The day of the party finally has come. Makoto was so excited she was calling Ren at 7 in the morning. He groaned a moment as he rolled over, grabbing his phone as he had to ruin his perfect comfy in his bed. He answered the call and placed it on speaker as he laid his head back down, hair messier than usual.
"Ren! Are you up?" Makoto asked sweetly.
"I'm awake…" He said groggily as he closed his eyes again.
"Doesn't sound like it." Makoto said sighing over the phone. "I just wanted to call and ask you to come over alittle earlier tonight to help finish setting everything up. Say around 3?"
"I'll be there…." Ren said slowly, laying his head on the pillow again.
"Are you even hearing what I'm saying? You sound like you're on autopilot." Makoto said with a small giggle.
"I'll be there…" Ren responded, proving her point as he was already back asleep. Makoto couldn't help but giggle as she could hear the soft snores of Ren over the phone.
"Enjoy your sleep cutie." She whispered softly into the phone before hanging up. She sat in her room, still in her own bed, smiling as she looked over at her gift to Ren for that night, still in its bag. "He's gonna love it for sure."
"So where do you want me to put these?" Ren asked, using his butt to push the door to Sae's home open as he carried several cases of sodas in.
"Just over on the counter. I have an ice chest for them." Sae said carrying the other case.
The party was in just a few hours and the three were busy putting the last touches on everything. Well, Ren and Sae were working. Makoto was to busy staring at the gift that Ren brought with him. It was placed on the table and Makoto was sat right in front of it, not tearing her eyes from it. She was extremely curious as to what Ren got her.
"Makoto, no peeking." Ren called out to her when he saw he subconsciously reaching her hand out to open the gift. Makoto quickly snapped her hand back and stood up, laughing nervously at being caught.
"Makoto was one who couldn't resist the allure of an unopened gift. Ever since she was a child she had to be told no on Christmas." Sae said shaking her head as she and Ren unloaded the cans of soda. Makoto stomped her foot in embarrassment as her cheeks blushed pink.
"That's just adorable." Ren said picturing a young child Makoto desperately trying to open her presents early. "What was Makoto like as a child?"
"No, nope no. Don't need to tell him." Makoto said injecting herself between Sae and Ren.
"She was always reading fairy tales. I remember when she was 7 years old and told me she was going to find her Prince Charming and marry him right away." Sae said as Makoto glared at her sister. "I think she found a better replacement."
Ren smiled, rubbing his cheek, as Makoto blushed even more, yelling at her sister for embarrassing her.
"Oh please, like you wouldn't kill to hear some cute stories about baby Ren." Sae said patting her sister on the head. The sister dynamic on full display.
"I mean….yes...but you just can't come out and say it!" Makoto said, looking at Ren, before turning her around to cover her face. Thankfully, for Makoto's mercy, the doorbell rang. Makoto quickly sprinted to the door and answered. "Ann? You're here early." Ren looks over and sure enough, Ann was there early. In fact, she even had Haru with her.
"Yeah I know, I just couldn't wait sorry. Though I always wanted to drop this off." Ann added as she began digging through her bag. "I found this from an old photoshoot and I just thought, how adorable it would be for you to wear it Makoto."
Finally after digging deep into her bag, Ann pulled out a small-ish crown. It was nicely decorated with what Ren hoped was fake jewels. Makoto gasped at the beauty of the item as Ann placed it on top of Makoto's head. "Now you really ARE a Queen!"
"It looks perfect. Like it was made just for you!" Haru added. Ann grabbed Makoto and pointed her towards Ren.
"Doesn't Makoto just look adorable Ren?" Ann asked smiling. Makoto, whose whole face was one big blush, looked at Ren, waiting to hear his answer.
"The most adorable thing I have ever seen." Ren said smiling, earning a smile from Makoto. She looked like a princess for sure wearing that crown.
"Alright, I'll wear it for a little while." Makoto said giving Ann and Haru a friendly hug.
"Now is there any way we can be of service? It would be rude to show up this early and not offer any help." Haru asked, showing the ever-present politeness of hers.
"Oh yeah, I actually need your help with something." Makoto said whispering something to the two.
"Oh...Oooooohhhh. Of course, we'll help with that." Ann said smiling as the three went and headed down the hall to Makoto's room, leaving Ren alone, confused.
