Disclaimer: All Gilmore Girls content belongs to Amy Sherman-Palladino.
Chapter Thirty-Five: Really, Marcia?
Dropping the bags again in the apartment above Luke's almost made Ella want to laugh out loud. Maybe she shouldn't have made such a big deal of leaving the diner to move to Philadelphia; she felt like she almost couldn't escape Connecticut. The trip, this time, was planned in advance, however. Both Adam and Rory were graduating, and Jess's new sister had been born only a week earlier. Much was to be done, many people to visit. It made Ella feel slightly overwhelmed, the prescribed familial nonsense. Going back to Stars Hollow was easier when she could just casually pop into Luke's or her home, and then drive away in the Station Wagon with Jess in the passenger seat and Liz Phair on the radio whenever she felt compelled. But the graduation had a scheduled time, Rory's graduation party had a scheduled time. There was no getting out of it.
For a moment, she had thought about staying back in her old room in the little blue house. She felt as though they were taking advantage of Luke staying over at his place as often as they did. But then it occurred to her that she had no real idea what her room looked like anymore. The few times she'd been over in recent years, she hadn't even ventured past the threshold of the small hallway, her door the second on the right. She felt maybe it was better to leave the room the way it had been in her memory. She was not in the business of reopening old wounds for no reason other than curiosity.
There was also the issue of her father. Fiona had been cagey at best about Jake on the phone. Would he even show up to the graduation? Surely he would. Even Noah had traveled back home, for the first time in years, though without his fiancé. She was a nurse, and hadn't been able to get away from the midnight shifts. He was a paralegal, though, and had been able to swing a Saturday afternoon graduation. But, still, there was a gnawing feeling in her stomach. A fear he would simply not show. He had been at her high school graduation, with his robotic hugs and teary eyes and the usual detached way about him. It hadn't been warm and fuzzy, but he had been there for her. He had clapped as she crossed the stage. And, as far as Ella was concerned, Adam deserved more than she ever got from Jake. Adam called often, and seemed to get along rather well with Fiona, but remained flighty about their father. She could count on him changing the subject every time Jake was brought up.
"Hey! Eleanor," Jess said, breaking her from her reverie.
She blinked harshly and jumped at the sound of his voice. Slowly, she turned her gaze away from the view of the window above Luke's kitchen sink. Town square was decorated with florals, and the troubadour stood playing an upbeat, folksy tune on one of the corners. And, as she thought about her family, it had all struck her as a bit plastic. It seemed impossible for so much heartache to happen to her while living in a place like Stars Hollow, but it had. In spite of the sunshiney smiles and the constant offerings for help. Probably why she got along with Jess so well, who understood more than anyone she had ever met what it was to feel a pain she could truly recognize. Luke, too. She wondered at how many people milling down on the sidewalk were concealing all of their hurt for the sake of maintaining a positive, cheerful facade. The farther away the years took her from her upbringing, the more reasons she felt she was better off somewhere other than her hometown. She had never quite been able to polish her outward mold, could never keep it all under wraps. Instead, she ended up cursing out kids who tried to steal random shit from the diner or punishing herself through constant schoolwork and lack of sleep, all to keep her problems from making it from her mind to her mouth. And, most of the time, she had slipped up eventually. Once more, her father came to her mind. He hadn't been able to wear a convincing mask, either.
"...yeah?" she asked, then looked down to realize the glass she had been filling with cold water from the tap was overflowing onto her hand.
Quickly, she shut off the sink and sipped carefully at the drink, until it was back down to a manageable level. She switched it to the other hand and shook off the wetness, though it hadn't felt unwelcome after having just come in from the May heat. Jess smirked quizzically at her, from where he stood at the fridge. They were meant to have a late lunch and then go over to Liz's house and meet the baby, Doula. Despite how much Luke was making fun of it, Ella couldn't say she hated the name.
"Jeez, Stevens. Where'd you go?" Jess's voice was lilted and smug as he pulled some leftover sandwiches from the fridge. Luke had instructed them to finish off whatever diner cast-offs they could find. It reminded Jess of his teen years, tense dinners with Luke at the small kitchen table, eating stale food which had been prepped but never actually ordered. And he felt an odd, surprising jolt of nostalgia. But his face didn't show it.
She shook her head at herself, placing her glass down on the table and grabbing the cutlery as Jess put the leftovers out on the table buffet-style. It reminded her of the way he arranged a meal on her kitchen table the night they'd watched the prom scene of Carrie together, when he'd brought her a care package because she had a migraine and then refused to admit to it later. And, for the most fleeting of moments, she was in the past and they were the people they had once been. A fond smirk tugged at her lips as she sat down, plates and forks in hand.
