Disclaimer: I own nothing

This AU takes place in England in the 1640s. There was a surge of witch trails between 1640s-1650s in that country. Those found guilty of practicing magic, if there wern't killed during the interrogation, were hung. More information can be found in the end notes.

I go into detail about the interrogation and execution during this fic. Discretion is advised.

This entire fic was inspired by a conversation I had on Tumblr.

A Leap in the Dark

The old cart creaked and rocked as it slowly moved towards its destination. With the exception of the occasional instruction to the donkeys from the wagoner, the only sounds from its passengers were whispered prayers and weeping.

Daniel (Danny to friends) Fenton closed his eyes as he waited for the inevitable. No amount of crying or pleading would save him now, and he'd come to terms with it. Or at least that's what he told himself.

Several days prior, town guards stormed his home and pulled him into the streets. He demanded an explanation only to be punched in mouth and knocked to the ground. Some of the guards grabbed him and forced him into a kneeling position as another took out a scroll.

"On behalf of his majesty, we the guards of Amity Park arrest Daniel Fenton, son of Jack Fenton, on suspicion of practicing black magic and soliciting with the devil."

He tried to argue with them. The charges were insane. Sure, his parents liked to experiment with alchemy which often seemed like magic, but he'd done his best to keep his nose to the ground once he moved out of their home. What did he do to get someone so upset with him that they falsely accused him?

His words fell short as someone hit him in the neck.

The next thing he knew, water fell on him, jolting him awake. Glancing around, he found himself in a cell. Trying to stand, he found shackles binding his arms and legs. In front of him, a guard with an empty bucket sneered.

Soon after, he found himself brought before the hallmote. A representative of the town stood before those gathered and explained what the accusations against him were. The other villagers yelled and hissed. The representative waited until they calmed to provide the evidence which involved reports of him meeting with a dark someone in the middle of the night at the outskirts of town.

Danny jolted as he realized someone saw him meeting up with Samantha. She and her family were fairly new to the area and affluent. Her parents didn't approve of him, and there was an issue of different religious backgrounds.

When he had a chance to speak, Danny explained just that. "I just wanted to spend time with my dear friend without worrying about the judgement of others," he pleaded to them.

The crowd's anger softened some. Another rose and asked if any further evidence could be provided. Hope welled within Danny. If no further false evidence existed against him, he might be able to walk away from this relatively unharmed.

The crowd shifted as they waited for someone to speak. When no one did, Danny sighed in relief. He'd be able to go home and live his life. He might have to let Samantha know they would need to move their meeting times to make it safer for both of them, but if that was the only thing he needed to do, he could live with that.

The sound of walking broke the silence. Everyone turned to see Vladimir Masters, another recent addition to the town slowly walk into the room. Danny didn't know what to make of the man. He had more influence due to his merchant money then the local lord which caused some tensions between them. However, he'd managed to charm most of the villagers and the church with his donations and public improvements. He also seemed to have an unhealthy interest in his parents, particularly his mother.

"Ladies and gentlemen of this fair town, I bring you one final piece of evidence," he announced as he opened his cloak to produce a large leather-bound book. He waited for the whispers to stop before he continued. "When rumors first started, I could scarcely believe the son of my two dear friends could possibly be involved in such things. So, I decided to follow him to one of his supposed meetings with the Dark One."

Again, he paused for effect. "I watched as young Daniel meet with a strange man who appeared on a dark mist. Afraid for my life, I didn't dare approach and instead hide behind a nearby tree. While I couldn't hear their words, I did see the stranger hand the boy a book before disappearing back into the mist. The boy glanced through it before heading further outside of town."

"Concerned, I followed at a safe distance. He eventually came to the hang man's tree that grows at the crossroads and buried it before heading back to town. I waited until I believed he would no longer be able to detect my presence and dug up the book. Lo and behold, I found a tome written in a language I could not read. Images of death and sacrifice littered its pages. Horrified, I returned to town with it in my possession to report it to both the guards and the Church."

"Are you so enraged that you can't have my mother that you need to frame me?" Danny spat at the man. "Everyone knows the crossroads are dangerous at night. I have no desire to risk encountering the vengeful and dark spirits that make such a place a home. Besides, don't we all know the Dark One is more likely to appear at the crossroads? Why would I go there after supposedly meeting with Him?"

Masters just gave him a sickly-sweet smile. "How is a simple man like me supposed to understand the logic of such evil? Besides, you have not denied ownership of this book."

The rest of the crowd erupted. Even through the symphony of voices, he could tell many of them cursed and condemned him. His heart sang as the shouts grew louder. Everyone knew the if the crowd believed your guilt, your fate was sealed. He would be handed over to the Church. If he was lucky, their interrogation techniques would kill him before he would be hanged.

