Disclaimer: I don't own Pretty Little Liars.
Author's note: This is dedicated to the amazing and very sweet JemilyPLLGleek78-10 as wella s my friend Emma G, Sana West and Jane XXX.
Author's note 2: If you want more stories set fully in the alternate reality, please send me a PM and give me an idea on what ya wanna see.
Author's note 3: If you enjoy this story, please leave a review.
Emily's alternate future
29 year old Emily Kathryn Fields wake up in the morning as the sun shine into the room.
She slowly open her eyes as she slowly sir up in bed.
For some reason she feel a weird sensation in her heart and stomach.
Once her eyes are fully open and she's properly awake she realize why she feel weird.
The room she's in is not what she expect.
It's not the cozy fancy wonderful bedroom in Paris, France, where she and her wife Alison DiLaurentis has lived for the past 5.6 years.
Instead it's a bedroom she has no idea where it is.
When she look at what she wear she get even more confused.
Her bra and panties are of a style that she'd never wear, since they are way too slutty and ponr-like.
And on her left knee and her right arm she sees tattoos that she know she doesn't wanna have.
Everything's wrong.
"What the hell's going on?" says Emily.
"Happy birthday, babe." says a male voice.
Ben Coogan enters the room and he's aged up to be the age he'd be to match Emily's known life so far.
"Oh, no...!" says Emily, who hate Ben for what he tried to do to her.
She now notice a golden ring on her fnger.
There is supposed to be a ring there, since she and Alison are married, but this ring is a different one.
Emily has somehow found herself in another version of her life where she and Ben are married.
"What's wrong?" says Ben.
"Don't you are to play nice one me, you damn perv. I didn't forget your attempt to rape me at school all those years ago. Thanks goodness that Toby saved me." says Emily.
"Em...I'd never do such a ting. I love you you love me. Are you okay...?" says Ben.
"No, leave me alone." says Emily, being clearly angry.
She hate Ben and has no desire to be his wife.
"C'mon, Em. What sort of weird joke is this?" says Ben.
"Look who's talking. You were always the one trying to manipulate me." says Emily.
"You must be drunk 'cause I've no mermoy of anything you mention." says Ben.
"Oh...what the crap do you remember? Let's hear your version of events." says Emily, still far from happy.
Ben takes a seat on a chair and says "You and I have been together since we started dating in early 2008. After Rosewood High we went to college together, to be specific Zefram Cochrane University near Bozeman. Shorly after graduation there we moved in together here in Clayville."
"Uh...go on." says Emily.
"Last year we got married in a small simple ceremony at the Church of Saint Jacob not far from here. Your friends Hanna, Aria, Spencer and Alison were there. It was the best day of my life, since you finally became mine for real." says Ben, a sweet smile actually on his face.
Emily is confused at how Ben doesn't sound and act like the Ben she knew.
He seem to be a nice man, not the horny egocentic guy that Emily remember him as.
"I don't remember any of that. The things I remember is you trying to rape me in the girls' locker-room at school and me breaking up with you because of that. Not to mention the fact that I am gay." says Emily.
"Calm down, Em. You are not gay and I didn't try to rape you. Did you have some sort of nightmare?" says Ben.
"No, this has to be the dream. I have clear memories f how stuff went down between you and me. You so didn't respect my wishes." says Emily.
"This time I'm confused. I lack memory of your version of what happened." says Ben.
"Same. I hold no memory of your story either."" says Emily.
"Are you really Emily Kathryn Fields, former star and captain of Rosewood Sharks?" says Ben.
"Of course. The one and only Em, that's me." says Emily, less angry now.
She's instead more confused.
Was the life she remember not real...?
Is the life Ben described her true life?
Everything confuse her a lot.
Deep in her soul Emily is pretty damn sure that the life she remember is the real one, which leave only a few options.
They are that either Ben is trying to trick her, the life she knew was just a dream or she has somehow ended up in an alternate reality.
"Okay, but if you really are Emily I don't understand why you seem to have forgotten so many years of your own life, including your relationship with me." says Ben.
