupted in cheers and applause, which sounded scant in the nearly empty place. Leo smirked at them from the stage and gave a mocking bow.

"They say the underground following is the most devoted," he muttered into the mic, stripping off his ruan. Then, he looked up at the large clock across the room. "But since we've still got ten minutes left, why don't we get secret musical prodigy Ella Stevens up here?"

Ella's brow crinkled with confusion, and her smile faltered. "What?"

"You never told me about the piano thing! C'mon, take advantage of this keyboard," Leo called over the mic.

She glared over at Chris, who pretended not to feel her eyes on him. "What did you tell him?"

After a moment, Chris slowly craned his neck in her direction. "Who? Me?"

"Asshole," she hissed under her breath, narrowing her eyes.

"Hey, I was simply relaying what little interesting information exists about you," he said, raising his hands in surrender.

Ella ran her finger horizontal across her neck, a teasing threat.

"We don't have all night, Ella," Leo continued into the mic.

"Yeah, let's hear it, Ella. I'm sure you're great," Mabel said genuinely, leaning over the table, conspiratory and cheerful. The positivity would have been annoying if Mabel were not so down-to-earth.

"Agreed," Matthew chimed in.

Ella laughed bitterly, shaking her head. "No one wants to subject their ears to that, I promise."

"I don't know, Stevens. I was pretty starstruck the one time I heard you play in all six years I've known you," Jess smirked, eyebrows raised.

"Judas," she spat at him, removing his arm from her shoulder.

"If you can get up in front of two hundred people to talk about the effect of the lost generation on modern art, you can do this, Daria," he continued, unphased by her grouchiness.

Heaving an ambivalent sigh, she listened to their persistent encouragement. Then, with one final huff of obstinacy, she stood from the table and marched up to the stage. She flipped them off behind her head as they gave hoots of satisfaction and Leo set the keyboard up at the front of the stage, with the stool and microphone.

"I'll never forgive you for this," she whispered to Leo.

He gave a nod, humoring her. "Yes, I fear you."

"Well," she said sardonically, sitting down and watching as he descended the stairs. "In a minute, you'll pity me. I did not inherit my mother's talent!"

She felt her heart expand when she saw Chris give Leo a congratulatory kiss before they settled into their seats next to each other. Then, she rolled her eyes at herself for not sticking to her ill will, and dropped her eyes to the keys. They were shiny white and black, newer but less charming than the piano at Miss Patty's. Her fingers were poised over the keys, and she swallowed dryly, remembering. She'd couldn't quite place when the last time she'd played had been.

Glancing up nervously, biting the inside of her cheek, she caught Jess's eye. He threw her another wink and she let out a scoff at him. The longer she sat up there, the more her heart slowed. She straightened her back, felt herself regaining the old position. Resisting the urge to tug anxiously at her earring, she flipped for a moment through her mental catalogue. Then, she cleared her throat and let a small, wicked grin cross her lips.

"Fine. But this is your funeral, everyone," she quipped. "This song is dedicated to Chris, who is fucking wrong about Joni Mitchell."

A final, slight shake of her head and she launched into "Blue." Her fingers were rusty and creaky, but the song flowed out of her as though she had just learned it. She couldn't sing nearly as high as was necessary for an exact recreation, but she was getting at more of a tuned down interpretation. Her voice was raspy, and Jess was never surprised how much she identified with Stevie Nicks. Though recently, there had been more Amy Winehouse spinning on the turntable. And Ella knew she could never sound remotely like Amy Winehouse.

The stage light was whitish and soft, and Jess could feel his heart do a skip at the sight of her. She wasn't the greatest musical talent, but it wasn't pure talent which made her breathtaking to him. It was the way her eyes shut and her voice lilted with emotion. How she lit up so wholly when she played. And how fearless she had always been, putting herself out there with not a care in the world for what others thought of her. No stage fright, only perfectionism holding her back. She was only ever completely herself, perhaps what he admired most about her. His intrepid artist, with dimples and green flecks in her eyes and messy hair and a fashion sense not quite like anyone else. Warmth filled his heart and his body and his mind, and he could only watch her with a tiny smirk on his face. And he had never felt so sure of anything before.

. . .

The cap of the red pen was clamped between her teeth, her back against the wall, Nietzche staring overhead. Suppressing a yawn, she placed brackets around a paragraph she liked particularly well. Her first read-through of the new book had taken almost no time at all, as she devoured Jess's prose fervently. She'd suggested some revisions, added some comments, without being asked. Jess insisted she didn't have to do that work for him, especially not for free, but she told him she simply enjoyed it. It reminded her of the days when they wrote notes to each other in borrowed texts, those which ended up sitting in a shared pile, all mixed together, in their bedroom. And he had only smiled in response. Once again, it had shocked him how invested she could be in art. Not that he would ever call his writing 'art,' especially how much he despised his first novel upon rereading. But Ella asked for the second draft once he had revised, offering her critical eye, if he wanted it. He did, of course. And she was nearly done. There were noticeable improvements, and several new sections. It was coming together before her eyes, and sometimes she wanted to tear up out of pride.

