Mary and Peter were talking in Wayne Tower whilst he's trying to keep her away from the vodka since she's already drunk enough as it is.
"I mean, god, Kate knew all along that Beth was alive. You know, that celestial sisterly bond is real. Actually, that's really heavy." Mary states and keeps reaching for the vodka as Peter just listens to what she's saying whilst smacking her hand every time she reaches for it.
"Mh-hm." Peter comments, just listening, not really following what she's saying anymore.
"I don't even know who my mom is anymore, and I do in fact have a second stepsister. And you have a second sister." Mary continues before turning to Luke. "Wait, is Kate with Alice right now?"
Luke stops what he's doing and turns to her. "I don't know. That's where we thought Peter was, now I have no idea what's going on."
"Wow." Mary sighs. "Here I am at the literal lowest point that I've ever been, and Kate decides to choose today of all days to go out for some sisterly bonding with a cold blooded killer? Meanwhile, how many people have I murdered?"
"Did you really ask that question?" Peter asks her.
"I try my best to be a good sister." Mary states.
Peter wakes up and sees he's handcuffed to a pipe in what he had to guess was the house she was kidnapped in and most likely on her bed. Looking down, he notices a tear in his suit.
"You found the tracker." Peter took a guess. "Wait, how'd you knock me unconscious? There's no way."
"Used horse tranquillizer." Alice answers. "I was beginning to think that it killed you."
Peter looks confused but just yanks his chain and breaks it off. "I don't know what you thought would happen."
"Good point." Alice sighs, seeing it was a longshot for that to work. "Look under there." She says as she gestures towards the pillow.
Peter moves over to it and takes out a ragged out green stuffed dinosaur.
Suddenly, faint memories come flooding in of when he was a child clinging to this stuffed animal.
"What?" Peter breaths, trying to find out how she has it.
"It was the one thing that I have for after the crash." Alice says with a tear rolling down her cheek. "For the weeks and weeks of captivity, I held onto it forever. My only memory to the outside. I have a brother who I might not get to know. A brother that might never get to know me."
And now it's Peter's turn to start crying. "That's why you kidnapped me when you first came to Gotham."
"I wanted to see you." Alice nods while tears roll down her face.
Peter does the one thing he didn't expect to do, and walked up to her and hugged Alice who immediately hugged back.
"I almost wish I hadn't gone down that rabbit-hole, and yet, and yet, it's rather curious, you know, this sort of life." Alice quotes again, but Peter doesn't mind.
Luke was working in the office while Peter and Mary were still talking when Kate calls and answers it.
"Hey, Kate. Where are you?" Luke asks.
"I'm looking for Peter. What do you think?" Kate asks.
"Peter's...right here." Luke informed her.
"Wait, what!?" Kate asks in shock.
"Yeah, we couldn't get ahold of you to say he's been here all day." Luke explains to her.
"Then how did his tracker get this far out?" Kate asks, looking to Jacob and Sophie.
"His tracker? Personal or suit?" Luke questions.
"He has two trackers?" Kate asks.
"Yeah, one's for his suit, the other is the one Bruce...took care of." Luke explains to her.
"I'm...not going to ask." Kate says as Luke boots up the tracker and does get Peter's location, and it's not at Wayne Tower.
"Wait...how is he..?" Luke asks but looks up to see Peter and Mary are gone. "Kate, I'm sending you the location. I'll call you back."
Kate and the others followed the location and find Peter in the same room he was in, but with Alice long gone.
"Peter, you all right?" Kate asks as she races up to him and checks for any injuries.
"She didn't hurt me. She knocked me out for a few minutes, but I'll live." Peter promises as Jacob notices the stuffed animal in Peter's hand and recognizes it easily.
"Where did you get that?" Jacob asks.
"She had it." Peter says, and they could tell he was referring to Alice.
Mary was brought out to a car that Peter called for.
"Hey, Peter. When you see Kate, tell her that I'm sorry for everything." Mary asks of him.
"Yeah, sure." Peter promises.
"Maybe if I go kill someone, she'll actually call me back." Mary says.
Peter rolls his eyes and opens the door the car. "Just go home and get some rest." He says as she gets in and he watches her as she goes just as Luke comes out and raises a gun to him.
"Stay where you are!" Luke says as Peter turns to face him with his hands raised.
"Luke, what are you doing?" Peter asks.
"How do you look like Peter?" Luke asks him.
"Because I am...Peter." Peter answers, confused as to what he's saying. "Luke, it's me."
"Prove it." Luke dares him.
"Your name is Lucas Fox. Your father was Lucius Fox. You graduated high school and were supposed to attend Massachusetts Institute of Technology. During your graduation party, your dad went out to buy some ice from Sip . You were waiting for him to come home to cut the cake, but he never came back because he was murdered at the store. Later on, you were hired by Bruce to work for Wayne Enterprises and subsequently appointed the head of Wayne Security. Convinced?"
Luke looks very confused how this is possible as Peter walks off as if nothing happened.
Peter and Kate look are on the bridge where they rescued Beth from.
"Sorry for scaring you." Peter apologizes to Kate for the day he gave her.
"No, I...I understand why you did it. You wanted the truth, and to see if she really was your sister." Kate replies.
Peter looks at the stuffed animal he hasn't let go of ever since he got it. "She tried to fight. Tried to get free, but she could never get out."
"Think we can help her?" Kate asks.
"Maybe...maybe not. But I'm not going to leave her behind." Peter promises.
Kate smiles and places her hand over his. "And I'll be there to help. She's our sister, and the best we can do is try to help her."
Peter turns and leans against his sister. "Thanks."
Kate hugs her brother and they just stand in silence.
Meanwhile, the black and red suited Spider-Man watches them from a distance almost in confusion.
But before they could notice him, Spider-Man takes off.