"I'm just as confused as you seem to be, Ben. In the life I remember I live in France with Ali and my two little daughters Grace and Lily." says Emily.
"Ali as in Alison DiLaurentis? You claim to've gone gay for her?" says Ben.
"Yes, her. And I have always been gay, even though I was unaware of it myself for a while." says Emily. "I should...uh...kinda...go to work."
"Sorry, you don't have a job, you're a husewife." says Ben.
"No. I'm an elite swim-teacher." says Emily.
"You gave up swimming after college." says Ben.
"I'd never give up on my primary interest. Swimming is a love for me. There's no way I'd give it up." says Emily.
"Oh...the Emily I love told me that she was tired and as a result of that decided to leave the world of swimming and become a housewife isntead." says Ben.
"Why do I remember one life and you another?" says Emily.
"I do not know the answer to that, Em. Can we continue our life now? Today's your birthday. Let's celebrate the same way we always do." says Ben.
"How? Cake and gifts?" says Emily.
"Yes, but our tradition also include hot steamy sex." says Ben.
"No, no, no...me is a lesbian." says Emily.
"You aren't a lesbian." says Ben.
"I am 100 % gay-woman and married to Alison." says Emily.
"What? Alison is dating Noel." says Ben.
"Not true. She love me." says Emily.
"Did you forget that we saw Alison dance sexy for Noel a month ago?" says Ben.
"I have absolutely zero memories of the life you claim is mine." says Emily.
"Well...the life you claim you've lived I don't remember anything of..." says Ben.
"Excuse me..." says Emily as she put on the clothes she find on the floor next to the bed.
She doesn't feel comfortable because the clothes are so far from her style as it could ever be.
"Where are you going?" says Ben when Emily is about to leave the room.
"Home, home to my reality." says Emily, all serious.
"At least eat a slice of cake and open your gifts first." says Ben.
"Thanks, but no, thanks." says Emily and then she leave.
She put on shoes and a jacket and walk outside.
Emily gasp in surprise as she remember that she know nothing about the town she's in right now.
The only thing she know is that the town is named Clayville, since Ben mentioned this.
"This cannot be real." says Emily, even though it feels real.
It doesn't feel like a dream.
She can feel the wind in her hair and the sunlight on her skin.
Never has she had a dream that felt this realistic.
Which means that somehow it is probably real.
Emily is so confused.
If this is real, what about the life she knew?
The life where she and Alison are married and live in France.
"Maybe the key to this enigma is in Rosewood." says Emily.
She finds a bus to Rosewood.
After over 8 hours the bus reach Rosewood.
Emily feel a bit better when she notice that Rosewood look the way it is suppsoed to.
"I'm gonna ask mom what's going on. She'll know the truth...I hope." says Emily.
Unfortunately when she get to the Fields house there's a small sign on the door that says 'For Sale'.
Emily starts to cry.
Where is her mom?
She takes a walk in the park where she all randomly happen to meet Hanna, but Hanna look different from the Hanna she remember.
The Hanna in this reality has dyed her hair black and she wear a slutty and overexaggerated heavy metal outfit, making her look like a whore or a pornstar.
"Hanna?" says Emily, as she stop crying.
"Oh my gosh! Emily? It's been years...what brings you to Rosewood again?" says Hanna.
"I'm looking for a way home." says Emily.
"Unable to get a bus to Clayville?" says Hanna.
"No, no, no...I wanna return to my reality. This is obviously not it. You're not supposed to look the way you do. I am not meant to be Ben's wife. I miss Ali, Grace and Lily." says Emily.
"What the pooping hell are you talking about, Em?" says Hanna.
"Something's very wrong here. Hanna where's my mom?" says Emily.
"Shady Pines Cemetery." says Hanna.
"She works there?" says Emily.
"No, your mom is dead. Don't you remember? That damn Nazi from Florida killed your mom and my dad. 4 years ago..." says Hanna.
"I don't remember any of that, Han." says Emily.
"What? We were there. You and me saw it happen." says Hanna.