"Say Ren, mind helping me move this table?" Sae called out, standing by the coffee table in the living room.
"...Yeah." Ren said snapping out of his trance as he offered Sae the extra hands to move the coffee table.
As the preparations for the party began to finally wrap up, the hour approached. Soon everyone was arriving for the shindig. Yusuke and Ryuji arrived together. Futaba and Sojiro were next, even bringing Morgana with them. Everyone was here and so the party could begin. Sae and Sojiro kept themselves busy in the kitchen as Sojiro asked for her help cooking. That was the first time Ren ever saw Sae flustered as she admitted that she wasn't a great cook. Sojiro shook her off, saying he will show her. It was interesting how much Makoto took after Sae, even when the two were embarrassed.
"Alright you two! Sit down!" Futaba said grabbing both Ren's and Makoto's hands as she pulled them to the couch. She pushed Ren down first, then sat Makoto on his lap, posing them like she was a school photographer. "Now stay like that!" She said as she pulled out her digital camera and began snapping picture after picture. Ren and Makoto tried their best to smile but the whole situation was getting alittle weird for them.
"Uh, Futaba? They aren't action figures you can just pose however you want." Ryuji said, earning a glare from Futaba.
"Shut up Skull! We need as many adorable photos of these two as we can get! They are grade A cuteness! Animes wish they could be half as cute as them!" Futaba snapped as Makoto didn't mind spending the whole day on Ren's lap, but was sure that it would get awkward after a while.
"I will admit this sight would make a lovely painting. Would you two ever be interested in maybe posing for my class as models? I'm sure the students would create beautiful pieces of you." Yusuke said framing the two with his fingers.
"That actually sounds like a fun idea." Ren said looking at Makoto. "I'm up for it if you are."
"Yeah, I don't see why not. It's for art after all. Just no nude posing!" She warned Yusuke, knowing his penchant for asking for them to pose nude.
"You have my honor as a gentleman and as an artist." Yusuke said putting his hand over his heart.
"A little overdramatic Inari." Futaba said, snapping one more quick pic of the two.
"Art is dramatic." Yusuke said confidently as everyone couldn't help but laugh.
"No I think that's just you Yusuke." Morgana said, sitting on the couch's armrest.
"God, you guys remember what we were doing this time 2 years ago?" Ann asked sitting down on the other end of the couch.
"Yeah, you were all saving me from myself." Futaba said rubbing her eyes as she thought back to those days when she was a reclusive shut-in afraid to speak to anyone.
"I wasn't part of the team yet. I was still just taking care of the school garden." Haru said nodding her head.
"This was probably the craziest period for the Phantom Thieves for sure. I mean look at how popular we were getting at that time." Makoto said calming, still sitting on Ren's lap as she was now hooking her hands around her neck. Seems she was starting to get more comfortable showing affection in front of their friends.
"Yeah then there was that Hawaii trip in the middle of it all." Ryuji said grabbing himself a new can of soda.
"Man, I wish I could've gone with you guys. I wanna see Hawaii so bad." Futaba said stomping her foot a little.
"It would be expensive, but it would be possible. Maybe next summer break?" Haru said as Futaba hopped up and down, already excited for an idea that isn't even set in stone.
"I'll go out and look for a part-time job right away!" She said determined to make this trip happen.
"I agree. And this time you will NOT leave me behind! I hear Hawaii has some amazing fish dishes!" Morgana said, standing up on his paws.
"Hawaii would be nice to revisit. We only really had two days there so we didn't get to really enjoy everything it had to offer." Makoto said as Ren nodded. "And if I remember correctly, I made a certain someone promise last time too." She said poking his nose as she reminded him of their promise to return to Hawaii together, just the two of them.
"Planning the honeymoon already are you?" Sae called out from the kitchen, leaning on the breakfast nook, grinning as she resumed her teasing from when they had lunch.
"Honeymoon?!" Everyone around them said shocked.
"No it's not like that. We're not getting married. Sis is just teasing." Makoto said quickly waving off everyone before they could get started.
"Dibs on best man." Ryuji said raising his hand.
"It's not happening yet Ryuji." Ren said sighing as everyone instead focused on this imaginary wedding that was to be taking place.
"Makoto would look amazing in that dress I'm sure." Ann said as even Makoto was asking her to stop.