After the official ruling was given, officials from the church entered and took him. The last thing he saw before being knocked unconscious was Masters' smug expression.

He came to in another cell. Sore and aching, he took stock of himself. Well, as best as he could due to the chains. He didn't seem to be injured which the exception of a few bruises. The pain appeared to be from resting in the uncomfortable position. Shifting, he tried to find a position slightly more comfortable and warmer while he waited for his fate.

An unclear amount of time later, a couple guards came to retrieve him. They removed him from the chains in the cell and placed more compact shackles on his wrists. Once they were certain he wouldn't be able to fight back, they led him to a different chamber.

He figured he'd see the vicar and maybe a deacon. Instead, Vlad Masters and some men dressed entirely in black greeted him. "I don't… I don't understand…" he stammered.

Masters clapped his hands. "My dear boy, I don't expect you to, but I should explain, seeing as you are my most recent guest." He closed the distanced between them after a few strides and began circling him as if he was a predator. "I'm one of those tasked with seeking out who have made unsavory deals with the Dark One."

An icy chill raised through Danny's chest. "Are you telling me you're one of those moon touched under that Hopkins guy?" While Amity Park wasn't part of any of the large cities, the stories of the sudden upsurge in witch hunts had reached them. Hopkins was the most prolific of the hunters.

"We have crossed paths on occasion," Masters responded as he continued to circle. "However, we disagree on some methods and share little more than a profession. While Hopkins believes those he prosecutes are truly evil, I do things a little differently." He closed the gap between them so he could whisper, "You see, I believe people need to fear evil, and to do so, I need to remind them of its existence, whether it exists in that location or not." For a moment, Danny could have sworn the man's features warped into something inhuman and evil.

Danny swore as the man moved away. "You… you monster! How many innocent lives have you destroyed?"

Masters just chuckled. "Not enough. My friends, could you please silence the boy? We need to begin our interrogation."

The men in black quickly gagged him before ripping off his clothes. They gasped and muttered darkly when they spotted the large birthmark on his chest. When they found no other mark of interest, they poke and prodded the mark. They started lightly before beginning to scratch and jab. Eventually, they brought out a small knife and drew his blood.

"He bleeds," the one muttered. "Surely this is no brand."

"Perhaps it is an illusion, or his brand is one of those normally unseen," another replied.

The first one nodded. "If that is case, then we must locate it." He then made a series of cuts on Danny's arm. "No evidence here. Please try his back."

They continued this investigation for some time. Slices were made up and down his arms, his chest and back, legs, and even his face. All of them bled. All of them hurt. Displeased they could find no sorcery mark, they ordered the guards to take him back to the cell.

The cool stone of the dark cell gave him some relief from the stinging cuts. If any one of them refused to heal cleanly, it could mean the death of him. One of his uncles died from a cut that refused to heal, and it was not one he would like to repeat.

After that, the attempts to get some form of acknowledgement or confession from him worsened. The beat him with their firsts and with whips. They burned him with hot iron. They even tried to throw him in the nearby river, but someone interrupted that one. While it wasn't much, he silently thanked the unknown stranger for the act of kindness.

While he never confessed to any of the false accusations, he did openly curse Masters. That apparently was enough for him and his cronies. The next thing he knew, he was standing in front of the Hallmote again with Masters announcing his confirmed guilt. As a result, he was sentenced to hang.

Danny spent the next few days in the prison's cell. In a different cell across the hall, a few more condemned prisoners also awaited their fates. He heard they would meet their ends on the same day he would. One of the others tried talking to him, but he decided not to respond. Whatever the man did to deserve his fate, he didn't need a chance to make it worse by speaking with someone accused of magic.

When the day finally came, the guards came to retrieve them. After their hands were bound behind them, they were led to the wagon to be transported to the location of the gallows.

While some of the other men prayed and wept, he just stared at the sigh. He'd made peace with his awful fate. As much as he wanted to blame the Lord, he couldn't bring himself to do so. He learned at a young age that while the Lord could work miracles, He couldn't always interfere with the evil acts of men. At least he knew he'd be welcomed in Paradise.

Once the wagon reached its destination, Danny allowed himself to glance at the crowd. Many of them were celebrating the day. He almost forgot how an execution could excite the townsfolk. Some were even taking bets on how long he and the others would last.

They were marched into a line underneath the scaffold. After the nooses were placed, the executioners gave the other men the chance to say their final words first. Then came Danny's turn.

He glanced around in hopes someone might be brave enough to save him. No one stepped forward. Instead, most of the faces visible to him appeared to laugh and jeer. Except one, he spotted Sam who appeared to be weeping.

"I hope that you who falsely condemned me are haunted by your choices," he stated while trying to keep his voice as even as possible. I know what awaits me on the other side, but can you say the same?" The crowd shouted obscenities at him as his words came to a close, but he didn't care, not anymore.