"Nowhere," she replied finally, her voice a sigh. Before Jess could ask anything further, she gave him a pointed glance as she piled some cold mashed potatoes onto her plate and continued. "You sure you're okay going to Liz's house today? We could always wait until tomorrow morning, then we could have an excuse to leave and go get ready for the graduation."
He seemed to consider the idea of a moment as he took his first bite of meatloaf, then shook his head. "No. Let's just rip the bandaid off."
"That's the spirit when you're going to see a new baby," she quipped.
"I can guarantee the baby will be easier to handle than Liz and TJ, no matter how much she cries," Jess grumbled, looking down at his food.
Ella bit the inside of her cheek and leveled him with her eyes. Each time they returned to Stars Hollow, he seemed to get more anxious about it. At first, it was because the entire town had hated him as a teen. But it got much worse when Liz moved there. She thought it strange how much everyone seemed to discount how Jess felt about this, how much Luke complained about her. How much they expected Jess to get over what he was feeling and play dutiful son. It reminded her of the way she felt she needed to treat her own father after her mother died. Though the sexist bullshit about her being the 'woman of the house' had also played a part. She knew how Luke felt about family, how he would always show up for family regardless of circumstance. Maybe Jess was the same way, loyal to a fault. But maybe it was only for his chosen family. Maybe the rest of it was more because of all the outward pressure he faced.
She reached over and ran a hand through his hand, smoothing it out. For a moment, she thought of saying something, but decided it wasn't the right time to start a conversation about Jess's childhood, or the lingering effects he still wouldn't acknowledge. Not right before seeing his mother. She was trying hard lately to be patient, despite the way his eyes became guarded at the mention of his new sister or his mother, or the increased frequency of his nightmares. It was getting worse before her eyes and she didn't know why. But Jess was Jess. And he wasn't going to see it until he was ready to. It almost physically pained her, the effort of swallowing down the words, but she bit her tongue nonetheless.
He offered her a lazy, lopsided smile in return.
. . .
His grip on her hand was tight as they made their way into Liz and TJ's house, just as gaudy and eclectic as Ella remembered from the baby shower. She might've even found it charming if it weren't for the screaming color of the decor. The place smelled of burnt toast and sour milk, and Ella was instantly glad she and Jess had chosen to eat beforehand, just in case Liz asked them to stay for dinner. The scent was overpowered only by the strong perfume Liz was wearing, which Ella couldn't ignore as Liz pulled her in for a big hug of greeting.
"Come in, come in," Liz said in her high, sing-song voice as she led them down the front hall and into the living room. "She's just waking up from nap!"
The room was littered with toys, empty bottles, blankets, story books Doula wouldn't be able to read for years. But it was sweet. Ella could see how much they'd been preparing, planning. For a second, she was relieved about it, but then the feeling mixed with a distasteful sadness. Jess had never specifically addressed his bedtime routine as a child, but Ella was fairly positive Liz had never read him Goodnight Moon. She gave his hand a final squeeze before disentangling their fingers and sitting down on the paisley patterned couch. Liz lifted Doula up from the bassinet in the corner by the rocking chair. Ella could barely see the baby beneath the patchwork quilt she was swaddled in. Doula fussed for a moment, and Liz smiled at the two of them apologetically.
"She needs a change. I'll be right back!" she said, retreating back into the bedroom. "Make yourselves comfortable!"
"Okay. Thanks," Ella replied cordially. She looked back at Jess as his mother exited the room. "You okay?"
He shrugged, his eyes surveying the clutter. "I guess so. It's just weird still. All of this."
Ella hummed, nodding.
"And I'm not really used to the whole baby thing yet. I've never even held one before," Jess said, slightly sheepish and slightly curious. He crossed his arms over the Metallica logo on his worn t-shirt. He'd taken a half day working at Truncheon before they left for Connecticut, and was always happy to change into less professional attire after his shifts.
"I know, but it'll be easy. Unless TJ pops out and sings that song the frog does in Looney Tunes. Then is the only instance when you'd be even slightly at risk of dropping her," Ella assured him, leaning back into the overstuffed couch.
She'd gleaned from their conversation the night before that his inexperience with children was also not helping his nerves. The only time she'd ever recalled Jess interacting with kids for any real length of time was the one Thanksgiving she'd brought him to meet her family. But even then, she'd been surprised how easily he'd wowed Erin with his card tricks, and played along with her jokes. Not something she'd exactly expected from the boy who wore a battered leather jacket and a constant scowl and a scarred heart on his sleeve.
