Sweet Blue

Summary - For the three-part prompt: Blueberry + Black + Bliss on Tumblr by a lovely anon

Lily barreled down the stairs, massive package in hand, grin rampant over lips as excitement buzzed like a second skin around her.

The Gryffindor Common Room, bereft of occupants save for a few stragglers who'd decided to forgo some precious Sunday lie-in, flew by her periphery without garnering so much as an acknowledging scan as she skipped towards the Boys' staircase. A foot had barely fallen onto the first step when she was halted unceremoniously by an amused call of her name.

"Oi, Evans!" his voice rang out, and she whipped her head around to spot a shock of black hair, smiling hazel eyes, lazy smirk. The sight of him, burrowed inside an armchair, instantly sent the thrum beneath her ribcage stuttering. "Off to accost some poor bloke this early in the morning? At least wait for the sun to rise fully, would you? Some of us need more time to collect our wit."

She narrowed her eyes, thoughts clattering as she debated her next course of action. Futile as the pretence that she'd been on a path to accost someone who was not the boy in front of her was, it only took Lily another half-second to make the decision, step away from the staircase, and towards him. James's gaze brightened infinitesimally, evidently pleased by the deviation.

"Don't club in everyone else with yourself, Potter," she remarked happily, rounding the couch to plop down on its unbelievable cushiness. "Not everyone's as slow as you."

He reached out one of those unfairly long arms to bridge the space between them and flick her nose. Lily held back the widening grin. "And there's that cheek. Even at six in the morning."

Rather than blush tellingly at the fondness he directed at her, she nodded at the pile of Transfiguration notes and books around him. "What's this? James Potter studying on a Sunday? Am I dreaming?"

"Afraid of a little competition?" he threw back, fire glinting off glasses. "Don't worry, Evans, you'll still beat me in Charms and Potions."

For a second, the golden glaze of the sun hitting his hair from the window behind stole the words from her tongue, the breath from her lungs. Prompted by James's prolonged stare, a warmth blossomed on her cheeks, bringing back some sense. "I'd beat you in DADA too."

"Ha! You can dream."

"I don't make it a habit to dream about you, Potter."

"That makes one of us," he said, completely unabashed.

Lily fairly choked on that honesty, muscles tightening near her clavicle with strange breathlessness. "You dream about yourself? Takes the narcissism to new heights."

James cocked a brow, but let her deliberate misunderstanding of the phrase slide. "Technically, everyone dreams about themselves."

"Ugh, it's too early for this," she groaned, sliding her legs into a fold on the couch, fluffy warm pyjamas keeping the December chill at bay. "I was going to your dormitory for a purpose, you know?"

James instantly leaned forward, pleased and making no effort to hide it. "You were coming to see me?"

"To see all of you," she mumbled like a coward. Perhaps there was also some lie interlaced in there, because he'd certainly been the reason she'd felt an extra jauntiness during her excursion. Not willing to impart that particular knowledge, Lily held out the package to him. "Open it."

Curiosity creased his brows, smile never waning. "What's this?"

"Open it, you impatient tosser."

James grumbled something about 'mean harpies posing as Head Girls' and 'no appreciation for those of curious minds' while carefully unwrapping the package, all of which Lily soundly ignored in favour of vibrating with anticipation. When the last of the brown wrapping paper fell away, she squealed at the pink box that was revealed, full with a glossy sheen and pretty prints and designs; exactly the way she remembered it.

James looked at her, back at the box, then at her again. Eventually, amusement had his lips pinching together. "If I don't find at least two dragon eggs inside this, I'll be disappointed."

"It's something even better, I promise!" She wiggled her palms, urging him to open the box.

When he finally popped open the lid, Lily found herself under the very real threat of toppling to the floor, so far had she leaned forward. Eager green eyes spotted the dozen or so confectionaries that sat cheerily inside, miraculously undisturbed during their journey across England. "They're blueberry muffins!" she informed giddily. "I requested mum to send across some from this bakery in my hometown."

James's smile softened as he looked inside the box, so much so that when he turned his eyes to her again, the gold in them had melted into a warm honey. "You do get blueberry muffins here too, you know," he said kindly, voice fond.

"I know, but those are just imposters. These are the real deal. Take a bite, go on. I can bet you'll be kissing my feet in thanks."

"Do I have to kiss your feet? Can't it be something else?"

Her heart bloated dangerously. "James."

"Only kidding," he chuckled, reaching inside dutifully and picking out a muffin. At her incessantly exaggerated prompting, he made a show of rolling his eyes before finally biting into the spongey cake. It was bizarre, but Lily could swear she felt flavours blue and sweet burst on her own tongue when James moaned aloud, eyes scrunched in bliss as he chewed.

"It's good, isn't it?"

"What the fuck," he whispered in disbelief after swallowing, staring down at the remaining muffin as if it had personally offended him by not being available before. "What the actual fuck?"

"I told you!" she crowed, smirking openly without a hint of modesty. "Isn't it just the best thing you've ever tasted?"

"Merlin, I might cry." He blinked, grinning at her. "Give me those feet, Evans."

Lily's smirk dimmed, veins strangely suffused with molten courage instead of blood as she reached forward and plucked the box from James's lap, setting it aside on the table. The distressed cry he let out died abruptly when she looked at him again, face serious.

"Will my lips do?"

James froze, eyes wide, muffin forgotten in hand. "Lily," he warned, voice low. "Don't. Not if you're still thinking—not if you're not sure."

Her fingers found his free hand, ran over the warm palm breezily. "I'm sure," she confessed, lashes fluttering as she stared at his Quidditch-given calluses. "I'm sorry it's taken me so long, but—I'm sure now."

"Look at me."

She did.

James's eyes were aflame, even as his breath remained tempered. "Tell me what you want."

"I want—" She bit her lip. "I want you to kiss me. I want to eat that muffin, and then I want you to take me to Hogsmeade next weekend."

A beat passed. And then she found his hand snaking around her wrist, tugging her forward until she sloppily stumbled over to his armchair and right into his recently vacated lap. Distantly, she registered that they had an audience—however meagre—but she'd truly never cared less.

"Good plan," James whispered, tossing the rest of the muffin into the box. Lily didn't even feel inclined to chastise him for messing up the presentation, because he was gripping her waist the next second, pulling her closer until his nose brushed hers tenderly. "Always the perfect answer, Miss Evans."

"Shut up," Lily laughed, cradling his head, pulling him forward.

Their lips met, mouths opened, and blue and sweet burst on her tongue.