With him being the last to speak, the executioner and his assistants began the process of covering his head with the characteristic hood and kicking the supports out from under their feet. Even though he was prepared for death, he didn't want to die. His weight forced the rope to press harder against his neck, making it harder and harder to breathe. He struggled to free his hands in hopes he might be able to save himself, but with each passing moment, he seemed to be drain of more and more of his strength.

His last conscious memory was to hope Sam wouldn't be targeted for her show of tears.

...

…

…

Consciousness came back to him slowly. Feeling groggy and stiff, he slowly sat up. As dirt fell away from his body, he realized night had already fallen. Why had he fallen asleep outside? Had he been stargazing again? After the first time, he decided to use his roof for that purpose as it was safer than sleeping outside the village.

"Danny?"

He jolted at the soft voice. Turning, he found Sam kneeling a couple feet away with her friend and servant, Tucker, standing behind her with a lantern that had an unusual intensity. Both of them watched him carefully. If he didn't know any better, he would have guessed they were apprehensive of him.

"Thanks for waking me up," he told them cheerfully as he stood and brushed some of the dirt off him. His voice didn't convey his feelings though as it sounded gravely even to him. He must have slept much longer than he originally figured.

Frowning as he realized his feet were buried in the dirt, he glanced behind him to find what appeared to be a shallow grave. Disturbed soil with an arm of an unnatural bluish color sticking out of it could be found only a few feet away. He'd been buried.

"Danny?" Sam called out again as she slowly stood and approached him. "What's the last thing you remember before waking up?"

As he thought about the odd question, flashes of his interrogation and the gallows came to the forefront of his mind. Scared at the implications, he rubbed his throat. The skin felt rough as if it had been injured and pain blossomed at his touch. He had been hanged. Falling to his knees, he thanked the Lord for a chance at a second chance at life.

Standing again once he finished, he glanced at his friend. "I'm glad you came when you did. I don't know what I'd do if I woke up alone out here. Let's get you home before something bad happens. Only one of us needs to be accused of practicing magic." He gestured to the lantern. "You didn't need to break out the good candles just for me. Actually, they might be too bright if we want to sneak back into town."

Tucker glanced at Sam, who bit her lip. "Danny, they just seem bright to you. The candle in there is the dimmest I could find. We could barely see where we were going while getting here."

She wouldn't look directly at him. Instead, she kept her gaze lowered which was unusual for her. That by itself clued him in something was wrong.

"Sam, look at me. What's going on? You're not telling me something."

"My lady, err… I mean Sam," Tucker floundered as she turned to stare at him. Even though her parents bought him to be her personal servant, Sam refused to have him call her by an honorific. She wanted him to consider her his friend first and foremost. "Should I bring out that mirror?"

"That might be best," she agreed as he hesitantly handed her the lantern while he dug through the sack attached to his belt. When he finished, he brought out a black stone and traded the lantern back for it.

"I thought that was supposed to be a mirror," Danny joked as Sam took a moment to polish it.

"It is… It's just a special type of mirror. Difficult to come across." She held it up to him. "It'll be easier to show you."

Not sure what to expect, Danny stepped forward until he could see his reflection in the stone. However, whatever person it reflected, it certainly wasn't him. The stone showed a creature with hair of moonlight and eyes of an unearthly green. Its skin reflected as the bluish pallor of death. Dark bruises were visible around the neck.

Cursing, he stumbled away. Grabbing at his hair, he found stuffs of whitish silver. The skin of his hands matched the color of the creature's skin. "What happened? What did you do to me?"

"I was trying to summon your soul."

"I get accused and executed for witchcraft, and you turn around and preform it?" Danny gave a hollow laugh. "Was my death not enough of a warning? And what did you plan to do once you summoned me?"

"I wanted to take down Masters, okay?" she snapped at him. Her gaze fell when they locked eyes. "Not all magic is evil. I just wanted to see if there was anything you could provided to help me make sure he didn't take any more victims before your soul became beyond reach, but something went wrong."

"What do you mean?"

"I don't know if I did something wrong."

"Don't say that," Tucker scolded as he placed a hesitant hand on her shoulder. "The crossroads hold strange powers as its one of those places where mortal and immortal can meet."

Danny gulped at the implication. He forgot criminals tended to be buried at the crossroads. And even though he wasn't as superstitious as some, he knew such places could be very dangerous. "So… what did the combination of this good magic and the crossroads do to me?"

"That's something I don't really know. It seems to have reanimated you, but you are clearly not as you were." She fell to her knees as tears began to roll down her cheeks. The Sam Manson crying! Sam never cried.