"Why do you always worry he's gonna do that?" Jess asked, cracking a smile for the first time since they'd walked in.
"I told you! He sang it to me one time when I was working and he was hanging out at the diner. He was trying to figure out what song to serenade your mom with," she explained, eyes wide and utterly serious. "I was just wiping down the counter, minding my own business, and he just appeared, like, right over my shoulder."
Jess rolled his eyes at the story, remembering when Ella had first told him about it over one of their phone calls, back when they were hundreds of miles apart. "Well, it doesn't seem like he's here right now."
"I didn't think he was in the diner when it happened," Ella countered, her voice jokingly grave.
Jess chuckled but didn't have a chance to respond as Liz reentered the room. A large smile stood out on her face, the baby dressed in a soft punk onesie in her arms. Doula squirmed around a little and cooed, but didn't seem altogether unhappy.
"Ready to meet your little sister, Jess?" Liz asked, coming over and preparing to put Doula in Jess's arms before he even had a chance to answer.
"Guess so," he muttered hastily, eyes widening.
"Just be careful with her head," Ella offered, watching as Liz hovered over her son, placing her daughter's head in the crook of his arm.
Jess was surprised at how naturally his other arm moved to cradle her. She felt so light, it was as though he was holding nothing at all. Her skin was slightly flushed from the warmth of the quilt she'd been napping in, and he could feel the heat against his arms and his chest, through his t-shirt. His heart fluttered around anxiously in his chest, and he couldn't help the slight trembling in his hands, but he was pretty sure he had a good grip on her. Liz straightened up again, looking down at the two of them. Jess almost couldn't take his eyes off the baby, embarrassed at how awestruck he was. Ella's nieces were the youngest kids he had ever been in contact with. He had never met someone when they were only a week old before.
"Isn't she something?" Liz said, hands on her hips. "She looked a lot like Danny Devito when she first came out, but I think she's finally getting past that early ugly baby phase."
Jess hummed in absent acknowledgement, but said nothing. Doula had thin wisps of blonde hair, and pudgy, rosy cheeks. Her fingers were curled into small fists, her legs scrunched up. He wondered vaguely if she was going to fall back asleep, since it seemed she couldn't keep her eyes open for very long. She smelled like rash cream, but he couldn't bring himself to be annoyed at it.
"Yeah, she's beautiful, Liz," Ella answered, though her gaze went back and forth between the baby and Jess. She couldn't think of a time when she'd seen his eyes so clear and full of wonder before. She'd been too young to hold a newborn when Adam arrived, but she remembered the feeling of holding Erin as a baby, in the hospital just hours after Julie had given birth to her. It was certainly a unique feeling, and she felt her heart swell at the thought of Jess getting to experience it.
Glancing back at the kitchen for a moment, Liz once again gained a frantic tone in her voice. But, after having known her for so long, Ella knew it wasn't unusual. Liz was the kind of person who put her coffee cup on the top of her car while unlocking the door, and then drove away without remembering it, the mug shattering and coffee splattering on the road behind her.
"Damn, I was just makin' a bottle when you guys got here. TJ usually does that stuff, but dinner got a little burned. He had to go get some Plan B takeout. Let me finish with the formula," Liz said, making her way back towards the opening into the kitchen. "You guys okay with her for a second?"
"Yeah. Fine," Jess answered, surprising Ella.
Just as Liz left again, Doula opened her eyes once more. But instead of letting them shut, she kept them open. She stared up at Jess, her large brown eyes meeting his and doing their best to focus on his face.
"She's got a withering stare," he murmured.
"Isn't so hard, is it?" Ella shifted a little closer to him, leaning over his shoulder to see Doula. "You didn't have to be nervous."
"Yeah, maybe not," Jess said quietly, a small smile on his face as he glanced over at Ella.
. . .
Back when she graduated high school, there had been rain. The day before, they'd had to move the ceremony preparation into the small auditorium. People were squished inside, standing up in the aisles once the seats ran out. Ella's valedictorian speech had been a bit more than daunting with a bunch of irritated family and friends facing her, those who had traveled miles to Stars Hollow only to be packed into the smelly room like sardines. She supposed having graduation outside in the gazebo was better. The class size was small at Stars Hollow High, but it was best when everyone still had personal space. The one downside was the heat. Connecticut was not usually up near ninety degrees in late May, but a pocket of dry air was currently sitting atop the state, moving at a glacial pace.
