"Wow it's so small!"
"It's even smaller than it looks in the pictures!"
This was unbelievably humiliating for PJ. Gabe had shown his girlfriends pictures of his tiny penis, and now they wanted to see it for themselves. Yes, Gabe had two girlfriends, that's how much of a man he was, or at least perceived to be by these two particular girls, Jo and Lauren. What a change it had been for Jo, to find Gabe very manly now.
Now they got to see it in reality, and, it was small, it looked smaller than the pictures as Lauren had said.
How did Gabe get pictures of PJ's penis? Well, Gabe had always known that PJ had an abnormally small penis, but that didn't concern him. However, PJ wanted to be humiliated. PJ had sent pictures of his small penis to Gabe "accidently" several times before Gabe got sick of it and told him he'd send it to other people if he kept doing it, which was exactly what PJ wanted, so he did it even more. Gabe caught on to that being exactly what he wanted after a few more times, and PJ asking him how the girls reacted to such a tiny penis.
So Gabe did it, but he told PJ he should be doing that himself, and also that PJ really should be getting his girlfriend to do things like that for him, and that she probably wouldn't appreciate that he was sending penis pictures to everyone.
His girlfriend was stupider than he was though, and she was completely incapable of giving him what he wanted, ironically enough. She didn't seem to ever know what PJ wanted when he asked for such things. So PJ had to get his humiliation on other methods. Which lead to what he had done with Gabe. Which eventually lead to Gabe sending those penis pictures to his girlfriends, which lead to them wanting to see PJ's tiny penis in reality.
"No wonder Gabe fucks Skylar for you, she probably couldn't even feel this!" Jo said. Yeah, Gabe had started fucking Skylar too, and PJ didn't do anything about it but get hard when it was mentioned. Skylar, being the ditz that she is, was easy to get into bed, and seemed to think that PJ had no idea what was going on, which, was exactly how PJ liked it. He didn't directly ask Gabe to do anything, but it was almost inevitable that Gabe was going to fuck Skylar, knowing that she wasn't getting much pleasure from PJ's cock. Apparently he was good with his tongue though, which Gabe really didn't need to hear about while he was having sex with her, but sometimes she blabbed on during sex.
Now, with this humiliation, PJ was erect.
"Wow, it looks even smaller when it's in my hands." Jo said.
"You can't even grip it with your whole hand, you have to use your fingers to stroke his cock." Lauren said.
"It's not very thick either, here, you feel it." Jo said, and then let go of his cock, which stayed straight out and erect.
"He does feel very hard though." Lauren said. With such a small cock it was easy for PJ to maintain an erection, it always seemed to be very hard, there was no semi-erection really, which only showed how small his cock was.
"I bet it would feel so weird on your tongue." Jo said.
"I dare you to lick it." Lauren said.
"You first." Jo said. "You're touching it."
They both giggled and there was a little hesitation before Lauren licked it. "Your turn."
Jo licked it. "You better not cum while one of us is licking you." It was weird to feel on the tongue, it was strange to have an entire erect penis on the tongue, like it was something their brains could not comprehend correctly, because there were used to Gabe's penis being something fitted in the mouth and sucked on, not a penis being licked and fitting on only the tongue.
If they kept licking him over and over like they did, he was going to cum from all the licking and the humiliation he was getting from this was going to make him shoot lots of ropes out.
The little jolts every time they licked and wimpy moans were telling the girls that he was going to cum soon.
Jo took the penis into her hand and stroked it with her fingers.
"He's going to cum!" Jo said and both girls giggled.
He came. "Wow his penis jerks so much when he's shooting!" Lauren said. Orgasm force was not an issue at all for PJ, as long as he hadn't been jerking his penis too much.
He was very humiliated as he cleaned up his load and the girls left. His penis was stiff again too.