"I would paint a beautiful portrait of the two to be displayed for all guests to admire." Yusuke said pictuing his art. Ren and Makoto looked at each other and shook their heads. Their friends always seem to take things to the extreme, even if it was fun planning something like this.
"Alright kids. Before you go ahead and elope on us. How about we all enjoy a nice meal." Sojiro interjected, laying out the food. Everyone quickly swarmed the nook and began gathering plates of food.
"Mmm this is delicious Boss." Ann said as she took the first big bite.
"It's absolutely heavenly." Yusuke said, on the verge of tears.
"So much better than the stuff from the cans Ren feeds me." Morgana said getting his own little plate.
"Sojiro really out did himself this time." Futaba added.
"All in a chefs day of work." Sojiro said taking a small bow, enjoying the compliments.
"I feel bad for inviting you only for you to have to worry about cooking." Makoto said bowing in an apology.
"Don't be. Consider it my gift to you two to let you have some good proper cooking for once." He said giving her a smile.
"Sojiro! More please!" Futaba shouted as she held up her empty plate.
"Relax, there's plenty more for everyone." Sojiro said calmly as he gave her seconds.
After everyone ate their fill of food, they all sat around the couch in their own mini food comas. Makoto resumed her spot on Ren's lap, hugging him tightly as he gently rubbed her back. Sojiro couldn't help but laugh and Sae took a quick picture of the team.
"Acting like you guys haven't had a homecooked meal in years." She said with her own laugh.
"That isn't homecooking. That's a 5-star meal." Ryuji said rubbing his stomach.
"How about while we all settle from our meal, we give Ren his gift?" Haru asked.
"Oh yeah that's right!" Ann said getting up from the couch and grabbing a bag from the the corner and handing it to Ren. "This is for you. Happy birthday!"
"Guys….you didn't have to get me anything." Ren said surprised by the gift, not expecting one at the moment.
"How could we not? It's your birthday! We didn't know what to get you, so we all chipped in and decided on these." Ryuji said smirking, wanting to see Ren's reaction.
Ren reached into the bag and pulled out the gift. A pair of red leather gloves that looked awfully familiar. Ren looked at the gloves, before smiling brightly as he looked at his friends. "You guys didn't."
"They're exact replicas of the gloves you wore in your Phantom Thieves attire." Haru said brightly as Ren laughed in enjoyment as he put them on. They fitted, well like a glove.
"You guys are just something else." Ren said admiring the craftsmanship of the gloves.
"They look as good as ever on you Joker." Futaba said smiling.
"There's even a surprise for Makoto in there." Ann added. Makoto confused, looked in the bag as she began to laugh too. She reached in and pulled out a second pair of gloves like Jokers, these clearly meant to fit a woman's hands. "Now you two can match."
"Oh Ann." Makoto got up and hugged everyone individually as a thank you. "You guys shouldn't have."
"Of course we should have! Happy birthday/anniversary you two." Ryuji said earning a bro hug from Ren.
"You're all the best." He said as the two patted each other's back. "Guess since this is what we're doing. Time for my own little surprise." Ren said grabbing the box that Makoto was studying earlier in the day when they were setting everything up. He went over and placed it on Makoto's lap, giving her a quick kiss. "Happy Anniversary."
Makoto, smiling like a child on Christmas morning, quickly began opening the box. She pulled back the paper inside as she found the gift. She looked at the present, then at Ren, covering her mouth as she began to giggle, her eyes beginning to water up. She grabbed the present and pulled it out, revealing a Buchimaru onesie, Makoto's favorite old mascot character, complete with a hood with ears on them. Everyone began laughing and cheering as Makoto joined them.
"You idiot. I love it." Makoto said getting up and kissing Ren deeply as everyone else cheers and claps.
"Ren sure does have an eye for unique gifts." Yusuke said holding the onesie up, getting a good look at the design of it himself.
"He thinks outside the box for sure." Futaba said. "Go try it on Makoto!" She added, pushing Makoto towards her room.
Everyone waited for a moment before Makoto came out in her new onesie, hood up. She had a blush on her face as she couldn't stop her own giggles. "Tada!"
"OH! My heart! It can't take the cute!" Futaba said laughing.
"Oh Makoto it looks so good on you!" Haru said, clapping.
"I don't even think I could pull that off!" Ann added.
"You're a genius Ren." Ryuji said putting his arm around Ren's shoulder as Ren admired just how adorable Makoto actually looked in it.