"Really? Tell me everything." says Emily.
"Okay. I'm a porn actress, Aria and Ezra has moved to Italy, Ali is dating Noel and Spencer is the uptight asexual single-lady mayor of Rosewood. After she and Toby broke up she became weird and pretty much ended her friendship with the rest of us." says Hanna.
"And what about me?" says Emily.
"You live in Clayville with Ben, your husband. You are a housewife, since you got tired of swimming. Too bad...you were almost going to the Olympics." says Hanna.
"No, no, no, no, no!" says Emily as she start to cry again.
Hanna is confused as she walk away.
"Mom..." says Emily.
Emily decides to search for Alison and see if she really is with Noel as Ben and Hanna claim.
She soon finds Alison at the Grille.
"No..." says Emily as her heart sink upon seeing Alison making out with Noel by a table in a corner.
They look very much in love.
It hurt like a poisoned dagger in Emily's soul, seeing her wife with evil perverted Noel of all people.
Emily feel like she almost wanna puke.
Lucky for her, ALiosn and Noel doesn't notice that she's there.
With a sad look on her face, Emily leave the Grille.
She get a cab back to Clayville.
She hate Ben but she has no other place to go.
"Great, you're back. Are we gonna celebrate your birthday now?" says Ben, trying to give Emily a hug.
Emily back away, not wanting Ben to touch her.
"Appears as not." says Ben, sad that Emily doesn't love him.
"Sorry, but I have no romantic or sexual feelings for you." says Emily.
"Then why did you marry me?" says Ben.
"I did not. I'm not your Emily. I am Emily from another reality. Where your Em is I've no idea." says Emily.
"Uh...another reality? I don't understand." says Ben confused.
"Trust me, I know not much more than you, but something's wrong. This is not my life. I don't belong here. You seem honest so I believe there's another version of me who's lived the life you remember. And I hope you'll find her soon. I on the other hand need to find a way back to my reality." says Emily.
"Do you claim there are multiple realities, each with its own version of Emily Fields?" says Ben.
"I indeed do and each reality also has its own version of you, for example the Ben in my world is not nice like you. He's a horny egocentric perv who attempted to rape me in school." says Emily.
"How did you survive that?" says Ben.
"Toby saved me from you." says Emily.
"Good. I think it's sad that my alter ego in your world is a bad guy. Here you're safe though. The other me might be a perv, but I'm not." says Ben.
"Well, you do seem much more nice than the Ben I remember." says Emily.
"All of this is weird, but I like you so I'll try to believe this whole multiple realities thing." says Ben.
"If you promise to not pressure me into sex with you and such, now I'd like my gifts and a slice of cake." says Emily.
"Okay. You have my word." says Ben and then he gives Emily 4 gifts and some cake and tea.
Emily open the gifts, they are a new swimsuit, a new dress, a book and a blue plush bear.
"Thanks, but I guess I only can keep these items during my short stay. Your actual Emily Fields are the one who should get them." says Emily.
Emily eat some cake and drink tea.
"Nice. Eat's blueberry-tea and blueberry-cake." says Emily, feeling much better.
"Of course, your favorite flavor, Em." says Ben.
"Sweet. My alternate self share my taste in snacks." says Emily.
"It seems you're more like my Emily than I'm like the Ben in your world." says Ben.
"Yeah." says Emily.
"Can you tell me about the other me?" says Ben.
"Uh...sure. Like I said, he and I date back in the day until he tried to rape me. Thank God that Toby saved me. I broke up with him and a while later I discovered I am actually gay and in love with Ali." says Emily.
"And what does he do these days?" says Ben.
"That's something I cannot tell. I've not seen him in years. He moved away and didn't ever return." says Emily.
"Were you Rosewood Sharks' captain and star just like my Em was?" says Ben.
"I sure was that and also later for the Stanford team as well." says Emily.
"You went to that college in your reality?" says Ben.
"Yeah." says Emily.
"So you're a lesbian?" says Ben.
