You and Sam have been close friends, but you started developing feelings for him. During Sebastian's birthday, Abigail initiated a spin the bottle game where whoever it points to has to reveal his/her crush. Unfortunately, the bottle pointed at you; Abigail urged you to tell who your crush is, and you nervously looked at Sam. You don't want to ruin your friendship, so you decide to lie and say 'Alex.' Sam looked at you in disbelief because he thought all this time he thought you liked him back with all his antics. Sam tried to look alright throughout the party, hiding his broken heart whenever he talked to you.
Sebastian noticed this, and as his close friend, he pulled him away from the crowd and talked to him in private outside. "Dude, you should just tell her," Sebastian confronted Sam. "She likes someone else, Seb; what else can I do?" Sam slumped his shoulders while looking at the river. Sebastian offered him a cigarette in which he declined. After Sebastian puffed out a cloud of smoke, he managed to reply, "I don't believe her. I can see it in her eyes.", "What do you mean?" Sam curiously replied. "I saw her look at you for the longest time before managing to say who she likes. I can feel it in my bones that she's just lying." Sam rolled his eyes, still not believing Sebastian. "Look at it this way; even if she likes Alex, don't you want her to like you instead?" Sebastian looked at him with all seriousness. "Of course I do! I even invited her to our first concert, remember?" Sam exclaimed. "Then do your best to win her heart over Alex, tell her how you feel, and court her." With that, Sebastian puffed her last smoke and went back to the party.
The next day you received a letter from Sam asking you to meet him outside his house later that evening. You prepared immediately, wanting to impress Sam for your meetup later. After dark, you went to his house and saw him waiting there. He smiled excitedly at you, blushing at your form. 'Oh, how beautiful you look in that dress,' he thought. "Hi Y/N, I wanted to talk to you in private" Sam looked around to make sure no one else could eavesdrop. "Ok, s-sure," you answered, shivering a little from the cold evening breeze because of your thin short dress. "It's kinda cold out here. Let's sneak into my room," Sam offered, helping you sneak in through the window of his room. Once you both got into his room, Sam held your hand and pulled you close. "So um Y/N, we've been good friends for a while now, and I know I've been talking about nothing but the band always..." he trailed off while scratching the back of his neck. "But I don't want you to think that's all I'm interested in." Sam looked at you straight in the eyes, closing the distance between you two until both of your noses were touching. "What I mean to say is that I'm glad we've become close... Y/N Do you think of me as just a friend?" Sam said with his breath brushing across your lips.
But just as you were about to reply, you hear a knock from his door. "Sam? I'm coming in", his mom, Jodi, said. Sam began to panic and pushed you on his bed, "Quick hide!". You covered yourself with his thick blanket and prayed that his mom wouldn't go near. Sam reasoned with Jodi that he was exercising; that's why she heard some weird tumbling sounds, and with that, Jodi left, making Sam lock his room to be sure. You peeked out of the blanket, and when you saw that the coast was clear, you entirely removed it from you. Sam looked back at you, blushing at the sight of you on his bed, with your thin short dress, where he can almost see your undergarments. Sam began to approach you, stripping his jacket off and joining you on his bed. "Y/N?", he said, looking at you in the eyes before pulling you into a passionate kiss. He licked your lips to ask for entrance which you gladly gave, letting his tongue explore your mouth. You two made out for a while before finally pulling away to catch your breath. "I always knew there was something special between us..." Sam said while catching his breath. "But why did you answer 'Alex' back at the party?" he added. "Because I was afraid to lose you," you managed to say.
Sam pulled you in for another kiss, but this time he went on top of you, pinning you down with his hips, with his hands working on to strip you. Following his actions, you also worked on removing his shirt, revealing his hard-toned abs. Stroking it while kissing, Sam smirked and said, "Like it, babe?" You blush, trying to look away but gasped when Sam suddenly kissed your neck, immediately finding your sensitive spot. Once he found it, he bit it, leaving you a hickey, and whispered "Mine" in your ear. Fully naked in front of him, Sam can't help but look at your body, enjoying every part of it. He began kissing you from your neck to down to your chest, where he suckled and massaged your breast, earning more moans from you. He quickly shot his head to you, saying, "Shh... they might hear us", nodding in agreement; you tried to contain your moans as he continued suckling on your breasts. Gasping and panting stopped as you eventually let out another moan when his other hand found your wet entrance. Smirking on one of your breasts, he inserted two fingers, pumping it inside you. You bit your lip, trying your best to muffle your moans as he curled it inside you, hitting your G-spot.
His lips moved from your chest to your thighs, slowly nipping towards your entrance, where he pulled out his wet fingers, licking it clean. You looked at him, blushing, and held his head. He pried your legs open and inserted his tongue inside your hot core. You were moaning his name in the process and throwing your head back in pleasure. Sam hummed in amusement as he sucked all your juices and continued pleasing you with his tongue. "s-sam!" you arched your back, panting as you came to his mouth. He licked you off clean and climbed back up. "Are you ready, babe?" he said as he unzipped his pants, revealing his big throbbing member. Gulping and blushing at his size, you nodded, letting him lift your hips to angle his member to your entrance. You wrapped your legs around his waist, and he suddenly fully inserted his member inside you. Biting your knuckle, you prevent yourself from screaming his name and waking his whole house. He started pounding inside you, moaning your name. "Y-Y/N, fuck, you're so tight". He threw his head back in pleasure as he kept thrusting inside you.
You gripped the sheets beside you as he increased his speed, thrusting in you harder and deeper. You grind your hips in rhythm with his, moaning every time he hits your spot. "F-fuck Y/N, I think I'm gonna cum", Sam said as he gripped your hips tighter, "Me too," you managed to pant out. "S-sam!" you arched your back as you cum around his hard member while he spilled his hot seed inside you. He thrust a few more times, riding out his climax before pulling away with his cum dripping off you. Both of you are panting, looking at each other blushing. Sam laid beside you, pulling you into his arms. "Does this mean you like me and not Alex?" he asked again. You chuckled and booped his nose. "Of course, silly, also correction, I love you." He smiled and pecked you on your lips. "I love you, Y/N." Both of you drifted off to sleep until the morning.