Breeze seeped in through the draughty window, and she tugged the blanket up over herself a little more. Her impromptu performance at the bar, which ended with her flustered in the wake of everyone's compliments even though she was aware she was nothing compared to Leo, had left her jittery and awake. Even after the presentation at school. Not exactly anxious, but charged with pseudo energy. She was only riding it until the crash. Jess wasn't snoring yet, and she knew he wasn't asleep, but dozing. Midnight had already passed into the early morning, and the rain was picking up again, pounding on the roof above them. Every so often, Ella looked precariously up at the water spot near the bedroom door.

Sighing faintly, she turned the page, more semi-stream-of-consciousness insights after a perspective shift. She had to commend him on his recent experimentation. She hadn't expected it. Her face softened as she read the next paragraph, a new addition to the draft. It was through the eyes of the main character as he watched a woman paint a mural on a nondescript city street.

Racing, racing, racing of his heart, beating against his ribs like footsteps at the sight of the woman. Eyes from bottom to top, from battered shoes to patterned skirt and button-up shirt, protected by a dirty, threadbare apron. Strangers, he thought, strangers everywhere with separate stories to tell, unaware of his thoughts or his feelings or his words or his face. She looked like she belonged, despite her complete uniquity. He couldn't imagine looking so established in any place, so uniform in unconformity. He wondered who she was painting it for, the ghostly figure surrounded by dead flowers and trash, a vision of the post-industrial American wasteland. Not many people were likely to see it under the bridge, which looked like where teenagers would come to smash light bulbs and kiss each other with teeth clashing together and sweat out their last bit of rebellion. He wondered who had assigned her the location, if she had chosen it herself, if she was painting only for herself.

The intensity in her eyes told him she could have been, green pools of vigor and concentration as he approached, boots rhythmic on the cracked sidewalk. A tragedy, he thought suddenly, staring at her near-finished creation, she was painting a tragedy and she knew it. She could feel it. He saw it not so much in her form as in the eyes of the ghost in the painting, hollow and desolate, with a single jewel of color in the middle. The rest of the piece was only in shades of gray, a hopelessness exacerbated by more small, foolish hope. He almost laughed under his breath, instead allowing his eyes to fall back on her as he passed around her, leaving considerable space between them. He didn't want to interfere, break her focus, not that she looked as though she could ever be shaken by anything. Their eyes locked for only a moment, as she stepped back to regard her work. She didn't smile, she didn't frown, she only saw. She saw, and then she was out of sight again. And another story was behind him.

Smirking slightly as she read, she capped the pen again once she had finished. And she placed the manuscript on the bedside table neatly next to her. She switched off the last lamp and settled down into the sheets. Jess breathed deeply, stirring at her movements. She turned over on one side to face him, their noses only inches apart.

"Jess?" she asked.

"Hm?" he hummed, eyes cracking open.

"Can't sleep?"

"I'm getting there," he shrugged, though they both knew it wasn't exactly the truth.

Ella nodded. "Well, I got to the part where he sees the woman painting the mural. And I have to say, I think I recognize the influences."

He rolled his eyes. "Fine. Maybe James Joyce wasn't completely incoherent. It wasn't serious, though. It was meant to be making fun of his adolescent emotionality, like Stephen in Portrait."

"Ah, I think I've officially converted you," she said, her smile growing wider.

"I think you're speaking too soon," he replied.

"Agree to disagree." Her tone was light and sincere as she continued, though her smile shrank. "Did you really love me when you first saw me?"

"Yeah."

"That's it, Chatty Kathy?" she asked, eyebrows raised in annoyance.

Jess sighed. "Well, what do you wanna know?"

"I don't know. I'm trying to understand it," she said, studying his face with narrowed eyes. If he knew the section she had just read, he shouldn't have been surprised by the question. Besides, she had been wondering for a while. How someone who had been bitten by the world so many times could still believe something so romantic. In a way, she was envious, and in another way, she was scared for him. "Why did you tell me it was that day in the gazebo?"

He paused for a long moment, running his hand over his mouth. She could see his grandfather's necklace peeking out from the collar of his t-shirt and glinting in the moonlight, which streamed through the window. He barely ever took it off.

"Well, first of all, I knew there was no chance you'd run away with me if you thought I was crazy enough to believe in love at first sight," he explained slowly, trying to ignore the embarrassed squirming in his stomach. "I was trying not to scare you off. Shocking, I know, considering what a Romeo and Juliet stunt I was pulling."

"He could've just waited to drink the poison," she agreed, earning her a chuckle.

"And, at the time," he continued, growing a bit more confident in his articulation, "I wasn't even sure. For a long time, I couldn't figure out when I fell in love with you. Eventually, I realized the reason was because I had been in love with you the entire time."

She hummed, her brows furrowing inquisitively. "I just can't imagine it."

