Leo's 16
Don's 16 (three months younger than Leo)
Mikey's 16 (four months younger than Leo)
Raph's 15
Raph nuzzled Leo's beak affectionately, as they lay tangled together in Leo's bed and said huskily, his warm breath ghosting over Leo's neck, sending a thrill down Leo's spine, "I'm ready. Are ya?"
"You sure, Raph?" Leo said, staring into Raph's green eyes.
"I am. We've been together for four months. I'm more than ready. I want ya ta claim me, Leo. Now. I wanna be yers."
"What about the others? We agreed we'd only do things with them."
"I want my first time ta be with ya and I wanna be with ya primarily, Leo. Be yer mate, but we'll have fun with the others too. Do ya follow me? Fuck me. I can't wait any longer."
Raph parted his legs and looked at Leo expectantly. Leo smiled, and planted several kisses along Raph's collarbone, his neck, everywhere he could reach. Raph tilted his head to one side, allowing greater access to his neck. Leo swiped a long lick across it and nibbled it, biting gently, making Raph moan in anticipation. Then Leo licked all the way down Raph's plastron, to his inner thigh, stroking, caressing the emerald skin and whispering sweet nothings. Raph closed his eyes and moved his legs further apart. Leo opened the dresser and took out a bottle of lube. He squeezed some out onto his fingers and rubbed Raph's slit, prepping him. It wasn't long before Raph's semi-erect and leaking cock made its presence and Raph dropped down with a tremendous churr, making Leo chuckle. "You like that, huh, Raphie?" Leo said.
"Fuck me and stop talkin', Leo!"
"As you wish, my gorgeous lover."
Leo stuck two fingers inside of Raph's hole, widening him and preparing him for his girth. His fingers slid deeper inside and hit Raph's prostate, making Raph churr in ecstasy and causing his cock to engorge, veins pulsing; his cock begging for attention. Leo kissed it tenderly, removed his fingers and said, "I'm going in. You sure you're ready, Raphie?"
"Fuck me!"
Leo rubbed his own slit and soon dropped down with a loud churr. Then he lined his cock up at Raph's entrance and thrust slowly inside of him. Raph grunted at the sudden intrusion, hooked one leg around Leo's waist and started moving his hips in rhythm with Leo, as he started to thrust in and out. Raph arched his back, as Leo pushed in harder and faster, aiming for Raph's sweet spot. Leo's so damn hard and fuck, this is amazin', Raph thought. This is what love is. Leo licked Raph's neck and bit it hard, leaving a large red mark. "You're mine, Raphie. Mine and I'm going to love you forever."
"Fuck me faster," Raph ordered. "Fuck me hard! I want ya so badly." He wrapped his other leg around Leo's waist and said, "Damn it. Faster, Leo! Fuck!"
Leo sped up; faster and more passionate with each thrust and he soon hit Raph's prostrate, making the hothead churr and close his eyes in bliss. This is everythin' I thought my first time would be, Raph thought. Passionate, fierce. Oh, fuck! I'm gonna…"Leo, I'm gonna come," Raph yelled, letting out a deep rumble, as he went over the edge, his nails raking down Leo's back. "Nghh!"
Leo came a minute later, shooting hot, ropey, streams of come into Raph, filling him up with his seed.
Pulling out, Leo said breathlessly, "That was frigging awesome, Raphie."
"It was," Raph said, panting.
"Did I hurt you?"
"A little, but I'll get used ta it. I love ya inside of me, Leo. Ya feel so right bein' in me."
"And I thought you were an alpha," Leo teased, and nipped at Raph's collarbone. "But you like being controlled."
"Only by ya. I'd never let Don or Mikey top me. That feels so good, Leo. Ah, Leo," Raph said, groaning. "Love that," Raph added. "Ya know how ta turn me on. And yer so fuckin' sexy. I could bang ya all day. I love ya, ya know that? I love ya."
"I love you too, Raphie," Leo said, lying down and pulling Raph close to him.
"Can't you dudes keep it down?" Mikey yelled, opening the door and entering the bedroom, followed by Don. "Me and Don are trying to sleep."
"Join us, Mikey and Don," Raph said, sitting up and looking at Mikey hungrily, taking in his sea green body, his toned muscles and blue eyes. "Me and Leo just finished, but we're always up for another round. And guess what? I pounded Leo earlier today and he just did me now. We're no longer virgins. Just like ya and Don."
"You said your first time would be with me, Raphie," Mikey said sulkily.
"Well, it wasn't, Mikey. I wanted it ta be with Leo. Either deal with it or this group thing ain't gonna happen. I wouldn't be too upset if it didn't, but I know ya would. Ya want me and ya want Leo."
"You guys promised that we'd only have sex as a foursome and not pair off."
"Ya guys broke that deal when ya fucked, so why couldn't we?" Raph snapped. "That's it. I don't wanna do the foursome thing anymore. I only want Leo."
"No, I'm sorry, Raphie. I'm wrong. You're right, bro. Don and I have no reason to feel annoyed that you and Leo went ahead and had sex. I want the foursome. I want to be with all of my brothers."
"Prove yer sorry," Raph said, looking at Leo for permission.
"Raph and I are mates, Mikey," Leo said. "And in love, but we also want to be with you and Don, Mikey. As long as you two understand that, don't try to come between us and there's never any jealousy, we'll be fine with the foursome thing."
"Don and I are mates, bro, so I get it. I don't want Raph as my mate, Leo. I just want to fuck him and I was angry, because I wanted to be the one who got to fuck him first. That's all. I'm truly sorry. Can we still have the foursome thing?"
"All right."