The party continued deep into the night as everyone greatly enjoyed themselves. The hours ticked away like seconds as eventually, everyone began calling it a night. As the apartment emptied out, only Makoto and Ren were left once Sae called it a night herself. The two sat on the couch, Makoto resuming her spot on Ren's lap as he hugged her tight, rubbing the back of her head softly.
"Tonight was incredible. I'm so glad we decided to do it." She sighed contently as she rested her head on Ren's shoulder.
"I know, I had a great time too." He said enjoying the feeling of Makoto's soft breaths on his neck.
"How does it feel to be 19?" She asked softly as she snuggled closer to him
"Not all that different from 18 to be honest." He said resting his head against the side of hers.
"Are...are you ready for your gift?" Makoto finally asked after a few minutes of silence, Ren just enjoying holding Makoto.
"You got me something too? You didn't have to." Ren said as Makoto shook her head.
"I told you I was going to buy you something. Please, come with me." She said softly as she appeared to be nervous. She took Ren's hand and pulled him up from the couch as she led him down the hall to her room.
Once inside, Makoto gently closed the door behind them, as she sat Ren on the edge of her bed. Her nervousness seemed even worse as she stood there in silence for a moment. "P-Please close your eyes? While I get your surprise."
Ren gave her a reassuring smile and nod as he closed his eyes tightly. He could faintly hear the sound of something rustling as he was curious to what Makoto had in mind for his surprise. Finally after what felt like several minutes, Makoto cleared her throat. "You can open them now."
He slowly opened his eyes and what stood before him made his throat seize up and his heart go haywire. Makoto removed her Buchimaru onesie and was now in her underwear. A new pair that showed off her body in perfect beauty. Ren could see distinct red designs in the black fabric. "A-Ann helped pick them out. They reminded me of you….and...I wanted tonight to be special for another reason."
Makoto slowly came over to Ren and sat down on his lap, facing him. He watched in shocked silence as Makoto reached behind herself and undid her bra. Ren's eyes nearly popped out of his head as his blush rivaled that of Makoto's. "W-what are you doing?" Was all he could ask as the inner man inside his head viciously yelled at him.
"We've been together for 2 years and we never did anything more than kissing. I'm finally ready to move on to something more. To be with you on a new level." Makoto said softly, covering herself a little as she bit the tip of her thumb. "I want my first time to be you."
Ren's brain was working overtime to process everything. He wanted her in this way so many times, but never said anything out of pure respect for her. Now that it was finally here, his brain didn't know what to do. His other brain, meanwhile, was screaming for a full charge.
"I want you to Makoto. More than anything else in this world." Ren finally said, placing his hand on Makoto's chin, turning her to look at him. The look in her eyes as she welled up, smiling softly as she threw her arms around Ren and kissed him deep, pressing her now bare chest against his.
Makoto pushed Ren back on the bed as she straddled his lap, running her hands up his stomach. She grabbed the hem of his shirt and began pushing it up. As Makoto began removing Ren's shirt, she leaned down and began kissing her way up his stomach and chest. Once his shirt was removed, Makoto quickly tossed it aside before burying her face in the nape of his neck, peppering it with kisses and light bites. Ren gasped at the forcefulness Makoto was showing, but Ren wasn't minding it one bit, in fact he was greatly enjoying it.
"Ren...touch me...please." She in a breathless whisper as she took Ren's hands and guided them to her chest. Ren's head nearly blew his top as he couldn't help but marvel at how soft she was and how her breast felt in his hands. He watched Makoto's reaction as she gasped and moaned herself, her face blushing more and more. She turned her attention now to his pants as she began unbuttoning them, slowly pulling the zipper down.
"Makoto…" He said grabbing her hand just as she was about to pull his pants down. "You sure about this? We don't have to if you don't want to." He said wanting to make sure she wasn't having second thoughts.
Makoto shook her head and quickly knocked his hand away from hers. "I want this. I want to feel you." She said reassuring him and herself as Ren placed his hand on her cheek as Makoto finished her job and removed Ren's pants, leaving him in his boxers. Makoto reached over to her nightstand and began digging in the drawer before pulling out a small square, the condom. "Better safe than sorry." She told Ren.
This is really happening….