Ella and Jess had sat sweating on some lawn chairs. While Julie and her husband Michael, who still lived in the same small house in New Britain, were on Ella's other side, trying to get their girls to sit through the ceremony to moderate success. Annie's wild curls were blowing in the scorching wind as she sat on her father's lap, reading the small storybook she'd brought with her. Erin, on the other hand, just about to cross over into adolescence and middle school, had folded her arms sullenly over her chest and rolled her eyes at nearly every name called up to receive a diploma. Ella didn't imagine she would've reacted much better at that age, being forced to sit out in the heat for hours only to watch Adam be handed a piece of paper. Noah had been on the far side of their row of seats, in his plain clothes, looking stoic as usual. He would be leaving just after the fanfare ended. He'd stayed at a motel the night before, with perhaps even less desire to stay in the little blue house than Ella had.
The valedictorian speeches were actually pretty good, but long. Adam would've been giving one if he hadn't stopped trying in every one of his classes except for those involving science during his senior year. Ella respected the decision though. She had never found any application for calculus in adult life, no matter how hard she had worked at it in high school.
Fiona and Jake had shown up, together for some reason, ten minutes late. No seats were left near Ella, or anyone else in the family. Instead, they were relegated to the far back row. Her brows furrowed at their entrance, but they didn't get close enough to Ella for her to say anything. Jess had brought her arm around her shoulder as she watched them pass her without so much as a look, and took to whispering jokes about their old principal in her ear. It didn't work as well to distract her as he had hoped, but it had still earned him a laugh or two, which was far from nothing.
As they all stood around afterwards, under the shade of some trees behind the old gazebo, congratulating Adam, Ella couldn't shake the thoughts of her parents from her mind. She wondered how different the day would be if her mother had lived. Would her parents still be together? Probably. Despite the problems they hid, the ones Ella had become more aware of the older she got, they did love each other. No matter how much her mother laid down and took Jake's outbursts and his alcoholism, and no matter how much her father ignored Sophia's distracted nature and inability to decide on anything in life, they loved each other. And, the thought struck her suddenly, that maybe everything would have been easier to swallow if they hadn't loved each other so much. It would have been easier to accept how quickly everything fell apart, and how quickly her father had found someone new to fill the hole in his heart.
"You okay?" Jess asked, close to her ear as they lingered amongst the group, pictures having been taken and pleasantries having been exchanged.
"Just peachy," she replied, unable to hide the bitterness in her voice.
"Yeah, I can see that," he said, pressing a kiss to the crown on her head and giving her hand another squeeze. It hadn't taken him long to gather how angry seeing her father again had made Ella. He wondered when the last time had been.
"I could do without the Brady Bunch performance," she whispered back to him, gesturing to the members of her family as they continued with fabricated niceties.
"Really, Marcia? But you're the oldest sister! That means you would've been prom queen!" Jess teased.
She rolled her eyes and snorted a laugh. "Whatever, Wally Logan."
Approaching the two of them with narrowed eyes, Erin still had her arms crossed over her frilly dress. She had more than one bandaid on each knee, and she had already pulled the french braid out of her red hair. Speaking mostly to Ella, she sized Jess up.
"I remember him," Erin said suspiciously.
A confused, bemused grin crossed Ella's face. "Yeah. At Thanksgiving. You were like five. You remember that?"
"I have a really good memory," Erin said, shrugging, confident and casual.
Ella chuckled at the flippant ten-year-old.
"Photographic, huh?" Jess asked, eyebrows raised.
"Pretty close," Erin replied, then focused her eyes back on Ella. "Did you ever figure out his middle name?"
"Sure did," Ella answered, smirk growing. "You wanna hear it?"
"Of course," Erin said. "I know for a fact it's not Santa Claus."
Jess rolled his eyes.
Ella leaned down and whispered in Erin's ear. Straightening up again, Ella watched Erin's gaze roam over to Jess doubtfully.
"What kind of a name is Cosmo?" Erin asked.
"Listen, my mom's into crystals and-" Jess began, but Michael called Erin over for something.
"Gotta go," Erin said, and skipped off towards her father without another word.
"C'mon, Elle," Jess groaned, a blush creeping up his neck and warming the tips of his ears.
She chuckled, nudging him with her shoulder. "Sorry, Cosmo."