"100 % gay-lady forever and in every possible way. Married to my sweet Alison. We live in a wonderful apartment in La Paris. I'm a swim-teacher and Ali is a fashion-designer. Ali and I have two adorable daughters named Grace and Lily." says Emily.
"Okay. That sounds like a good life. If you are here I wonder where my Emily Fields is." says Ben.
"Probably in my reality. I'd guess she and I were switched." says Emily.
"Logical idea." says Ben.
"I need to return to my world and if the other me is there I'll help her to get back here to you. If she's truly Em Fields too I assume she wanna be here as much as I wanna be where I belong." says Emily.
"Good. I miss my Emily Fields. She's sexy." says Ben.
"What's she like?" says Emily.
"She looks almost exactly like you, that's why I thought you were her. She love the color blue, dancing and dolphins. She's a housewife, but talented enough to get any job she'd want." says Ben.
"Thanks for saying so much sweet stuff about my alternate self. You're much more nice than Ben in my reality could ever be." says Emily.
"No problem, babe." says Ben.
"Uh...yeah." says Emily.
"Sorry, you're not my Em. How's your brother doing?" says Ben.
"Brother?" says Emily.
"Daniel Fields." says Ben.
"He doesn't exist. I am an only child." says Emily.
"Oh...Emily here has an older brother named Daniel and a little sister named Jenny." says Ben.
Ben switch on his phone and use it to display a photo of his reality's Emily with her brother Daniel and sister Jenny.
"These are them." says Ben.
"They look nice." says Emily.
"And they sure are. Emily of my world is very good friends with them both. Daniel is a doctor and Jenny study music at Malibu Music School." says Ben.
"Do you love my alter ego very much?" says Emily.
"Yes. Emily is my one true love. She's...uh what was it again? I think it was...like 'shy in the streeets and sexy in the sheets' or something. She told me that Alison described her that way at some point." says Ben.
"Sure remember those words from Ali's mouth." says Emily.
"Did she say that in your world too?" says Ben.
"Yeah, she sure did say that to me." says Emily.
"Emily that I'm married to can be very sexual and erotic. I like that." says Ben.
"I'm glad you love her. I hope you get her back 'cause I cannot give you what she can, since I'm gay." says Emily.
"She might be...dead..." says Ben in a sad tone.
"Don't worry. She probably is in my world." says Emily.
"How do we switch the correct Emilys back?" says Ben.
"No idea." says Emily.
"We need to find a way. I miss my Emily so much. If she was here we'd celebrate her birthday right now." says Ben.
"You shouldn't give up." says Emily.
"Ben?" says another Emily as she enter the room.
She is the Emily who's married to Ben and she look very tired and she's wet as if she's been in the rain, despite it being like a beautiful sunny day in the summer outside.
"Em." says Ben as he hug 'his' Emily in joy.
The tattoos on 'our' Emily disappear.
"Uh...excuse me, how did you get here?" says Emily.
"Thanks to this. Take it and go home." says alternate Emily as she give something to Emily.
It looks like a remote control of some sort.
"Okay." says Emily.
She press the green home-button and swirling water appear around her and teleport her to her own reality.
She appear outside the building where she and Alison lives.
At the same time in the alternate reality, Ben and Emily celebrate Emily's birthday by having porno-style sex in Emily's bed.
"Mmmm!" moans Emily.
"Yeah, babe!" moans Ben.
Emily enter the building and walk up to the apartment.
When she enter the apartment she sees Alison.
"Em!" says Alison, happy to see Emily.
They hug each other.
"Mommy!" says Lily and Grace as they exit their room and sees Emily.
"Are you 'our' Em?" says Alison.
"Yes, babe. I assume my alter ego was here." says Emily.
"She was here and she was not like you. I mean, she was straight and rude to our lil' sweeties. I had to comfort them both after she said extremely bed thing to them and such." says Alison.
"Everyone can relax now. I'm home." says Emily.
The entire Fields-DiLaurentis family celebrate Emily's return with french pizza in front of the TV.
They're all happy that the correct Emily Fields is back.
The End.