Disclaimer: I do not own Marvel Cinematic Universe or anything else you may recognize
So I got this idea from a fic called 'Need Him' by 'Whedonista93' on AO3, really nice fic, you should definitely check it out, and now it compelled me to write my own Matt/Buffy/Faith one-shot. Hope all enjoy it.
Thank you to Brainstorm Sorcerer for his help, and to Bl4ckHunter for a villain suggestion.
Now everyone may not be completely in-character in this, though I tried to keep them like that (not too much), but remember, this was mainly written by me to have some fun, that's it.
Timeline wise, this takes place after Daredevil Season 3 and Buffy Season 7, while Angel Season 5 would be on-going currently for this.
New York City, night
Buffy and Faith hadn't expected the fight to be this hard, even against a warrior of the Underworld. Angel had once told them of his fight against Vocah, so they had assumed they could beat this one too, but this one was clearly stronger than Vocah. They had even thought at multiple points in the fight that they'd die. There were cuts on both Slayers all over, and they were a little weakened.
Buffy blocked one of his strikes with her sword before Faith kicked him back, and they ducked to avoid his next swing, before Faith tried to strike him in a spin motion but he dodged and kicked her sword out of her hand, then flipped and kicked her back, and as Buffy charged, he blocked her attack, then kneed her abdomen, and grabbing her by the back of the neck, threw her away too.
He then twirled his scythe, ready to take them both down, and they waited for it, when suddenly a Billy club hit a wall nearby and ricocheting off of it, hit him, sending him staggering back while it flew into the hand of Daredevil, who flipped and leapt down, ready to face him.
Buffy and Faith groaned as they looked up at him, having heard stories of him. Many thought he was a powerful creature, since he had defeated the Hand, who had carried out a reckoning to wipe out all Demons in New York City years ago.
The warrior of the Underworld twirled his scythe, looking forward to this. "Ah! The Devil of Hell's Kitchen. Let us see if you live up to what I have heard about you."
Daredevil just cracked his neck as the warrior charged with his scythe and struck five times but Daredevil blocked all 5 times, then slid to the warrior's other side to avoid his next swing, and the warrior turned and tried to swing but Daredevil ducked without even needing to look back before flipping himself back up onto the warrior's other side.
The warrior struck with his scythe as Daredevil put his armored hand in the way to block, but was pushed back due to the warrior's superior strength. Then he hurled his club, the cable tying the warrior as Daredevil pulled, sending him rolling to the ground.
Daredevil rushed him, leaping in the air in a spin motion but the warrior rolled away to avoid, getting back up.
Buffy and Faith were now back up too, swords at the ready to help Daredevil.
"Heard a lot about you", Faith said to Daredevil, not taking her eyes off the warrior.
"You really didn't disappoint", Buffy smirked.
"Good to know", Daredevil muttered as all three charged together, the warrior blocking their strikes, before Buffy pushed him back, then Daredevil tried to strike as he blocked.
He tried to strike Faith who slid away to avoid when Daredevil got behind him and grabbing him, threw him off.
He got back up and picking up his scythe, struck at Daredevil really fast, making him grit his teeth as he felt a huge gash on his abdomen, blood pouring out, and he staggered down.
He then rushed Buffy and Faith again, the two blocking and dodging his swings, as Buffy blocked his scythe and grabbed his hand in a lock, and Faith stabbed his chest, making him gasp, then pulling her sword out, went down and grabbing him by the back of the foot, flipped him to the ground, while he rolled away.
During that time, Daredevil staggered back up and threw his Billy club, the cable elongating which the warrior dodged, but Faith grabbed the club and threw it back at him, making him stagger back as he gritted his teeth, and Buffy leapt at him, wrapping the club around his throat before rolling back.
Faith threw him into the air and then Daredevil pulled with his club, making him fall back down. As he started getting up, Daredevil pulled his club repeatedly, slamming the warrior's head on the ground again and again, making him groan in pain, and as he got up again, Daredevil did a spin motion and kicked his face hard, sending him flying off before pulling him back down with the club, weakening him more.
Daredevil then pulled his club back and as the warrior staggered up, Buffy rushed to him and stabbed him in the abdomen, Faith finishing the job by chopping off his head in a spin motion.
The two let out breaths as Faith said. "Now that was a fight."