"I feel the same way, Leo," Don said. "I just want to bang you and Raph, but my heart belongs to Mikey."
"How shall we start?"
"Raph get on the floor doggystyle and we'll begin."
"I only listen ta Leo," Raph said firmly. "And I ain't bottomin' for anyone else. Only him."
"That's not fair, Raph," Mikey growled. "You promised you would when you were no longer pure."
"I don't wanna. I ain't a submissive like Don and ya can't make me be one. I'll suck ya, but I ain't gonna let ya fuck me."
"Fine," Mikey said, while inwardly thinking, I will have my shot and dominate him. "I'll go doggystyle. You suck me, Leo. Don, you can enter from behind. Raphie, you can watch."
"Got it," Leo and Don said in unison. They all stroked each other's cocks and churred loudly, as they dropped down. Then Leo placed his cock in Mikey's mouth, while Don lined his cock up with Mikey's entrance. Mikey sucked Leo's girth to the root and Don thrust inside. The double penetration soon had Mikey climaxing and yelling out Don's name. Leo and Don both came soon after, shooting their essence into Mikey and panting heavily, as they pulled out.
Raph had watched the unfolding scene with glazed eyes, and, turned on, he'd stroked his slit until he dropped down with a tremendous churr. He continued stroking until his ten inch cock was fully engorged and yearning for more attention. Unable to take his eyes off of his brothers, Raph rubbed his cock until waves of pleasure coursed through his body and he climaxed with a loud churr that echoed off of the sewer wars. Hot jets of his essence painted his plastron and the floor. Maybe it would be nice ta have two guys make love ta me at the same time, Raph thought. It looks pretty hot and fun. I'm gonna try it.
"Hey," Raph said. "I changed my mind. I'd like ta try bottomin'. Might be fun."
"Thought you might," Mikey said, and grinned. "You'll love it, Raph. Hey, what's that smell? Is it you, Raphie?" Mikey asked, going to Raph's side and sniffing him. "You smell so amazing."
"Raph's in heat, Mikey," Leo said. "It's pheromones he's releasing and he does. He smells incredible. I love his scent."
"Same here. Wow. You're driving me nuts, Raphie. Need you, dude."
"Then come and get me," Raph purred, and dropped to his fours. Grinning, Mikey lined his cock up with Raph's entrance, while Don thrust his member into Raph's mouth.
"Suck me good, Raph," Don ordered.
Raph sucked Don hungrily and deep throated him, while Mikey pounded into him. The double penetration feels friggin' awesome, Raph thought. I always wanna do it. "Nggh!" Raph mumbled, as he climaxed and went over the edge. Mikey and Don came soon after, ejecting streams of come into Raph's ass and mouth respectively. Leo had watched with hooded eyes and thought that he'd also like to try it sometime. "That was hot," Raph said, panting.
"We're not done yet, Raph," Don said, lifting Raph up and carrying him to the bed. At six foot four, Don towered over his five foot brother. "I'm going to make you feel so good. And I know you want me," Don added, kissing his brother on the lips.
"Want ya," Raph said, turned on. "I didn't want ta bottom before, but it's amazin'. I wanna have ya. All of ya buried deep inside of me."
"You'll get that, Raphie," Don said, parting Raph's legs and lining his cock up with Raph's entrance. Leo's your mate, but we'll all fuck you."
"Be careful with him, Don," Leo said. "I don't want him hurt."
'He'll be fine. Relax, Raphie." Don thrust into Raph and started pounding away, hitting his prostrate and making Raph churr, as wave after wave of pleasure hit him. I like it, Raph thought. Fuck. I love it. I have Leo as my mate and Don and Mikey wanna make me happy too. I'm lucky. Oh, Fuck.
"I'm gonna come!" Raph shouted. "Fuck!"
Raph climaxed and so did Don, the latter, shooting his seed deep inside of Raph. Pulling out, a panting Don kissed Raph tenderly on the mouth and said, "Thank you, Raphie."
"Yer welcome. Who's next?" Raph asked, feeling bold and ready for another round. Mutant turtles recovered fast.
"Me," Mikey said, bending down and kissing Raph deeply. The green eyed turtle returned the kiss and rubbed at Mikey's slit until his cock made its presence. "Want ya in me, Mikey," Raph husked.
"Wow. You've become quite the slut, bro."
Raph looked at Leo and said, "Leo, we're mates, but I've discovered that I love bein' dominated by all of ya and I wanna have ya all in me every day. Is that okay?"
"Yes," Leo said. "Because although I love you, I also want to sleep with Don and Mikey."
"Fuck me, Mikey," Raph shouted. "Now." Mikey did as he was told and slammed his rod into Raph, thrusting in and out, making Raph scream in ecstasy.
The brothers all took their turns with Raph that evening and when they were done, they collapsed into a large turtle pile on the bed, snuggled close. Raph rubbed his tummy and thought, I loved bein' dominated by all of my bros, their massive cocks fillin' me up and shootin' their seed inside of me. Initially, I just wanted Leo and I didn't want ta bottom for anyone else, but after seein' how good it was for Mikey, I had ta do it and if Leo's infertile, there's a good chance the others won't be. It's matin' season, which made me extra horny. I was fuckin' for breedin' purposes, as well as showin' Leo my love, but it's only physical attraction between me and my other bros. At least on my part. Not romantic love. They don't know that yet. And I'm ready ta have babies. I've wanted them ever since I started layin' eggs two years ago. They were unfertilized and duds, but now, now that I have my brothers fuckin' me, there are gonna be actual babies and my brothers are gonna be daddies. They're gonna be so happy and so will I, because I'm finally gonna be a mommy.