Hesitantly, he crouched down in front of her and used his fingers to lift her chin. Her skin felt so warm to the touch. "While I can't say I'm comfortable with what happened, I can say it's not your fault. You had no idea this would be the outcome. You're also right about Masters… There's something wrong with him. During the interrogation, I could have sworn I saw the shadow of evil on him."

Instead of responding, she lurched forward to embrace him. Not sure what else to do, he rubbed her back in a soothing manner.

"Sam, you're going to get dirty. Neither of us will want to risk the wrath of your parents." Tucker spoke softly as he tried to gently pull her off of Danny.

She didn't respond. Instead, she buried her head deeper into Danny's chest. Not sure what to make of it, Danny shared a look with Tucker. Eventually, she stated, "I can hear your heart beating. Danny, I can hear your heart! You're alive." She looked up and gave him the biggest and purest smile he'd even seen.

"But how? How is that possible? I couldn't have survived the gallows, and my appearance is of some specter… What the?" As he spoke, a blinding light washed over him. As his eyes adjusted, everything seemed much darker. If it wasn't for the faint light of the lantern and the visible sliver of the moon, he doubted he would have been able to see anything. Wait, he'd been able to see just fine moments ago.

"Tucker, the lantern!"

Seconds later, the lantern appeared within inches of his face. "Whoa! Watch it! Those metal ones hurt when they hit you."

"Danny," Sam's smile somehow grew wider, "you look like you again! "

"Is that why I suddenly can't see?" When she rolled her eyes, he quickly added, "I mean, that's wonderful!"

"I doubt it's that simple," Tucker noted as he watched the two of them stand. "You touched death, and that always leaves a lasting mark."

Sam brushed the dirt off her skirt before she began to walk. "That's true, but for now, we should return to town. We can figure out what happened to Danny as we work on destroying Masters. He can stay at my place for now. It's big enough we should be able to hide you for a few days."

Danny acknowledged that would work for now. Even though he didn't want to put either Sam or Tucker at risk, it would be easier to discuss the future once they rested.

Perhaps he could even stagger back into town in a day or two just to see how the townsfolk would react. Maybe they would consider his return to life as the will of God. Or, if he could take the form of that creature again, perhaps they'd consider him a vengeful wraith. The latter made him smile. Oh, Masters didn't know what type of revenge he unleashed.

Notes:

Firstly, if anyone would like to expand upon this idea, please feel free. I have no desire to extend this. The plot bunny, now that it's fulfilled its goal, has run off.

Now for the historical notes.

The hallmote is a court held in a Justice's hall. In medieval England, this is the lord's manorial court. For the lord, this primarily functioned for fees and land ownership. However, when it came to issues regarding laws, the villagers acted as prosecutor, legal authority, witnesses, and judge. The lord of the area rarely had anything to do with legal issues.

I know that when it comes to magic, usually that fell under the church's domain, but I wanted to mention a trial first before he was handed over to them as the accusations against Danny were fabricated.

Moon touched is being used as a euphemism for being crazy.

Vicar is a term primarily used in the Anglican church for parson/minister.

Also, witch hunts and trails did still happen in the 1600s in England – they peaked again in the 1640s and the 1650s due to the English Civil War and the rise of the Puritans.

I did review the interrogation techniques of this time period. While they existed beforehand, the specific ones I mentioned were championed by a man named Matthew Hopkins, who flourished as a witch hunger during the English Civil War. He and his colleagues are believed to be responsible for 20% of the total people persecuted for witchcraft in England between the 15th and 18th centuries. His book is also considered a contributing factor in how the trials in Salem, Mass. played out.

The accused often had their bodies searched for marks which were said to be proof of their pact with the Devil. This was often a birth mark, mole, or other skin manifestation. The area was believed to be unable to bleed or feel sensation.

Hanging. The gallows with trapdoors (drops) weren't invented until the 1760s. So, Danny is experienced it the old-fashioned way where they put the noose on and cover the head with a hood. Depending on the gallows, the condemned might stand on stools or be on the wagon at first. Then those were removed. Unlike modern hangings which were designed to break the neck upon the sharp drop, the original version had people die by suffocation. Most loose consciousness within 5-10 minutes and death occurs soon after. The title actually is a saying believed to have derived from being hung.

There are some instances where people simply lost consciousness and revived at a later time after they were cut down. Some considered that a pardon from God. Others thought the person made a deal with evil.

Executed criminals were traditionally buried at crossroads. Normally, they couldn't be buried in a church graveyard, and there were concerns the dead could come back to haunt the town. Being buried at a crossroads helped confuse angry spirits.

Crossroads were considered liminal places where one could meet all manner of supernatural creatures. Some traditions state it's the best place to contact the dead or conduct spells.

Sam is still Jewish (although secretly since this is the 1640s) in this fic. There are old Jewish spells, which fall under a specific type of mysticism, that call allow one to call forth the dead to ask a question. This is what she was trying to do.