"Yeah", Buffy nodded before they turned to see Daredevil staggering again, holding his wound, and ran to him.
The amount of skill he had shown in this fight had astounded them both. He was possibly more skilled than both of them, and just a normal human.
"Hey!" Buffy said, supporting him alongside Faith. "We got you. Where should we take you?"
"No need", Daredevil said in a stubborn voice that reminded Buffy of herself.
"Really? You're bleeding out, Devil man", Faith pointed out to him.
"I will handle it", Daredevil snarled.
"Don't want to reveal your place and identity, do you?" Buffy asked, and his lack of response was answer enough.
"Look, we got secrets of our own that we don't tell much, besides, you need to get that treated and closed up", Faith told him. "And we don't have supplies where we are, so we are hoping you would."
"And let's see, if we don't treat you, you'd lose a lot of blood on the way back and pass out, and some civilian will find you, put you in a hospital, and everyone will know who you are", Buffy pointed out to him. "If you let us take you back, it is only the two of us, besides, we won't tell."
Daredevil listened to their heartbeats and sure enough, it seemed like they wouldn't tell. Their bodies also seemed a little denser than normal, and their hearts beat slightly faster too. They weren't normal humans.
It was ironic, he was a lawyer, but this time he got defeated in an argument.
"All right, I will show you to my place, just don't tell anyone else a thing you see, not even your closest friends", Daredevil relented.
Later
Matt lay on his couch, now without his suit on, and naked from the waist up as Buffy and Faith provided him some first-aid. They had to admit, he looked really handsome.
"Wouldn't you need some first-aid too?" Matt inquired.
"No, we heal fast", Buffy told him.
"So you aren't normal then", Matt muttered.
"Nope, we're chosen by destiny to fight these creatures of darkness", Faith told him.
"Like that one there?" Matt asked.
"Yeah, he was some Underworld warrior, he is in here for a ritual, still don't know what it is, but we'll find out", Buffy told him. "Your eyes, are you…?"
Matt sighed, they knew who he was, so no point hiding his abilities.
"Yeah, I'm blind", Matt nodded, and both were jaw-dropped. He was blind, and more skilled than both of them? Really?
"How did you do all that then?" Faith asked.
"I had chemicals spilled on my face, they made me blind and enhanced all of my other senses to superhuman levels, and a man trained me to control them, as well as in fighting", Matt revealed.
"Huh?" Buffy said, clearly impressed, the first-aid now finished. "Well, you're going to be fine."
"You got anything to drink?" Faith asked as she walked off.
"No alcohol", Matt said.
"Well damn", Faith muttered, deciding to get a soda instead.
Matt sighed as Buffy touched his chest. She had to admit, he was really hot, and his badass fighting skills, which he had in spite of being blind, made him even more attractive than usual.
And as much as she hated to admit it, Faith was right. Slaying did make one hungry and horny.
Angel was a great guy, but they were better apart and as friends than together as a couple, as both of them regressed each other into lovesick puppies.
She loved Spike still, but he was gone now.
And she was too afraid to ask out Faith, due to their history.
Buffy touched Matt's chest and leaning over to him, whispered. "I thought I might have actually died tonight, that guy was something."
"Well, you're still alive", Matt assured her.
"Thanks to you", Buffy said as she brought her face closer to his. "Thank you."
And with that, she ended up kissing him on the lips, Matt was caught off-guard but ended up kissing back, before they parted, a little breathless.
"We just met", Matt pointed out.
"I know, but well, slaying does that, as much as I hate to admit it, and you're nice", Buffy said. After her experience with Parker, she had gotten much better at judging people. Matt was actually nice, she had a feeling he wouldn't hurt her. "Come on."
Matt hadn't ever been in a relationship after Elektra's death, it pained him still, but, being celibate in her memory would be unfair to him, he had to admit, and even she would want him to move on. She'd probably return to life and kick his ass for being this hung up on her after her death. If she was alive, she'd definitely want Matt to be hung up on her, but dead, nope.
"I think I could do this", Matt told her with a smile, and she smiled back as they kissed passionately on the lips once more, Buffy slipping out of her coat.
Matt breathed over her neck, running his hands over the back of it before he started pulling up her shirt, Buffy helping him out as she pulled it over her head and threw it away.
