"What are you crazy? That was so dangerous." Leo said.
"We were all aware it could be dangerous. But we chose to do it anyway."
"Fine then tell us the name of this elder so we can talk to him." Piper said.
"No, now that we know we realized we can't tell you."
"What, why not? You said you would tell us if you knew. Well now you know." Phoebe said.
"Yes that was then this is now." Wyatt said.
"Why what changed?" Phoebe asked.
P.J. knew Wyatt couldn't come up with a convincing lie without it getting out of hand. So she felt she had to. "In the memories we received it said that once he was exposed he stabbed you Piper and fled with Wyatt. He nearly killed your second child as you were pregnant at the time." She wished she could tell them the truth that it was Chris that was stabbed and later died. But at the moment she knew that would lead to questions like why they would ever leave baby Wyatt alone with Chris.
Piper waved her off. "Well you won't have to worry about that. I have no intention of getting pregnant any time soon."
'That's what you think.' The kids thought. They would find a way to make sure she and Leo had Chris.
"Even still Ladybug is right. We won't risk your life." Melinda said.
"Melinda is right, Piper. You shouldn't risk your life." Phoebe said.
Everyone stared at her. Melinda wondered how she found out and P.J. was mad at herself for not realizing that if her mother's dream vision told her who she was she should have realized it might have exposed Melinda as well.
"What? What did I say?" Phoebe asked as everyone stared at her.
"You called her Melinda." Piper said pointing.
Wyatt really wished at this point one of them had developed their mothers ability to stop time but everyone freezes good and bad unless you don't want them to.
"I did? I'm sorry Melissa, I don't know why I said it." Phoebe said, trying to cover her mistake.
Although the kids now knew that Phoebe knew everything they had to be careful she didn't spill. They should have thought ahead in case she found out and made the spell be continuous of new information. Piper and Leo however were suspicious. But it didn't make sense to them why Melinda would lie about her name so they let it go for now.
"Wyatt please come back to the house. Let Leo look you over and then we'll set up a cot in the babies room. Then we'll talk to Gideon about this issue, then hopefully find a way to get you home."
"No. I won't do any such thing. I understand you are under the assumption that Chris is trying to turn me evil. If he wanted me dead or evil he had plenty of chances I'm sure. I know you don't understand why we won't tell you the elders name. Trust me when I say it's for your safety or do you not trust me?"
"Wyatt honey, of course we trust you it's just that…" Piper started.
"Mom trust me. In a few months we'll be able to tell you more."
"Why a few months? What happens then?" Phoebe asked.
Wyatt wanted to strangle her as she should know. But before he could respond Chris groaned and sat up and said "Future consequences. You'll have to wait."
Wyatt was quickly by his side running healing hands over him. "How are you feeling?"
Melinda was also quick to turn to be sure her brother was okay.
"Like I got hit by a truck." Chris said. "If you tell Gideon anything then he might tell the other Elders and the one responsible might increase his timeline. Thus putting us all in danger. Hearing the story the Elders learning that Wy is evil in my time might help the cleaners to erase Wy for good this time. They might not be willing to accept that this Wyatt is good if we find who hurt him. But like you the other Elders might not believe one of their own is responsible." Since they couldn't tell them yet it was Gideon he hoped that the threat of losing baby Wyatt again might be enough to buy their silence for now.
Realizing that their parents weren't going to leave Wyatt decided that it'd be easier for them to leave than try to get their parents to. So he said, "Excuse us. We have things to discuss. Please head our warning and not tell anyone." Then orbed him and his siblings out to Chris' park as it was safer than the bridge. Melinda's hand was still on Chris' shoulder so Wyatt just put his hand on Chris's shoulder knowing Melinda would come to.
"Ladybug honey, let's discuss this." Phoebe pleaded.
P.J. realized that she was going to have to take care of her mother before she blabbed enough for Piper and Leo to realize who she is or her attitude gave it away if it hadn't already. Then they might question if Melinda's name was really a slip and questioning who she really is. Although she doubted they'd ever guess who Chris was they might Melinda if Phoebe dropped enough hints. So she beamed them to where the others were.
"Are you feeling any better, Chris?" Melinda asked.
"Yeah thanks."
"I say we redo the spell not just because of Phoebe but us as well." P.J. said.
"Come on, you guys I promise not to tell." Phoebe whined disappointed P.J. didn't call her mom. "Besides I want to know more about the cupid I'm going to marry. When do I get to meet him?"
"Not for a few years." P.J. said.
"But aren't cupids supposed to help you find your soulmate? If I really am soul mates with a Cupid then I don't need to waste my time with finding another boyfriend? Just tell me his name, maybe I can find him now."
"No, first off the other boyfriends teach you what you need to make your relationship work. If you know who he is, then how will you know if he's truly your soul mate. Just because he's a cupid and we say so." Chris said.
"Besides would you really want to miss out on other romances that might end in heartbreak or just instantly meet and be with dad because we told you. No taking time to get to know him because you already know. Wouldn't you always wonder if you chose dad because you knew you would have me and my sisters or did you choose him because you love him." P.J. said.
"So I have more than two?" Phoebe asked excitedly. Showing everyone that everything that Chris and P.J. just said went out the window.
"You would really want to be with him because we told you that you were soul mates? Not because you yourself realized it. And 2 without the hardships of other failed boyfriends the Elders might not agree to let you get married. You might not even realize he's the one, he could just be there to introduce you to another Cupid." Chris said despite knowing it was the Elders that sent Coop to her hoping she'd fall in love with him. He knew if he told her that then she wouldn't put a lot of effort into her other boyfriends and just wait. But by telling her Coop might not be The One then she wouldn't realize he is The One right away.
Phoebe nodded reluctantly, understanding. But that didn't mean she wasn't curious. After all she knew she'd have at least one daughter by this Cupid. If not two or more if he was also the father of the other girl her vision said she'd have and P.J. herself said sisters implying more than one other.
Much to Phoebe's dismay P.J. recast her spell but made sure this time that any new information learned was also meant to keep quiet till Chris is conceived.