Holding his breath, feeling his heart in his throat, he watched Makoto break down the last wall between them as she pulled his boxers down, leaving him bare for her. He could see the surprise in her eyes as this was certainly the first time she's seen someone naked like this, and he'd be in the same boat as her. Opening the small wrapper, Makoto slowly placed the latex ring around Ren. She looked up at him one more time.
"Ready?" She asked softly as Ren nodded, gulping a bit.
"Yes...I'm ready."
Makoto sat herself up, bending over just a bit as she pulled her panties down, joining Ren in the nude. She settled herself slightly over his lap as she lined herself up with him. With a deep breath and one final look at Ren, Makoto slowly lowered herself. The sudden feeling as Ren entered her caused the both to moan out loud. Makoto fell forward, hugging Ren tighter as her body shivered in pleasure as more and more of Ren pushed into her, meeting some resistance.
"Go ahead Ren." Makoto whispered as Ren nodded. He placed his hands on her hips, kissing her deeply as he pushed her alittle deeper, breaking through the wall as Makoto's whole body reacted. She grabbed and squeezed at Ren, tears slowly rolling down her cheeks. Ren placed a hand on her cheek, checking on her. "I'm fine. It doesn't hurt as much anymore." She said softly.
Sitting herself up, rubbing the tears from her face, she began to slowly move her hips. Ren couldn't help but watch in bewilderment at the beautiful woman on top of him. Her eyes half closed as soft little moans escaped her mouth. The moonlight coming through the window, hitting her in just the right way that almost illuminated her whole body with this heavenly glow. His hand roamed up her stomach and chest.
"Ren….yes…" Makoto gasped as her movements slowly picked up in pace. This feeling was brand new and something he never thought he would experience, now he never wanted to experience it with anyone besides Makoto. He didn't want this night to ever end.
Makoto leaned back down, tilting Ren's head to the side before she began kissing and sucking on the side of his neck, several spots of redness forming. She smirked to herself at her marking Ren as hers. Next she began nibbling on his ear. Ren couldn't help but let out a moan as Makoto smiled softly as she found a weak spot on Ren. She continued to chew on his ear, her hands combing up into his hair and grabbing handfuls of it, her own moans muffled by the chewing. "Does that feel good Ren?" She asked softly.
"Y-yes. It feels so good." He said, his breathing getting heavier as Makoto switches sides and begins chewing on his other ear, enjoying watching his reaction to it all. She wanted this night to be as good for him as it is for her. She could feel Ren's heart pounding against her chest as her fingernails dragged down the back of his head and neck. "Makoto….I'm getting close…" He breathed out.
"It's okay baby, I am too. Let's do it together okay?" She said sitting herself up, placing both her hands on Ren's chest. She began to bounce herself harder and harder, their moans getting louder as well. Soon it becomes too much for either of them as with one more thrust of her hips, Makoto's entire body seizes up and begins shaking as her moans become a never ending flood. Ren pulls her down and hugs her tightly as both of them hit the point of release, their bodies burning up against each other. The wave of pleasure washed over them both as they cling to each other tightly, not wanting to let go. Makoto is the first to move as she better sits herself on Ren, staring down into his eyes.
"How was it?" She asked softly, stroking his face, admiring him as she looked at the hickeys forming on the side of his neck.
"It was everything I dreamt it could be and more." He said pulling Makoto down as he buried his face in her neck this time, kissing and sucking on her as he left his own marks on her neck. Makoto giggled as she didn't stop him one bit.
"Oh Ren. You are just too much sometimes." She giggled out as she finally pushed him off her neck, pinning him back by his shoulders. "Next time, I promise to do some research. Make things even more exciting for us." She said giving Ren a seductive gaze, licking her lips for him. Ren grinned too, grabbing Makoto by the waist and rolling themselves over so that she was now on her back with him on top.
"I better hope so." He said, grinning as Makoto dragged her nails up and down Ren's back.
"Happy birthday Ren." Makoto said smiling as she leaned up and kissed Ren, who more than graciously returned it.
"Thank you baby. I love it." He teased for a moment. "I love you."
"I love you more." Makoto said pulling Ren down so that his head was resting against her chest. "Now let's get some sleep shall we?" She asked as she let out a yawn.
"I agree." Ren said yawning himself as he wrapped his arm under Makoto's back as Makoto let one hand rest on his waist and the other played with his hair softly. The two soon feel asleep in each other's arms, the only light being the touch of the moon.