Disclaimer – I do not own Fairy Tail
*Rated M for Mature
Summary: There are good dreams, there are bad dreams, and then there are dreams that seem so real that it makes you paranoid and you freak out whenever something reminds you of that dream! Gray and Natsu come to know what that means.
When Good Dreams Go Bad
"Gray," Natsu panted breathlessly as the ice mage above him licked and sucked at his collarbone. "Hurry up. I can't hold on much longer. I need you in me now!" Natsu emphasized his point by grinding his exposed erection into Gray's.
The ice mage just chuckled and ground back, eliciting a delightful moan from his lover. "Are you that desperate to try out that new lube you bought?" he smirked devilishly.
"Stop teasing, and get in me already!" Natsu both whined and growled.
Gray would have given in if he hadn't wanted to tease the dragon-slayer just a little bit more. Raising his right hand, he brought his fingers to Natsu's lips, which he immediately pulled into his hot mouth. Gray groaned at Natsu's sucking technique as he lathered his fingers with his gifted tongue.
When the ice mage drew his fingers away, Natsu automatically spread his legs even wider, granting the ice mage easier access.
Pushing his first finger inside, Natsu instantly began bucking his hips, driving himself down on the narrow appendage. Adding a second finger, Gray began scissoring sensually inside Natsu, making him writhe and pant on the bed in the most erotic way.
"Just one more, Natsu. Then we get to the good part," Gray stated as Natsu started making small whimpering sounds. How could one person be so innocent and vulnerable, yet so sexy and erotic at the same time?
Natsu cried out in pleasure when he felt Gray add his third finger. As he thrust his fingers in and out, the dragon-slayer felt nothing but pleasure, his sweet spot being hit every single time.
And suddenly, the fulfillment was gone.
"Gray?" Natsu called out breathlessly. The loss of the fingers made him feel empty.
"I can't stand it when you act so cute and hot at the same time. So you better brace yourself, because this is going to be quick," stated Gray huskily, his eyes taking on a hungry expression.
Natsu gulped when the ice mage quickly lathered himself with the lube. He yelped when Gray quickly thrust into him, burying himself to the hilt. They stayed that way for a moment, trying to steady their breathing before Gray began their lovemaking. The ice mage pulled out and—
"Stop!" Natsu screamed. Gray immediately stopped, confused by the pained expression on Natsu's face.
"Natsu?" he asked softly.
"Don't move. It hurt when you pulled." Natsu had tears forming in his eyes.
"Hurt when I pulled?" Gray echoed. That didn't sound right. They'd had sex plenty of times before, and Natsu had never reacted this way. They weren't doing anything different. Sure, they got the new lube, but—
Gray quickly turned his head and carefully reached for the discarded bottle of lube. After he read the label, his roar could be heard throughout the entire apartment.
"YOU IDIOT! THIS ISN'T SUPER LUBE! IT'S SUPER GLUE!"
That meant…he was stuck inside Natsu!
By this time, Natsu was crying. One, he was in pain whenever Gray moved; two, he felt like the stupidest person on the planet; three, he was embarrassed; and four, he was afraid that Gray would hate him.
The ice mage noticed his lover's tears, and although he was on the brink of going insane due to his anger, the pain etched on Natsu's face quelled his rage.
Leaning down as gently as he could, he kissed Natsu's tears away, trying to calm him down. All he received was a wince and a sob. "Shh, Natsu. I'm not mad at you. Calm down. We'll get out of this."
"How?"
Gray took a deep breath and said as calmly as he could, "On the count of three, I'm going to pull out as fast as I can, okay?"
"What?" Natsu screamed. "No!"
"Natsu, you have to trust me. Everything's going to be okay."
Natsu nodded, trembling slightly.
"Okay, Natsu. One…two…THREE—"
"AAAAHHHHHH!"
Both Gray and Natsu shot up from their bed, shaking and breathing uncontrollably.
After a few moments of silence, they turned and looked at each other. Gray tentatively reached down as if to protect his groin while Natsu pulled his knees to his chest.
"You would do something that stupid," Gray said, finally breaking the awkward silence.
"What are you talking about?" Natsu stammered in response.
"Replacing our lube with super glue," he spat.
"Wait! You had that dream, too? You were stuck inside me, and you said you were gonna pull out and—"
"I know!" Gray snapped, putting the pillow over his crotch. If that ever really happened, that would have hurt like hell. For the both of them!
"But how did we have the same dream?"
Gray groaned and flopped back down onto the bed. "No more sweets and stupid movies before bed. Ever again!"
Natsu swallowed hard. "Okay," he replied meekly, but then a smirk grew on his face. "Hey, Gray. You wanna try the new lube I got?"
Gray turned and faced him, an evil expression on his face. "You want to try the new leash and collar I got?"
Natsu tried to scramble out of the bed, but his legs got caught in the sheets, which gave Gray the opportunity he needed to catch his wriggling lover.
"Let's have you put them on and we'll try them out." Gray suppressed his laughter when he saw Natsu's eyes widen to the size of dinner plates. Hey, it was Natsu's fault they'd had that nightmare anyway, so he could at least punish him in the most pleasurable way possible.
"Don't you dare put that on me! No! NOOOOO!"
End