Before Jess was able to retort, Fiona and Jake approached them. Considering they were split up, the peculiarity of the two of them arriving together wasn't lost on anyone, not that it would ever be mentioned. At a closer proximity, Ella was surprised to see how different Jake looked. His hair was greyer, he was skinnier, there were dark circles under his eyes. Whatever has been going on in Maryland didn't seem to be conducive to health. She had to bite back her sigh at the sight of him. Fiona was more or less the same, though Ella had visited her more or less recently. She couldn't remember the last time she had laid eyes on her father. The shadow of the man he had been when she was a child was almost completely gone. Her heart twisted painfully in her chest.
"Hey, kids," Fiona said, giving Ella a quick hug.
"Oh, hi," Ella chirped, surprised at her instant warmth.
She also hugged Jess, shocking everyone involved.
"So good to see you guys! How are things in Philly? Adam tells me you just got a new apartment?" Fiona asked, buzzing and bubbly. Her black hair was cropped close to her head. Ella remembered how she used to let apprentices at the beauty salon experiment on her locks during breaks.
"Yeah, we've been there about a month," Ella said. "It's only a few blocks over from school. I can walk there."
"How nice," Fiona smiled.
"It is," Jess agreed.
Shifting uncomfortably from foot-to-foot, Jake finally interjected. "Hi, Ellie."
"Hey, dad," she said, biting the inside of her cheek.
"Young man," Jake greeted Jess coldly, nodding.
Jess gave a curt nod and a thin-lipped smile in response.
There was a long pause before anyone spoke again, filled with distant, amiable chatter of other families and shrieks of congratulations. Out of the corner of her eye, Ella could see Adam was already off with his friends. Soon, they would be headed to dinner and Project Graduation. Part of Ella was glad Adam didn't want a big day of family celebration. No one would've survived any extended period of false positivity.
"I see you've got tattoos now, Ellie," Jake said, looking down at the tulip on her arm, exposed in her spaghetti strap dress. "Your mother would've called that sinful, you know."
The corners of Ella's lips tugged up into a resentful smile, the words dripping with venom as they left her mouth before she could stop them. "Well, it's a good thing she's dead then, isn't it?"
Both Fiona and Jake's jaws dropped and it seemed all the oxygen had been sucked out of the air around them. Ella's stomach dropped and she brought her hand over her mouth just after she said it. Her hazel eyes grew to the size of saucers. Immediately, Jess took her by the shoulders and began leading her in the direction of the diner, blurting out excuses.
"Hey, nice to see you folks, but we have to get to Rory's graduation party tonight and it'd be pretty rude if we were late so…" he trailed off, stopping once they were far enough away, leaving Fiona and Jake flabbergasted and speechless.
"Oh my god," Ella muttered, chewing at her thumbnail for the first time in what felt like forever. "Oh my god, oh my god, oh my god. I was gonna try to be nice if he came, because...at least he showed up, right? Fuck. Oh my god. Jess. Oh my god."
"It's okay, Daria. Just try to relax," Jess breathed, steering her towards the diner as she instantly began melting down.
"I can't relax, Jess! Don't fucking tell me to relax! Did you hear that?! Did you hear what I just said?!" she muttered hastily. "Fuck me! Fuck! Every time I see him, my fucking mouth-"
"Hey, language!" Luke scolded her as they entered the diner, the bell jingling jovially above the door. There were only a few customers scattered around, the mid-afternoon lull.
"God, Luke, I thought age was supposed to negatively affect your hearing!" Ella snapped as Jess directed her to a stool and sat her down, hopping up on the seat next to her.
"Joe Pesci here is having a bad day," Jess explained shortly as Luke shot Ella a bewildered stare.
"What happened?" Luke asked, arching a brow.
Ella heaved a great sigh and placed her head in her hands, elbows on the counter. "Bigmouth has struck again. And apparently she has even less of a filter now than she did in high school!"
"Right," Luke said, increasingly confused.
Running a hand up and down over Ella's back as she continued fuming, Jess gave Luke a dejected glance. "Green tea?"
A shadow of realization passed over Luke's face. "Comin' right up."
Author's Note: Thank you for reading! Please let me know what you thought! Feedback nourishes my soul! I know this chapter probably seems light on dialogue, but it is more of an exposition for the next chapter, which will include Rory's graduation party. Just bear with me! :)
aldupotterbing: Your reviews are so wonderful and detailed! They put a smile on my face every time I read them! Thank you so much for bringing a little extra light to my life! Yes, Luke is a total dad to everyone, especially them, and would definitely get in on the moving no questions asked. Glad you were intrigued by the talk of a proposal. ;) And I'm happy you found Ella's mindset relatable! I can definitely also identify with it. Thank you again!