Matt nibbled at her ear and she moaned before kissing his head, then unstrapped her bra, throwing it off and revealing her assets as Matt kissed them, Buffy feeling jolts of pleasure go down her body while she straddled Matt.
"Started without me, really?"
They turned to see Faith standing there, throwing off the now empty soda can.
Buffy started. "Faith-"
"So you do admit now that slaying makes you hungry and horny", Faith smirked, slipping out of her coat.
"All right, yeah, I admit it", Buffy sighed.
"You have a real hot and perfect body", Faith told Matt with a smirk before turning to Buffy. "And you have fantastic tits."
"Thanks", Buffy said, blushing.
"Oh, don't be shy, B, I've always liked ya", Faith winked, surprising her.
"Really? Because I-I did too, but didn't think…." Buffy trailed off.
"You are so adorable when you ramble like that", Faith chuckled as she walked to Matt.
"So, I see you two have a lot of issues to work out", Matt commented.
"We'll work 'em out on you", Faith said as she shared a kiss with Matt as well, it was hot and passionate, and she took off her shirt too, Matt unstrapping her bra, letting it fall as her assets were revealed as well, and he kissed them, sending jolts of pleasure down her.
"Damn, you're something!" Faith said, as no one had pleased her instantly like that, and both Buffy and Faith climbed over Matt, the three giving into each other passionately for most of the night, pleasing each other perfectly, and eventually moved it to the bedroom.
Next morning
All three woke up at about the same time, Matt in the middle with Buffy and Faith on his left and right side respectively.
"Wow, that was among the best I ever had", Buffy said sleepily, still sounding pleased as she told Matt. "You're amazing."
"How many times do you have girls over?" Faith asked with a naughty smirk.
"Used to have a lot before, now, not much, you two are the first time in a year", Matt said honestly.
"What do they say about your scars?" Buffy asked, running her hand over them.
"They're too busy enjoying themselves to notice", Matt said, making the other two chuckle.
"Oh I don't doubt that", Faith told him, running her hand over his scars too.
"Well, this was amazing", Buffy said. "Where do we go from here?"
"So, now you know, B, I like you, you like me", Faith told her. "And we both like Matt clearly, and he likes us both."
"Still, we will have to go back eventually", Buffy pointed out.
They sat up on the bed as Matt said. "How long would that be?"
"No idea yet", Faith told him. "I mean, we still have no idea what ritual is going to happen, or where it will happen."
"I can help you out with finding out about it", Matt told them. "As for us, well, the night was amazing, for a relationship, we need to…..get to know each other better."
"You think we'd have a chance to?" Buffy asked him.
"Well, there is no harm in trying, besides, the first night was the best, what do you think a full relationship would be like? It'll be something else", Faith said. "And you know if I'm advocating a proper relationship, it should be considered."
"Not wrong there", Buffy realized.
"It has been a long time since I was with anyone", Matt told them both. Faith reminded him of Elektra for some reason, while Buffy was like the best of Claire and Karen, without their flaws. She would have some, but definitely not the same as those two. It was like getting the best of Elektra, Claire and Karen without any of the baggage associated. "I do want to try it out again."
"Fine by me", Faith told Matt, kissing him on the lips as he kissed her back.
Buffy thought about it. Like she'd mused to herself last night, she and Angel were best as friends, and while she hadn't gotten over Spike yet, he was gone now. Matt and Faith were here.
"I want to try it out too", Buffy said, and she kissed Matt too, as he kissed her back as well.
After they parted, Matt got up and started wearing his clothes. "I'll make breakfast for you too, that should be a good start."
"Such a gentleman", Faith smirked as she and Buffy started wearing their clothes.
"I have a feeling we won't regret this", Buffy agreed with a nod.
And like that, a new and special relationship between the Devil and the Slayers started.
Done here, this was quite fun to write. The fight was based on the fight of Scorpion and Cole against Sub-Zero in the new Mortal Kombat film.
While this fic I just wrote to have some fun with this potential 3-way pairing idea, I do think they can work. Faith and Buffy would be like the best of Elektra, Claire and Karen without any of the associated baggage, and Matt would be good for them both I reckon, like he can help Faith tap into the darkness without completely giving in, and make Buffy less naïve regarding the human world and its laws.
Anyway, hope all enjoyed and see you all next time with some other update. Stay safe from the coronavirus ya all!