"Which is why the amount of poetry you read will never make sense," he said. Then, after a moment more of gathering his thoughts: "And it's not the same kind of love. It's still love, but it's not the same as what I felt after I got to know you."

"What do you mean?" she asked.

Breathing out a long breath, Jess searched again for the right phrases.

"I don't know, Stevens," he admitted, biting down on his lip for a moment. "Maybe it's more like I knew I would love you. I saw you, and I knew I loved you before I knew why I loved you. Now, I know why."

She nodded earnestly against her pillow, damp hair smelling of lavender. "Curiouser and curiouser, Mariano."

"Not to the Hemingway fans among us," he said.

"Well, Hemingway fans are the biggest romantics. It's a universal law," she replied, voice growing heavier with fatigue. Finally, it seemed, the rush of the night was wearing off, replaced by a tranquil ease she hadn't expected. Spring break was long overdue.

"So I've heard," he replied fondly. "I told you the first time we met, y'know."

"What?"

"That I loved you."

She furrowed her brows suspiciously, a smirk tugging at one corner of her lips. "I think I would've remembered that."

"Well, I didn't say it in so many words." Jess's eyes twinkled with teasing, and she scoffed.

"You did not."

"Yes, I certainly did."

"Shut up."

"I'm serious, Daria."

Her face lost its brevity as she saw he was, in fact, serious, despite how cocky he sounded. Playing the memory over in her mind, she was hit was nostalgia and confusion. Humming Stevie Nicks, spilling salt, empty threats, cleaning tables with Jess following behind her, never losing his wiseass remarks or his sarcastic grin. Then, after a moment, it hit her. As you wish. She had hardly noticed it at the time. Only a reference, leading to their first argument over movies versus books. The words Wesley had spoken to Buttercup in The Princess Bride as a way of saying 'I love you.' She never even considered its meaning.

She let out a breathy, surprised chuckle. Meeting his eyes again, she shoved his shoulder playfully and flipped onto her back. She stared up at the ceiling, noticing the water spot again. The raindrops pattered a steady beat. "Fuck off."

"What?" he asked, propping himself up on one elbow and tilting his head at her in amused askance.

"Jesus. That is so...sweet and wonderful. And fucking cheesy. Makes me sick," she said, though she grinned through her words. She sighed and shook her head slightly, closing her eyes and pinching the bridge of her nose as she giggled again. "I don't know whether to murder you or marry you."

His breath caught in his throat for a second, but he regained his composure before she opened her eyes again and smiled up at him. "Well, maybe meet me in the middle and let's get our own apartment?"

"Really?" she asked. So much information was flying at her, she didn't know which thread to latch onto. And, unbeknownst to Jess, she was fighting the lump in her throat. She may have been a realist, but she wasn't heartless. And she wondered how long she would be able to hold off the tears that threatened to spill over. A deep, aching love spread throughout her. It almost made her dizzy with joy. As you wish, he had said. It played over in her head suddenly, as though she had just heard it.

"Yeah," he said, averting his gaze hesitantly. "It doesn't have to be right away. There'll probably be more leases in the summer once all the students go home. But I thought...maybe we'd have room for a keyboard or something. An easel, too. And we could stop hearing Chris and Matthew argue over which place has the best burritos at three in the morning. What do you think?"

"We could get an actual shelf for all your books," she said, holding her smile.

"Yeah. You could organize them whatever way, if you want." Jess tucked a loose strand of hair behind her ear as he spoke, then leaving his hand to rest on her cheek. "Or, I could do it. There is a method to my madness, y'know."

"Okay, I'll definitely need a couple months to decide whether to do color coordination or alphabetical order, then," she said.

Jess chuckled. "Yeah, we'll take some time. But...you want to?"

"Yeah. Yeah, I do, James Dean," she whispered softly. She placed a gentle hand on the back of his neck, and brought him in to place a sweet kiss on his lips. He smiled against her, nerves calming and body relaxing with her touch.

As they broke apart, he laid back down on his side, drawing her closer to him with an arm over her waist.

"I love you, Mariano," she said, eyes fluttering shut.

"Love you back, Stevens," he replied, thinking he may not be able to handle the pleasant butterflies erupting in his middle.

She breathed in contentedly. "And your new book is the next Great American Novel."

"I doubt the New York Times will think so."

"Well, I do," she said simply. "You're the fucking best."

"It's been said," he quipped, finally shutting his own eyes. Their words had turned to murmurs, cozy and soft beneath the sound of the rain.

"But, I especially love how humble you are," she added, yawning against the back of her hand.

"Right back at ya," he deadpanned.

Snorting a laugh, Ella shifted so she was flush against him, warm in the cold room. And, by the time the sun rose through the breaking clouds, the rain had stopped completely.

Author's Note: Thank you for reading! Please let me know what you thought! Feedback nourishes my soul!

ForeverTeamEdward13: Ah! Thank you! Hope you liked this update!